5 ms·
You should give C# a try. It's pretty open these days (bonus: it's a much nicer language than Java)
by nicoburns 8y ago
You should give C# a try. It's pretty open these days (bonus: it's a much nicer language than Java)
- thefounder 8y agoOr better use Go! It's 100% open/BSD license.
- mustardo 8y agosigh... I'll just rewrite my 500k LOC products, abandon all of the great open source libraries instead of just using an open JRE https://adoptopenjdk.net/ https://adoptopenjdk.net/ Go fanboys are the worst
- dana321 8y agoIts all still encumbered by patents, its not free. Its "open"
- currysausage 8y agoTo be fair, grandfather did write: "I would rather use a programming language not licensed by a huge corporation."
- mustardo 8y agoIsn't Go out of Google...
- dana321 8y agoI do myself now use go, i've developed a scripting language on top of go which has all the great features of the go runtime but it is interpreted instead. It has a few hundred commands and will eventually have the ability to modify its own commands at runtime. I started the same thing with C++ but found that i spent too long getting libraries to work with each other without clashing (especially on windows) I've also found java to be a terrible memory hog and require significant tuning to run stable without having long periods of garbage collection and non-responsiveness, i've not had that problem with go out of the box. Thats the one thing about go that is great, goroutines and the (much much better) garbage collection. Yeah, i'm a bit of a go fanboy :)
- pdimitar 8y agoYou should not call yourself a fanboy for being practical! Lately I am on the hunt for a good closer-to-the metal language because I feel that even though the Erlang runtime (and thus Elixir's) is extremely stable and with unmatched concurrency and parallelism primitives, there still is a need for a native hyper-optimized code every now and then (crypto and compression come to mind). I like Go a lot. The authors got a lot of things right and the language's tooling is exceptional. Goroutines are no match for the true preemptive scheduling that the BEAM (Erlang's VM) can provide though. But I don't intend to use Go where I would use Erlang/Elixir anyway. They serve different niches. --- Have you evaluated other languages outside of Go and C++? For example Rust or OCaml? If you did evaluate anything else, what are your impressions?
- dana321 8y agoI have evaluated Rust a while ago, before i updated my C++ skills to C++17 with vcpkg / cmake and learned go using the new go modules functionality. I think rust is overly complex, and very quirky but.. It has some good ideas that i have taken and used in my own experimental languages i have developed like the error/ok branch structures. I think Ocaml is even more quirky than rust, they are using symbols (|) to define select statements, i would to be honest rather have something more readable. Reminds me of perl a lot. Both use "let" for defining variables that i'm not a fan of as a keyword.
- pdimitar 8y agoEh, but you cannot deny these are cosmetical / taste preferences and not technical disadvantages of the languages. IMO OCaml is a less sciency Haskell, and more focused on getting stuff done -- but I am still evaluating it and it definitely has warts in the tooling. Time will tell. Rust... I looked at it but it struck me as a modern C++... too many ways to do one thing. We need opinionated tech. Programming is not an art class practice session.
- dana321 8y agoIts all about: Syntax Libraries Runtime I picked syntax briefly, because i think its the most important part of the language. The libraries can be written, the runtime improved but if the syntax is bad its hard to change it later.
- j16sdiz 8y agoGo is good for system-level tools. But the web-facing / framework-wise is weak. The dependancy hell is not fully fixed yet.
- mustardo 8y agoThis x1000 If you want to make a little cross platform binary for some utility sure maybe Go is the right choice, but most of the time people are building a "Web Application" in which case there are dozens of better languages to use
- thefounder 8y agoI found Go a better fit than Java & Python for my web APIs/micro-services. I'm not sure what web application are but Go compiles to WASM so it would make it an even more complete solution once WASM gets DOM access.
- thefounder 8y agoI would say that the lack of gigantic frameworks is a feature. Go is great for web APIs.
- elygre 8y agoIs C# more open than Java?
- nicoburns 8y agoWell it's about the same amount of open as far as licensing is concerned, but it's created by microsoft rather than oracle, so you're less likely to be chased into ridiculous lawsuits. Downside is: the library ecosystem is less open. Some libraries are proprietary, which is not something I've encountered in other ecosystems. This seems to be changing though, now that C# itself is open source.
- marktangotango 8y agoIt’s more common to pay for licenses in the .net ecosystem in my experience.
- pron 8y ago> you're less likely to be chased into ridiculous lawsuits. Microsoft has sued/legally threatened companies over Android and extracted many billions of dollars from them: * https://www.forbes.com/sites/ewanspence/2015/11/01/microsoft-android-patent-income/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/ewanspence/2015/11/01/microsoft... * https://www.computerworld.com/article/2475440/android/microsoft-gets--2-billion-a-year-in-android-patent-fees--really-.html https://www.computerworld.com/article/2475440/android/micros...
- gruez 8y agoAFAIK it’s not because of android, but because of fat32.
- charleslmunger 8y agoPatent extortion works by threatening the most applicable patents you have, then licensing your whole portfolio. If they didn't have fat32, do you really think they wouldn't have just used another patent to try and extract rents?
- mustardo 8y agoBecause who could possibly imagine a world where M$ would pull this same sort of stunt with the CLR...
- marktangotango 8y agoUsage of “M$” is very juvenile in 2019, but this is the same point I was going to make. Microsoft hasn’t been as extortionist as oracle, at least not yet.
- ui-explorer12 8y agoMicrosoft has also demonstrated a far stronger commitment to developers over many decades compared with Oracle, who never sell or promote that far away from the C-suite.
- mustardo 8y agoRealy? I remember pretty much every development stack for windows being dropped and abandoned (leaving devs in the lurch) time after time on windows. XNA, Silverlight, WinRT, etc. It's easy to make MS look ok when you compare them to the horror show that is Oracle
- severino 8y agoHe said "no big corporations behind". Also, it's not fully open, as you said.