6 ms·
The Last Free Generation (2018)
- simplecomplex 8y agoThe author really doesn’t have to move to undeveloped countries to stop posting online and developing tracking software... It’s not that black and white. We have a lot more freedom than he’s making it sound. If you use a computer 24/7 you might feel oppressed by it. Like with anything.
- rezous 8y agoWe have a lot more freedom than this guy makes it out to be.Is it shrinking ? Probably yes. All I can see though is a rather poor attempt to advertise his startup.
- js4ever 8y agoError establishing a database connection
- catdog 8y agohttp://archive.is/ChaL9 http://archive.is/ChaL9
- jaabe 8y agoI minored in history, maybe I didn’t pay enough attention to it, but I can’t think of a period where we’ve been more free than we are now. Not even 10 years ago. We live in a time where you can frankly do anything you want if you’re born in the western world. If you want to become a blacksmith who specialises in creating fantasy weapons, you can do that. If you want to disconnect and go live a self-sustainable life in the Swedish forest, you can do that and unlike the hippies of the 60ies you won’t even have to starve if you suck at it. And so on. I think it’s completely possible to live a full life and never realise you had the option to be free though, and, I think it’s fair to blame the way we’ve constructed our society in the wake of new public management. We’ve essentially build a system where every human being is viewed as a Hunan resource. It starts in the daycare institution where the social workers have checklists for normal child development. It picks up in the school system where academic achievement is measured from the first classes and children have to know their path from the 6th grade to make sure they take the specific classes which allow them to advance to the next institution. The once you’re on the job market you’re evaluated on productivity and finally when you retire it’s about keeping you in good health so you cost less. All to make sure people are as efficient to the system as possible. Social media and the massive surveillance state that we’ve build by sharing everything plays right into this. We self-censor and pretend, and everything we share on the “free” tech-platforms is kept and used against us. Which I completely agree is very worrisome. The thing is though, 1984 was right. If anything the current level of surveillance and manufactured information is way worse than Orwell predicted, and yet, you can still go make fantasy swords in the Swedish forests if you wanted to. I just don’t share the authors negative outlook. Maybe I’m naive, but I really don’t think that we’ll turn the west into China. I think things like the European GDPR is a show of this. We don’t want companies or governments to misuse our data, and we’ll punish them if they do. It’s happening slowly, but that’s how a democracy operates, because you have to compromise. It’s happening though, and it’s happening because people wanted it. I also fully expect the younger generation to rebel more than we did. You see it already on climate issues, with children refusing to go to school if they won’t have a future anyway. I suspect they won’t want to keep our surveillance state or our HR centric view on society either.
- djaychela 8y ago>I also fully expect the younger generation to rebel more than we did. You see it already on climate issues, with children refusing to go to school if they won’t have a future anyway. I suspect they won’t want to keep our surveillance state or our HR centric view on society either. I don't see this in my experience. I expected my stepkids' generation to all be real eco-zealots, totally concerned about everything my generation and before have done wrong. In practice, all of them that I know are a cross section - some are quite eco minded, but a lot aren't. They aren't all as PC as I expected them to be (ditto - a cross section, including some who are strongly anti). Most of them are just completely absorbed in their own lives, via whatever social platform is currently most popular. None of them give a monkeys about their privacy, being tracked or anything else - they're totally blind to all these issues, and think that I'm a complete loon for bringing any of them up. I get the 'this is the future old man' routine fairly often, and none of them think that the consequences I'm concerned about have any relevance to them. (They range between 12 and 19 years old, FTR). I appreciate this is anecdotal, but I don't think that the next generation will be the saviours we were expecting them to be. I expected them all to be totally tech-savvy and miles ahead of me - most of them don't even understand the basics of how the Internet works, let alone any of the details. It's the magic of the Wookie Hole Witch as far as they are concerned.
- a0-prw 8y agoThe only reason you can make fantasy weapons or live in the Swedish forest is because those things don't threaten the man. Try exposing state war crimes and see how far you get with your "freedom".
- xvector 8y ago> My son Atlas is just over nine months old [...] One thing that’s been troubling me, is that he probably wont have [privacy] in his lifetime. > I write systems that predict the moods in real-time of nearly a million people who are communicating on the internet (HNProfile.com & RedditProfile.com). Moral bankruptcy at its finest. No one is forcing you to write systems that do this. You can easily make top-tier salaries at companies that value the privacy of their customers.
- blueboo 8y agoMr. Gotcha claims another victim [https://thenib.com/mister-gotcha https://thenib.com/mister-gotcha]
- xvector 8y agoAmusing, but entirely irrelevant to my point. You need a phone, car, society to function and live a reasonably high quality of life. OP has options here and this makes all the difference. No one is forcing him to write deanonymizing software, and he faces no loss in quality of life by finding a job in which he can work on something more ethical, whereas the people in the comic all face a significant loss.
- ismail 8y ago“You need a phone, car, society to function and live a reasonably high quality of life.” Is that actually true? Yes that may be necessary in society Today. But does that = quality of life ?
- cimmanom 8y agoI think that’s tangential to the parent’s main point.
- est31 8y agoSomeone will write the software one way or another. All that OP would achieve by leaving is to increase the price for this specific thing a little bit. Also, insiders like OP always have specific insights into the full extent of the thing they are involved in so they also know really well how bad it is.
- mirimir 8y agoYawn. OK, I gotta recycle this from John Markoff:[0] > "True Names" by Vernor Vinge (1981): "The basic premise of that was, you had to basically hide your true name at all costs. It was an insight into the world we’re living in today … We have to figure it out. I think we have to go to pseudonymity or something. You’re gonna participate in this networked existence, you have to be connected to meatspace in some way." Indeed. At least pseudonymity. We need to compartmentalize. In meatspace, we must be totally unremarkable. We must make only routine communications, for entirely utilitarian purposes. Everything even vaguely sensitive -- that is, everything that we want kept private -- must use secure channels. And if it's truly sensitive, it must be ~anonymous. With the degree of anonymity proportional to the level of sensitivity. I see no other option. 0) http://renaissancechambara.jp/2017/06/14/oprah-time-true-names-by-vernor-vinge/ http://renaissancechambara.jp/2017/06/14/oprah-time-true-nam...
- bostik 8y ago> Everything even vaguely sensitive -- that is, everything that we want kept private -- must use secure channels. I see this in a different way. The starting point should be that everything is secured. If you use the secure messaging only for non-mundane stuff, it stands out. So you want to add as much noise into the use profile of the secure channels as possible, to make it that much harder to detect when anything of value is being transmitted. This, however, I completely agree with: > And if it's truly sensitive, it must be ~anonymous In the context of secure channels, that adds that the use of ~anonymous methods must not be any different from outside the channels. Preferably not even from the inside, because you have to assume that a portion of such a system is compromised at all times.
- mirimir 8y ago> The starting point should be that everything is secured. If you use the secure messaging only for non-mundane stuff, it stands out. That's a good point. But consider, how do I use "secure messaging" with my meatspace bank? Or with my wife, or my meatspace friends? Sure, I use HTTPS. But trying to get any of those to use truly secure channels would be pointless. And even worse, it would attract attention. For noise on secure channels, I torrent random stuff. That all goes through a VPN service. But among the torrent traffic, there are indirect VPN connections.
- IndrekR 8y agoSite is down at the moment. Archived copy: http://archive.is/ChaL9 http://archive.is/ChaL9