3 ms·
Overlapping functionality for sure. I think the primary difference is that there's not stock MES built into something like kepware, which keeps a large number o
by softwaremoat 8y ago
Overlapping functionality for sure. I think the primary difference is that there's not stock MES built into something like kepware, which keeps a large number of smaller manufacturers from using it. An API on its own is useless to them. OPC (UA) is one of the protocols we offer as an endpoint, but to be honest I think OPC (again, UA) is too complex for most use cases. It's a good protocol, but there's not enough tooling built up around it yet, and it's very much geared toward large enterprise. Not to mention the saga of legal issues it just escaped from. We also offer an HTTP API which uses swagger and swagger UI for documentation and testing, and normalize data across machine types before storing it in a database. This allows a company to grow from our opinionated MES into their own customized system as they grow. Additionally, we offer two way integrations with ERP systems. There are some other common interconnectivity applications required by most of the manufacturers we work with (we've been doing services for a long time and have 1000+ active service customers). These are not commonly covered by OPC servers, but are covered within our software.
- maxbaines 8y agoI'm reading this with some interest, as this is what my company and I do too! http://cncdata.co.uk http://cncdata.co.uk what you have written here is almost scary like reading my own words. To answer your original post, my opinion is in Industry & digital factory, for it to succeed we must look to whats come before in software. It's inevitable long term that protecting the unique knowledge we have is not the model of success for the industry, hasn't it always been this way? Sure we can make good money but overall does industry win? We're about to open source everything we do, that's a Web API for Machine Data, MES, Quality systems and all of our Machine connectors, OPC/UA and Propriety. check out http://openindustry.org http://openindustry.org
- kevinherron 8y agoI’ll keep an eye on openindustry.org. I’m the author and maintainer of an open source OPC UA stack/SDK.