3 ms·
You didn't hear about it because the majority of the West is too busy directing their moral outrage at the most ethnically diverse country on Earth, which, surp
by fastball 8y ago
You didn't hear about it because the majority of the West is too busy directing their moral outrage at the most ethnically diverse country on Earth, which, surprisingly, has problems with racism.
My pet theory is that this is because Americans are one of the few groups of people who are willing to accept the fact that they have problems with racism. Every other country mostly just denies the existence of any racism that crops up (or overreacts in the opposite direction) and is therefore not so easy a target.
- tlarkworthy 8y agoIf you think that country is US you are hilariously mistaken https://www.worldatlas.com/articles/most-ethnically-diverse-countries-in-the-world.html https://www.worldatlas.com/articles/most-ethnically-diverse-... Africa and India are more diverse than US
- denzil_correa 8y agoAfrica is a continent while India is a country. India is indeed much diverse than almost other countries.
- moorhosj 8y agoThe World Atlas link shows 16 African countries more ethnically diverse than India.
- denzil_correa 8y agoIt's not surprising that a continent is more diverse than a country.
- moorhosj 8y agoSure, but that’s not what I, or the World Atlas, said. There are 16 individual African countries more diverse than India. 1 Guinea 2 Tanzania 3 Democratic Republic of Congo 4 Uganda 5 Liberia 6 Cameroon 7 Togo 8 South Africa 9 Congo 10 Madagascar 11 Gabon 12 Kenya 13 Ghana 14 Malawi 15 Guinea-Bissau 16 Somalia
- iguy 8y agoWell it's going to depend on your definitions. By American categories, India is 100% asian, and almost every sub-saharan country is 100% black. Of course local definitions vary. But that aside, GP has a point that contemporary American culture spends a lot of energy worrying about this. The energy expended is a poor measure of the size of the problem.
- moorhosj 8y ago==By American categories, India is 100% asian, and almost every sub-saharan country is 100% black. Of course local definitions vary.== But the claim was about "ethnicities", not races. People frequently refer to their ethnicity as Irish, Sicilian, Catalan, etc. Rarely have I heard someone say their ethnicity is white. ==The energy expended is a poor measure of the size of the problem.== Who gets to be the judge of the size of the problem? If a certain race or ethnicity is spending a lot of energy on this, maybe it is incumbent on everyone else to re-assess the true size of the problem.
- iguy 8y agoI'm not defending that the US is the "most ethnically diverse", I think that's far from true, but pointing out that this isn't an unambiguously defined question. I'm not sure I've never heard anyone state an ethnicity, but have heard the same people state belonging to multiple groups in different contexts. The dividing lines between what's an ethnicity and what's a race or a language group tend not to translate accurately between different places. Judging the extent of racial prejudice is also hard. But only crazy people think the US is more racist now than 100 years ago. 100 years ago the NYT did not devote many pages to white self-flagellation. Nor does China today. Nor does Liberia, for that matter.
- moorhosj 8y agoWhy would we compare the US today to the US 100 years ago? Should the Jim Crow-era really be our North Star? Categorizing it like this could be viewed minimizing today’s prejudice by comparing to prejudice of 100 years ago. I think the goal is to get to zero prejudice, so let’s compare against that. “Women don’t have it so bad today, 100 years ago they couldn’t even vote.”
- deogeo 8y agoIf I'm not mistaken, that study doesn't take into account how similar ethnic groups are. It would assign the same diversity index to a 50% Catalan, 50% Spanish country, as to a 50% Finnish, 50% Ugandan country.
- fastball 8y agoPrecisely. Measuring purely the number of technically different ethnicities is a silly way of calculating diversity. You need to look at the delta between the ethnicities if you want to talk about diversity that isn't purely on paper. I probably should've just said "racially", but oh well.
- tlarkworthy 8y agoYeah probably US is most racially diverse
- fastball 8y agoFair enough. I was thinking more in terms of the delta between the different ethnic groups, not in terms of the sheer number of technically different ethnicities.