3 ms·
I think there's some truth to that, though. As a former video game addict, I look back on my time spent gaming as largely a waste. Most of it was a compulsion,
by hombre_fatal 8y ago
I think there's some truth to that, though.
As a former video game addict, I look back on my time spent gaming as largely a waste. Most of it was a compulsion, like staying up until 4am re-queuing in Dota. Or grinding some armor piece.
But I don't look back with regret on any of my time spent reading. I think most people here know what I'm talking about. Why is that?
I can think of a few guesses. Books aren't in the same category of quick dopamine releases as most (not all) games. There's an element of imagination and mental world construction in the book with even the cheapest entertainment. You're exposed to different interpretations of the world, possibly integrating the thoughts of others against your own. It also helped me write and spell.
I'd certainly categorically rank books higher than games if I had to. Though I know if you told this to my 14-year-old self, I would've made you think I only played MathBlaster and games from The Learning Company all day. "What, you think learning is bad?!"
I'm reminded of when I was at my friend's house when he kicked his son off Youtube to go outside. He thought it was the most unfair thing in the world, happy to let you know how many good educational videos there were on Youtube even though he'd just done a four hour binge of screaming Minecraft vids.
I chuckled and thought of myself at about that age. At one point I spited my mother by bringing paper and pencils outside to draw instead of playing in the street. That'll show her! Well, I now have a drawing hobby that I still practice weekly in my 30s. :)
- cortesoft 8y agoI think the same arguments you make for books could be made for video games (especially ones like minecraft): they require imagination and exposure to different interpretations of the world. My mom also used to tell me to get off the computer and go outside, while I wanted to stay inside and mess around with the computer. 25 years later, I use those self taught computer programming skills to make a good living as a software developer. I think the point is that it is impossible to know which 'boredom' activities will lead to creativity.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- hombre_fatal 8y agoSure, I remember thinking it was super unfair that I was kicked off the computer even though I was reading content on webdev forums. And I can certainly tell you some positive experiences that were had from making friends with guild members in World of Warcraft or building content in MUDs. If you, as a parent, understand the difference between four hours of an iPad F2P game vs four hours of interacting with friends in Minecraft with voice-chat, you're surely in a good position to make informed decisions here instead of the frustrating "computer=bad" that a lot of kids have to deal with. I'm not yet a parent, but I can sympathize with the idea that you want to see your kids develop well-rounded interests. You see your kid on computers and phones all day (just like adults) and don't necessarily have any insight into how they are actually spending that time (especially on their phone). At which point, it might be a relief when they pick up a book for an hour or two.
- IdiocyInAction 8y agoI count reading entertainment-focused books in the same category as games personally. At the end of the day, it's usually ecsapism. Good point with learning to read and spell though, that's a plus books have over TV and games, especially for kids.
- cortesoft 8y agoMy division is between 'consumptive' activities and 'productive' activities... are you passively absorbing something someone else created or are you creating something yourself? You need a balance of the two to have a healthy life.
- deltron3030 8y agoMy theory is that what matters is the level of anticipation as a skill, or the distance between action and reaction that you're aware of. If you're impulsive like a kid, this distance has to be short, so you're either obedient to your parents and do what's good for you long term, or you're screwed if nobody cares. But as an adult you can actually understand how things relate, like a mental timeline, how the things you're doing now and your decisions might play out at a later stage.
- smacktoward 8y agoI dunno, I think there are (or can be, anyway) good games and bad games, and good books and bad books. I remember playing many hours of Sid Meier's Pirates! when I was a kid, for instance, and then my history teacher being amazed at how much I actual history I'd learned about the 17th century Caribbean. And I've read tons of pulp novels that weren't enriching in any way, they were just fun to read, empty mental calories for me in the same way it sounds like Dota was for you. I feel like it's more fruitful to ask what makes good games and books good and bad games and books bad than it is to put all books in the "good" pile and all games in the "bad" one.
- solipsism 8y agoI don't look back with regret on any of my time spent reading. I think most people here know what I'm talking about. Why is that? Easy one. It's because this is how society teaches you to feel. You grew up in a world where schools tell you read anything you can get your hands on. They have book fairs, summer reading contests, entire libraries full of both nonfiction and fiction. It's drilled into your from an early age how valuable reading is. If society indoctrinated you to feel that way about video games, that's how you'd feel. There was a time when they only books considered worthwhile were nonfiction (and maybe the Bible). If a teacher caught you with a mystery or romance book, you'd be spanked in front of the class. In those days you'd feel guilty for spending an entire day reading Jane Eyre.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kurtisc 8y agoHaven't books dripping with philosophy also always been considered appropriate? But I agree. Just look at an airport book shop's best sellers: is anyone really getting anything enlightening out of a trite mystery book that they don't get from TV? We (or at least I) feel some guilt for not having read classics and then attribute the same feeling to any sort of reading. Provided it's on a dead tree. I've spent ages reading A Song of Ice and Fire, ultimately that is just the same as time wasted on the internet or TV if what I'm valuing is time spent on self improvement. Even reading a manpage is more valuable.
- coryrc 8y agoIt's whether there's a story line or not; playing Mass Effect is going to give you a book-like experience while DotA is just a time filler.
- edanm 8y agoAs is chess, and yet most people don't seem to have a problem with kids playing a lot of chess, and encourage them to go to chess clubs and compete in it.
- ThalesX 8y agoIt is a personal belief, coming from someone who played a lot of DotA2 and not as much chess. I think there’s more value to cold calculated strategies in a simple ruleset than to spur of the moment reactions in a dynamic environment. Then again, I was never a good DotA2 player. Maybe there’s an element I missed that’s closer to chess.