4 ms·
> If we encountered an alien species with as much intellectual distance from us as we are to the monkeys, then how would our most innovative theories fare agai
by lisper 8y ago
> If we encountered an alien species with as much intellectual distance from us as we are to the monkeys, then how would our most innovative theories fare against theirs?
That depends on how far you are willing to suspend disbelief in your concept of what such an alien might look like.
Are they made of atoms? If so, then they are overwhelmingly like to have senses very similar to ours. This is because our senses are fundamentally rooted in the physics of atoms, and there just aren't that many fundamentally different things that atoms can do. They can absorb and emit photons, they can stick together and be pried apart, they can emit alpha and beta particles, and they can fuse and fission. That's about it. And with those fundamental building blocks there is only so much you can do. You can imagine, say, aliens that can natively detect different parts of the E-M spectrum than we do, but that's not going to lead them to new physics that we haven't discovered.
On the other hand, if these aliens are made of dark matter then all bets are off. But given how hard it is for us to detect dark matter at all it's hard to imagine how we would get to the point where we would even recognize a life form made of it, let alone figure out how to communicate with it.
- thaumasiotes 8y ago> our senses are fundamentally rooted in the physics of atoms, and there just aren't that many fundamentally different things that atoms can do. They can absorb and emit photons, they can stick together and be pried apart, they can emit alpha and beta particles, and they can fuse and fission. That's about it. And with those fundamental building blocks there is only so much you can do. Our traditional physical senses: - Sight. Based on interacting with photons. - Sound. This is based on atoms physically colliding with each other. However, we process it using a complex apparatus that essentially performs a Fourier transform on the raw air-pressure data, extracting the frequencies of the wave pattern that reaches our ears on the assumption that a wave pattern is what we will get. - Touch. This is based on atoms colliding with each other. It is set up more for the detection of large-scale structural characteristics. (e.g. hard / soft / liquid) - Smell. This is based on atoms colliding with each other. It is totally unlike touch in that the sense of smell processes molecules based on their molecular shape -- the specific way in which they interact with dedicated sensors -- rather than on their physical characteristics. At this level, you're interacting with a molecule more than with a substance. - Taste. From a physics perspective, this is basically just the same thing as smell. From a biology perspective, it's pretty different. I don't see this as good evidence that the set of possible senses is meaningfully limited by a simplistic view of how atoms can physically interact with other atoms. We have many other senses that are less obviously based in simple physical interactions, like the sense of time. Some people have had magnets implanted, leveraging their existing sense of touch into a sense of magnetic fields. This is something humans don't ordinarily have, and is actually not allowed for by your list of the capabilities of atoms -- you forgot that atoms can hold an electric charge -- but is analogous to some other animals' ability to sense electric fields. I'm curious how you think "emitting an alpha particle" differs from "being pried apart" or "fissioning".
- lisper 8y ago> many other senses Yeah? Like what? You've listed two. Two is not "many". You don't need to have a magnet implanted to feel a magnetic field. All you have to do is hold two magnets close to each other. As for our "sense" of time, this arises from the fact that our brains perform data processing at a characteristic speed, and that in turn is an emergent property of atoms. > I'm curious how you think "emitting an alpha particle" differs from "being pried apart" or "fissioning". Alpha-decay is spontaneous, fissioning generally needs to initiated by neutron bombardment. "Being pried apart" was intended to refer to chemical reactions, not nuclear ones.
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agoSince we're talking about hypotheticals: Imagine a lifeform that experiences entanglement directly. Or one that senses gravity waves. (It would have to be very, very, very big. But even so.) Or one that is just as good at making maps of social and political configurations as it is at mapping its physical surroundings. Or one that has evolved with an intuitive understanding of the patterns that define how knowledge is structured, rather than learning low-cost approximations for essentials and off-loading high-cost speculation to external media and low-threat contexts, like humans do. "There are only so many ways for atoms to do stuff" is true, but that doesn't mean we have the first clue what all of those ways are.
- lisper 8y ago> that doesn't mean we have the first clue what all of those ways are Actually we know a few constraints that they have to meet: 1. They have to provide an evolutionary advantage in some environment 2. They have to be Turing-computable 3. They have to realizable in hardware made of atoms (unless you want to consider dark-matter aliens) So: > a lifeform that experiences entanglement directly I don't know what you meant by this. You do experience entanglement directly. The entire classical world is made of entanglements. Your very existence is a massive network of entanglements. > one that senses gravity waves > It would have to be very, very, very big This is actually conceivable for a dark-matter alien, but then we have all the aforementioned problems of detecting and communicating with it. For an alien made of ordinary matter this is inconceivable because #1 above. > just as good at making maps of social and political configurations as it is at mapping its physical surroundings. Humans are actually pretty good at this in their ancestral environment where there are at most 100-200 individuals to deal with. But this is actually the most likely avenue IMO, an alien that can "natively" handle communities of millions or billions of individuals where everyone knows everyone else.
- state_less 8y agoApes use very similar senses, but our brain gives us the advantage of deriving more from those same senses. Similarly, aliens might be able to process the data better, or gather and process more data than we can. In a sense, we are alien compared to our ancestors of hundreds of years ago. Our technology extended our natural sensors and we started to learn more about our place in the solar system, galaxy, super cluster and so on. We learned more about physics too. I suspect there is more to the story and more advanced aliens would have some surprising things to say about the nature of our universe. We might have difficulty understanding it if there is a large knowledge gap though.
- lisper 8y agoWe really have only one significant evolutionary advantage over apes and that is our ability to reason symbolically, i.e. to use language and math. We got that hundreds of thousands of years ago, and that, plus the invention of writing, turned us into Turing machines. That's as far as you can go in this universe unless you can somehow evolve a quantum computer, but that seems exceedingly unlikely. It's hard to imagine an environment where there would be an evolutionary advantage to being able to factor large primes. Aliens might have made significant scientific and social progress over us (most likely) but we will have no trouble coming up to speed if we get access to their libraries. It's a lot harder to figure something out for the first time than it is to learn it once someone else has figured it out.