4 ms·
Are you sure you can't get fined or detained or whatever for not showing ID? Cops would find that really really suspicious. I thought you were legally obliged t
by johnisgood 8y ago
Are you sure you can't get fined or detained or whatever for not showing ID? Cops would find that really really suspicious. I thought you were legally obliged to show ID when asked anyway, at least in the UK. Is it not the case? I would say that the act of not showing ID would be "reasonable suspicion" by itself. Maybe not, but curious how it plays out in practice, and what the law has to say about it.
- robjan 8y agoThere is no national ID card in the UK so it would be impossible to enforce. There is no law saying you have to produce ID on request and "reasonable suspicion" only applies to a specific crime. The police can't just say that they have "reasonable suspicion" that you are committing an unspecified crime.
- johnisgood 8y agoDoes "reasonable suspicion" imply an unspecified crime? Does it have to be the case? Suspicion doesn't necessarily mean that it is the case, so as long as they can come up with reasons, it's fine, and they don't need to be correct, or at least they won't get "punished" for being incorrect. Is it wrong? I am just trying to gather more information. :D Hmm, how do you generally prove identity in the UK?[1] [1] Actually this is something I could easily look up on the Internet, sorry. I don't mean to waste your time.
- robjan 8y agoBasically the police can stop you if they have "reasonable suspicion of committing crime x" and they have to tell you which crime they suspect you of and why. To prove who we are we can use a driving license or passport, if we have one. But there are many people with neither. In that case it's quite complex and usually requires a trustworthy person (doctor, lawyer, chartered engineer) who knows you well to confirm your identity.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoReasonable suspicion that you are breaking the law, or are about to break the law. They may be required to justify their grounds, i.e. what they suspect you of and why. They have been known to simply ignore those requests for why. e.g. I suspect you of going equipped to commit burglary due to your stripey jumper, crowbar and bag with "swag" printed on it. Proving ID is usually done via passport or driving licence. If you don't have those producing a couple from bank statement, utility bill or council tax bill is usually enough. I'm old enough to have got bank account without any requirement for ID at all. Yes, that means it can be a chain of circumstantial evidence rather than proof.
- acct1771 8y agoHow does what you're saying here about UK law being respected jive with the details presented in this story? https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/facial-recognition-cameras-technology-london-trial-met-police-face-cover-man-fined-a8756936.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/facial-recogniti...
- codedokode 8y agoIt is very interesting, but how can people without an ID card vote, open a bank account or buy a ticket for a plane? How are they identified then? I guess there must be some equivalent of ID anyway. At least in Russia you need an internal passport even to exchange the currency if the amount exceeds $611 (which is great because earlier the threshold was about $250).
- eesmith 8y agoSomehow people managed to vote and have bank accounts before ID cards were common. The UK wants a National Insurance number to register to vote. https://www.gov.uk/register-to-vote https://www.gov.uk/register-to-vote UK residents are sent a National Insurance number automatically just before their 16th birthday. https://www.gov.uk/apply-national-insurance-number https://www.gov.uk/apply-national-insurance-number Pulling up an arbitrary UK bank, https://www.tsb.co.uk/current-accounts/faqs/identity/ https://www.tsb.co.uk/current-accounts/faqs/identity/ shows many options to establish identity, including ones that don't require an identification card. Those under 18, for example, can use a National Insurance card or letter. I don't know what domestic flights are like in the UK. From what I can tell, it's left to the airlines. Most (? all?) require some sort of id, and different airlines accept different forms. For example, FlyBe allows "Council issued bus pass" and "NUS card (National Union of Students)" and "Company ID card of nationally recognised company" - https://www.flybe.com/check-in/id-requirements https://www.flybe.com/check-in/id-requirements . In some countries (I'm thinking Australia, based on a podcast I listened to from a couple of years ago), domestic check-in is all automated and does not always require an id check. https://www.jetstar.com/au/en/help/articles/travel-identification-domestic-flights-within-australia-and-new-zealand https://www.jetstar.com/au/en/help/articles/travel-identific... says "If you’re travelling with checked baggage on a domestic flight in New Zealand, you must provide ID." "Accepted ID types" include "Original or certified copy of a birth certificate", so "ID" is pretty broad. Something like 17 states in the US don't require any form of id to vote - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voter_ID_laws_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voter_ID_laws_in_the_United_St... - so this isn't unique to the UK. To point out, voter impersonation - the sort of fraud which ID cards might solve - are very rare. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voter_impersonation_(United_States) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voter_impersonation_(United_St... . The vote is private, so if there was an organized system it's difficult to verify that the vote actually went the correct way. It requires a lot of people in order to sway an election, and that sort of organization has a higher chance of being detected. The list of people who voted is public, so it's also possible to track down if they actually exist, and there's the risk that a impersonator will try to impersonate someone who actually voted. If it's important to know who someone is, then it can sometimes be solve by using a chain of trust. For example, the bank might require that a current account holder in good standing be willing to vouch for me, even if I have no id. Or, I might deposit a lot of money but have limited abilities until the bank trust me more. Regarding the UK, see also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opinion_polls_on_the_British_national_identity_card https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opinion_polls_on_the_British_n... .
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoAs I understand it, and I am not a lawyer, you don't have any obligation to identify yourself unless you are arrested. If you get stopped in a vehicle, police may ask for your driving licence. If you don't have it you're issued a "producer" which requires you to produce your licence at a police station within 7 days. This only applies to traffic stops.
- johnisgood 8y agoI see. I hope it works out well in practice too, but I always show ID when asked, as a "just in case" scenario. I don't live in the UK though. If I were to live in the UK, and the cops asked me to do something, I would probably do as asked because I don't want any trouble or surprises! :D
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoI've never carried ID, nor driving licence. The few times I've been stopped it was never an issue, even the morning after an IRA bombing as I was on my way to work. In traffic stops or getting booked for speeding I've just taken driving licence and insurance to a station on a producer.
- DanBC 8y agoA producer is the police making life a bit easier. They don't have to do so, the offence is complete and they could charge people for it. If you're the driver of a car and police stop you ans ask for ID you commit an offence if you refuse to identify yourself. Section 164: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1988/52/part/VII/crossheading/powers-of-constables-and-other-authorised-persons https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1988/52/part/VII/crossh...
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoHmm, the producer seems to be covered in the act and I'm not aware of any situations where they don't apply, or someone not getting the standard 7 day. Which is not to say there aren't any.
- DanBC 8y agoYou only have to show ID if you're stopped under the Road Traffic Act, and that only applies if you're the driver of the vehicle. There's other powers that PCSOs have for people who've been engaged in anti-social behviour, and those powers are probably misused. But otherwise there's no legal requirement to identify yourself to police. If they have enough to detain you then they can detain you to find out who you are. But that's not the same as just demanding ID from everyone.
- tomxor 8y agoIt's not compulsory to carry ID so how on earth would it be compulsory to produce it upon request... It is extremely common to not carry any official form of ID in the UK.
- johnisgood 8y agoSomeone also said that in the UK you don't have ID cards, so you wouldn't even be able to carry something that doesn't exist. Do you usually get frustrated at people who are trying to obtain information, or learn? If you are not write-only, you should have noticed that it has been already answered. Seems like to me that the only reason for your comment is to let out your frustration at someone who is trying to learn. Thank you.
- tomxor 8y ago> Seems like to me that the only reason for your comment is to let out your frustration at someone who is trying to learn heh, uhm... fuck you. I'm stating facts, you are doing ad hominem based on faulty assumptions: ID cards are not the only form of ID, based on your assumption it would be insane for police to even attempt to ask for ID.
- dang 8y agoPlease don't break the site guidelines like this, regardless of what someone else posted. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- dang 8y agoPlease don't cross into personal attack. If another comment is wrong, it's enough to give correct information. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- johnisgood 8y agoI didn't attack or try to attack him. He replied to my post with a seemingly frustrating attitude and used phrases to degrade me merely for asking something I didn't know. In any case, I stopped replying to him.