4 ms·
While beautiful, I don't think it illustrates BitTorrent very well. Data doesn't just magically flow to clients, it needs to be coordinated and/or negotiated so
by zokier 16y ago
While beautiful, I don't think it illustrates BitTorrent very well. Data doesn't just magically flow to clients, it needs to be coordinated and/or negotiated somehow. Data integrity is also somewhat important aspect of BitTorrent, every piece that client receives is verified against the .torrent file.
- vdm 16y agoDoes this mean that the tracker isn't included at all? I think you're right. How would you visualise verifying integrity? Is that really necessary to visualise?
- smackfu 16y agoI think you could only cover that by visualizing the path of a single chunk. Showing that the client asks the tracker who has it, then asks the other peer if they are willing to provide it, then receiving the separate blocks and checking the integrity and blacklisting the peer if necessary. Then advertising that you have that chunk to other peers. To me, that is the more interesting side of BitTorrent, compared to what the linked visualization is showing, which is just that "peers get stuff from peers that already have it, then once they have it, provide it to other peers."
- wmf 16y agoThe tracker doesn't know which peers have what data; "have" messages are used for that.
- ryanpetrich 16y agoAlso, it appears that in the visualization all clients have the same amount of bandwidth. In the real world this is usually not the case.