5 ms·
> many other senses Yeah? Like what? You've listed two. Two is not "many". You don't need to have a magnet implanted to feel a magnetic field. All you hav
by lisper 8y ago
> many other senses
Yeah? Like what? You've listed two. Two is not "many".
You don't need to have a magnet implanted to feel a magnetic field. All you have to do is hold two magnets close to each other.
As for our "sense" of time, this arises from the fact that our brains perform data processing at a characteristic speed, and that in turn is an emergent property of atoms.
> I'm curious how you think "emitting an alpha particle" differs from "being pried apart" or "fissioning".
Alpha-decay is spontaneous, fissioning generally needs to initiated by neutron bombardment. "Being pried apart" was intended to refer to chemical reactions, not nuclear ones.
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agoSince we're talking about hypotheticals: Imagine a lifeform that experiences entanglement directly. Or one that senses gravity waves. (It would have to be very, very, very big. But even so.) Or one that is just as good at making maps of social and political configurations as it is at mapping its physical surroundings. Or one that has evolved with an intuitive understanding of the patterns that define how knowledge is structured, rather than learning low-cost approximations for essentials and off-loading high-cost speculation to external media and low-threat contexts, like humans do. "There are only so many ways for atoms to do stuff" is true, but that doesn't mean we have the first clue what all of those ways are.
- lisper 8y ago> that doesn't mean we have the first clue what all of those ways are Actually we know a few constraints that they have to meet: 1. They have to provide an evolutionary advantage in some environment 2. They have to be Turing-computable 3. They have to realizable in hardware made of atoms (unless you want to consider dark-matter aliens) So: > a lifeform that experiences entanglement directly I don't know what you meant by this. You do experience entanglement directly. The entire classical world is made of entanglements. Your very existence is a massive network of entanglements. > one that senses gravity waves > It would have to be very, very, very big This is actually conceivable for a dark-matter alien, but then we have all the aforementioned problems of detecting and communicating with it. For an alien made of ordinary matter this is inconceivable because #1 above. > just as good at making maps of social and political configurations as it is at mapping its physical surroundings. Humans are actually pretty good at this in their ancestral environment where there are at most 100-200 individuals to deal with. But this is actually the most likely avenue IMO, an alien that can "natively" handle communities of millions or billions of individuals where everyone knows everyone else.
- thaumasiotes 8y ago> Yeah? Like what? Most people try to support an argument with something stronger than "I don't know very much". You can sense acceleration. You can sense temperature. You can sense the position of the various parts of your own body. ("proprioception") You can sense whether you need to eat, and what you should eat. ("hunger") Note that from a physical perspective, hunger appears identical to taste and smell. That is to say, it is implemented by special receptors that bind to a particular molecular shape. But unlike those two, it is not general-purpose -- it is a computational artifact, the specialized means by which your digestive system sends messages to your nervous system. But it is no less of a sense than your others. A sense is a means of receiving input. This should tell you that the number of senses you may experience is not limited by the number of interactions one atom may have with another atom; it is at least as large as the number of different types of computation you might want to do. If you're really interested in a catalog of senses, I suggest checking out the psychology literature. And whether you're interested or not, I suggest trying to base your arguments on something more than bluster. Believing that humans have five senses has all the scientific backing of believing in the tongue map.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoI think 'lisper wasn't interested in a catalog of senses, but whether they're "going to lead them to new physics that we haven't discovered". Once you listed are less about physics/external world and more about internal status of the body.
- thaumasiotes 8y agoI don't think asserting that there's nothing more for us to discover is a good method of determining whether we might discover something new. If an alien sense relying on physics unknown to us were to come to our attention, it seems likely to me that it would indeed lead us to discover that new physics. But since we don't know whether physics like that exists or not, we can't say whether such a sense could exist either. lisper has very clearly claimed that such a sense cannot exist because there is no such physics; I don't see how he could be interested in the question you state. > Ones you listed are less about physics/external world and more about internal status of the body. I'd say temperature, time, touch, hearing, sight, and smell are primarily about the external world and proprioception, taste, and hunger are primarily about the internal status of the body. That's really what distinguishes taste from smell. Acceleration seems like a gray area.