3 ms·
A few years back, I remember being on my way out of what I thought was a pretty successful interview with a very well known (CEO seems to be on the front page o
by ryandrake 8y ago
A few years back, I remember being on my way out of what I thought was a pretty successful interview with a very well known (CEO seems to be on the front page of HN every week) U.S. Silicon Valley company. The interview itself was professional and by-the-book. While the H.R. rep was walking me to the front lobby area, she was making small talk and eventually asked something along the lines of "So, are you married? Have any kids?" I was shocked to say the least, and mustered up "You know, I don't think you're allowed to ask that question." I mean, she's in H.R. If anyone in the company should know what to ask and what not to it's her. Never got an offer, and always kind of wondered if my push-back might have been part of it.
- bluetidepro 8y agoIdk. Personally, you even said it yourself above, that just seems like it was honest/genuine “small talk.” It could have totally been just that and nothing more. I wouldn’t jump right to “invasion of privacy” if someone asked me that. To me, those don’t seem like invasive questions. Same thing I’d imagine to hear from any random stranger at a work event, for example. Pretty basic boilerplate “get to know ya/small talk” questions, besides the ol’ “so, this weather huh?!” Haha Maybe I’m just being optimistic that not everyone in tech is evil, with an agenda? ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- pertymcpert 8y agoIt’s incredibly stupid for HR to ask that. We had training from HR so we didn’t even unintentionally ask questions during small talk they could indirectly force them to reveal sensitive information. How on earth could a HR rep make that mistake astounds me.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoPeople are human. No mistakes astound me anymore. They simply fall on the range between "they haven't had their coffee yet" to "you're going to need corrective surgery for that not to be permanently debilitating" to "you might need a great attorney to get you out of this".
- fredgrott 8y agoeven Microsoft has rules in place for their HR people not to do this...come on its 2019