3 ms·
As a US citizen, it's honestly embarrassing. The high volume also means prosecutors get to use plea deals as extortion, even when they have no chance of actual
by tyingq 8y ago
As a US citizen, it's honestly embarrassing. The high volume also means prosecutors get to use plea deals as extortion, even when they have no chance of actually prosecuting. Then there's also the awful state of our bail/jail/prison system.
It seems like the demographics are changing enough that we could actually start changing our punishment (vs rehabilitation) centric justice system.
We're now close to 1% of the adult population in prison, and 2% on probation. I wonder what the percentage of "was ever in prison, or had an immediate family member in prison" is.
- perfmode 8y agoI'm super interested to know the "has had a parent in prison while under the age of 18". That would certainly bring to light the broader impact of imprisonment.
- Someone 8y agohttps://everysecond.fwd.us/downloads/EverySecond.fwd.us.pdf https://everysecond.fwd.us/downloads/EverySecond.fwd.us.pdf (for those who dislike PDF, the report also is on https://everysecond.fwd.us https://everysecond.fwd.us, but I find it unnavigable): ”adults age 18 to 29 reported having had a parent incarcerated at more than twice the rate of respondents from other age groups (34 percent compared to 14 percent)” That doesn’t quite answer your question, but it seems likely to be closer to that 34% than to that 14%, unless older people somehow forgot that their parent went to jail in their youth (the numbers are from “online and phone surveys”), or the younger respondents exaggerated.
- Latteland 8y agoIt's worse than embarrassing, it's disgusting, it's shameful, it's kind of indicative of the breakdown of our societal norms - see politics for another area. A lot of those people were minorities, all of them must have been poor. We don't have equal rights for people who can't afford a lawyer. If you are a juror in a case, you have to consider if this is the situation. It never really hit me that I could be one of the people who could be faced with a situation like this - could I detect that non-existent defense lawyer, could I be strong enough of character to discuss that with the other jurors. I'm sure that for our entire history this has been something faced by poor and minority defendants, but I think it must be worse than in the past because of the plea bargain hunting by prosecutors and the increasing prosecution and filling of prisons. We have maybe 3 levels of criminal justice in America. The larger group of people who can't afford a lawyer and have an overburdened public defender, regular people who can afford a lawyer, and then rich people who can afford endless money to challenge even reasonable evidence - think any celebrity accused of a crime. Prosecutors try to plea bargain cases, and poor people probably are told by their overburdened public defender to go along with it. If a lot of those people didn't plea bargain but went to a real trial, then the public defender wouldn't even be able to go to that many trials. One of the presidential candidates this year was a prosecutor (Sen. Kamala Harris), and she was one of those who in some cases at least didn't seem to intervene in cases where there was proprietorial malfeasance.
- bellerose 8y ago> We don't have equal rights for people who can't afford a lawyer. This is why if I were to have kids. I would make sure they have 10 grand saved for a lawyer (if & when an emergency happens in adulthood) and having them understand it could be 50 grand needed for bail. Parents who have kids with little to no finances really shouldn't in today's society. Innocent people can have their lives just ruined by being poor.
- pjc50 8y agohttps://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-46471444 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-46471444 : > Nearly half of all US adults have had an immediate family member incarcerated at some point in their lives, according to a new study. > African American adults were 50% more likely than white Americans to have had a family member jailed > 54% of jailed parents were the breadwinners of their families.
- tyingq 8y agoWow. Higher than I would have guessed. I wonder why reform doesn't resonate as an election issue.
- bellerose 8y agoI'm assuming the candidates prefer issues they can relate towards and they typically have the funds for good attorneys. The public that hasn't been effected by false incarceration may have the belief it won't happen to myself and the issue doesn't resonate necessarily like other issues of employment & taxes.
- pjc50 8y ago"Tough on crime" just resonates much more. Also, felons are disqualified from voting; then there's the usual set of gerrymandering, voter suppression, misleading news, etc. problems of the system as a whole.
- jdietrich 8y ago5.4 million Americans have lost the right to vote through felony disenfranchisement.