3 ms·
In the Bay Area, when they added the ability to pay a toll to use the HOV lane, and also extended the HOV lane hours to end at 10AM instead of 9AM, it immediate
by hedora 8y ago
In the Bay Area, when they added the ability to pay a toll to use the HOV lane, and also extended the HOV lane hours to end at 10AM instead of 9AM, it immediately added 30-45 minutes to the 880 -> 237 commute from East Bay.
Extending congestion hours by lowering road throughput is counterproductive, so saying “it smoothed congestion” is applying the wrong metric.
At this point in time, we can measure door-to-door time of commuters, and also the number of trips per hour. Instead traffic engineers use metrics that seem to be designed by NIMBY’s that want to increase the cost of commuting into high property value areas.
The bus lanes you propose are likely to have the same problem.
Since you have the ability to improve the success criteria for transit projects, please consider using better metrics.
- shereadsthenews 8y agoI don't think that is a very good example because that particular "HOV" lane is 100% Teslas with a single occupant, and because the HOV lane ends abruptly in the middle of 237 before anyone exits. The real lesson of these projects is that the EV sticker program was a failure and the cost to drive down 237 at rush hour should have been $50 instead of whatever it is.
- hedora 8y agoIt’s not 100% Tesla’s. There are also parents with children and fleet vehicles. Those latter two categories are already as low occupancy as they can be. I suspect they’re representative of HOV users in other states. Simply eliminating that HOV lane would probably improve the commute though. There’s data from a UC Berkeley study that more or less proves it.
- jedberg 8y agoI've been saying for years that only licensed drivers should count for the carpool lane. I have kids, but I'm not eliminating any cars by carpooling with them.
- Robotbeat 8y agoNo, but you are reducing the impact on other transportation systems. The killer app for personal cars is families. And families have enormous positive long-term externalities for the human race for obvious reasons. And your proposed system doesn’t make sense. It’d encourage people with no need for driving to get their driver’s license and punish others who couldn’t pass based on age and disability.
- rdiddly 8y agoImproving your commute by car isn't the goal. The goal is to get you to stop doing it, or bear your share of the real costs for a change.
- hedora 8y agoIf the goal is to prevent people from commuting by car then we should just tear up or barricade all the roads. No need to invest in public transit, since that’s not part of the goal. From what I can tell, this is the actual policy the SF area has been implementing for the last decade. I’d think a better goal is to minimize the average time and environmental impact of commutes, while maximizing the number of people that can use the transit system to commute (including cars, bikes, busses, trains, etc).
- rdiddly 8y agoWow I never thought of that! Here I thought barricading the roads would solve everything! But you're right, people could actually still get where they're going but use bikes, buses, trains etc.