2 ms·
Silicon Valley Puts the ‘Con’ in Consent
- js2 8y agoThe top comment on the article is worth reading. I’m copying it here. James K. Lowden (Camden, Maine) writes: It’s not just privacy, not just the internet, and not because of the internet. It’s corporate power. Some of us remember when getting a phone or credit card didn’t entail 13 pages of fine print. There was nothing to agree to. Both parties reserved all rights under the law. Let’s note that the contracts we supposedly sign never grant us additional rights. They’re entirely one-sided: you agree to thus-and-such for the privilege of using what you paid for. I learned in Business Law 101 that valid contracts had to be entered voluntarily and had to include consideration: something of value from both parties had to be at stake. “Shrink-wrap” contracts on software didn’t meet that basic standard, but have been upheld nonetheless. The law should state: there can be no “terms of sale” agreement for any retail purpose. No waivers for renting a moped or a car, no terms on software or websites, no contract for a phone or bank account. The firm must comply with the law, an the consumer reserves all rights under the law, full stop. Anything less is involuntary on its face. The corporate lawyers draft an “agreement” worth millions to the firm but in absolute terms that same stake is divided amongst millions of customers, none of which has enough at stake to hire a lawyer (pretending the terms were negotiable). The very fact the terms cannot be modified is prima facia evidence of coercion. https://nyti.ms/2DSfq4B#permid=30447668 https://nyti.ms/2DSfq4B#permid=30447668
- platz 8y agoWhat is the difference between a software liscence such as GPL and a "contract" that must include consideration?
- LocalH 8y agoLegally? Probably not a lot. IANAL tho. Morally? The entire intent, as compared to that behind most modern contracts where one party has no real negotiation leverage.
- gumby 8y agoWell the GPL is standard and short, while most licenses are long and custom. But I agree: I've long wondered why the GPL is treated like kryptonite, as really it's just like any other software license except 1> the "consideration" only applies when you distribute it and 2> the requirements for distribution aren't paid in cash (just provide the appropriate source code). If your corporate lawyers can deal with you licensing, say, VxWorks (or Oracle!) they should find the GPL trivial by comparison.
- malvosenior 8y agoHow many trackers and ad platform pixels are currently running on nytimes.com? It's ridiculous for NYT to get on a high horse and continue to attack tech companies when they subject readers to just as many privacy invading technologies as anyone else. The title of this piece alone is pure yellow journalism.
- danharaj 8y agoBeing a hypocrite doesn't make you wrong.
- ardy42 8y agoIt's also not at all clear that the authors of this piece chose to put any "trackers and ad platform pixels" on the site or are empowered to remove anything like that. The NYT is not a self-hosted blog run by a techie.
- jammygit 8y agoIt does rub me the wrong way though that if I get a paid subscription i still get tracked when they write so many articles against it. At least Ars Technical put their money where their mouths was and fixed that for subs