5 ms·
Again and again I see the comments of how crazy it is that we allow violence in films/TV/anywhere, but not sex which is peaceful and harmless -- as if this were
by crazygringo 8y ago
Again and again I see the comments of how crazy it is that we allow violence in films/TV/anywhere, but not sex which is peaceful and harmless -- as if this were some kind of idiocy or hypocrisy.
There's a good reason we try to draw lines between areas where sex is "allowed" and "not allowed" -- because it's arousing and has the potential to be greatly embarrassing. It's private, in a way that violence isn't. I seriously don't get how so many people seem to willfully ignore this.
When I Google something in a meeting or in front of my mother, I do not want sexual results to appear because some term has an alternate meaning. When I watch a movie with my parents, nobody's going to squirm from the violence, but we certainly don't want to watch a steamy sex scene together. That's just how human beings are wired. We're not prudes, there's just a time and a place.
So having major internet services like Google and Facebook default to being non-sexual seems like a pretty smart move to me. And then there are still countless sites on the internet devoted entirely to sex. Keeping them largely separated seems smart. And while what happened to Tumblr was very sad, I'm sure other sites will replace it... it's the internet after all.
- hobs 8y agoThat's completely a cultural artifact though, there's no reason to be squeamish about sex and to accept violence. Plenty of cultures have much looser taboos around this than yours, its not how human beings are wired.
- mberning 8y agoI would love to know in which cultures a teenage son watching soft core porn with their mother is perfectly comfortable or possibly even celebrated.
- Juliate 8y agoThat's not the point. The point is about the disconnect of a society that protects/promotes speech/messages/images/behaviour about violence while refusing the same for sex. While one is deadly and the second is not; while one can be a great resource of connection and pleasure, while the other is the exact negation of it.
- mberning 8y agoI’m pretty sure that is exactly the point the op was making when they said “Plenty of cultures have much looser taboos around this than yours, its not how human beings are wired.” All I am asking for is an example of such a culture. A mother and teenage son watching some film with nudity and simulated sex and neither of them is uncomfortable at all about it.
- Juliate 8y agoWell... in France, for a start? Or anywhere in Europe? Depending of your circle, you'll have a range of different people about that. But nudity is pretty much inoffensive here, unless you really insist of putting your luggage in the face of people. There are family-friendly naturist places all around the country. Some find them bizarre. Some find them offensive. Some find them fine. Some don't care. And (simulated or not, who cares) sex in a story is pretty much a non-event as well, unless: - it's totally disconnected from the story itself, - it is violent/coercitive.
- house_atr 8y agoAnd that's a problem with modesty that Europe needs to work on. Not something the rest of the world needs to acquiesce to because the Nato bloc are rich countries and we should all do what they do, often at the implication of "or else".
- jaegerpicker 8y agoHow about right here in the USA, I've watched plenty of movies with sex scenes with family members and it was no big deal. Besides that what kind of pansy culture is worth censoring a valid natural healthy part of human life because we are too "uncomfortable" with a real and healthy positive aspect of adult life. I'm not anti-violence in media but I'm certainly against the filtering of expression just so someone else doesn't need to deal with a little uncomfortable feelings. I'm not personally directing that at you as a poster, more the general idea of the censoring based on uncomfortable feelings overriding someone else's right to expression. Sorry if it comes off aggressive I don't mean it in that way towards you.
- saagarjha 8y agoIf you consider nudity to be in that category, then many European countries.
- crazygringo 8y agoI don't think too many people are confusing general nudity (like the nudist lifestyle, totally non-sexual) or a few topless advertisements with softcore porn. They're completely different things. So no, I don't think Europe counts as an example here.
- gottebp 8y agoIf something is cultural, why does that imply it is automatically bad or should be tossed aside? This is not to say any culture is all good or all perfect, however didn't much of culture come about through generation after generation evolving and learning and passing on what worked? I invoke Chesterton's fence here: Fences take work to put up, and someone put in that work. First understand why it was put in place and only then should you consider tearing it down. Cultures each have differing strengths and weaknesses, woven into a complex fabric, and it is difficult to change just one part in isolation without butterfly effects elsewhere -- much like a large codebase.
- hobs 8y agoYou can make a faithful argument that a particular culture is good, though you wont find me backing it. That's not what was said though, what was said was that it was human nature itself, which is bogus.
- Juliate 8y ago> If something is cultural, why does that imply it is automatically bad or should be tossed aside? It does not. But neither does it imply it's good. Because something is cultural does not make it immune to analysis and critique. Especially today, as we see firsthand how much culture, minds, beliefs can be influenced, manipulated, in a few years-time, for the very political and financial interest of some very specific clique. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Village_(2004_film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Village_(2004_film) is a pretty nice exploration of that topic.
- untog 8y agoIt feels as though you are answering the question "why are these things taboo?" with "because they are taboo!"
- NPMaxwell 8y agoI rarely see violence in the movies I watch. The result is that I squirm a lot when I am visiting my son and we watch some blockbuster showing heads being crushed by sledge hammers. I believe that you do not find that sort of thing makes you cringe. I believe the term for that effect is "desensitizing". In the 1970's, I once watched a soccer game with a family in France. On of the advertisements showed a naked lady get out of a bath, with full frontal nudity, and hug a very handsome naked man. I was shocked, but my hosts were more intent on getting drinks before play started again. And, sex is like air and money. If you have enough, it's not really interesting.
- Juliate 8y ago> because it's arousing So is violence. Not arousing in the same way, we are imitating animals. > and has the potential to be greatly embarrassing. That is also a social construct. Why should sex be embarrassing that violence wouldn't be? That's the very definition of being prude.
- DSingularity 8y agoWhat? Violence is embarrassing -- not arousing. And like sex, I wouldn't be comfortable to casually snack on popcorn while watching movies which present detailed re-enactments of people murdering each other. And I certainly wouldn't be comfortable to watch it with anyone else either.
- Juliate 8y ago> Violence is embarrassing -- not arousing. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/arouse https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/arouse - you have no idea. But great, you'll learn something fundamental about a human construct we devised to help us cope with that: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catharsis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catharsis.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- yesenadam 8y ago>I wouldn't be comfortable to casually snack on popcorn while watching movies which present detailed re-enactments of people murdering each other. Check out the IMDb top 250 - the vast majority of movies near the top of the list fit your description. https://www.imdb.com/chart/top https://www.imdb.com/chart/top (..not to mention the huge popularity of first-person shooter games.)
- DSingularity 8y agoMan thank you. I would take it a step forward and argue that the reason it is so embarrassing is because sexually explicit content clashes with our basic nature. Unfortunately you cant say such things without being painted as a caveman who refuses to evolve.
- ggregoire 8y agoCavemen probably had sex in front of everyone without any shame.
- khalilravanna 8y agoMy knee jerk reaction is actually to agree with you wholeheartedly: sex is arousing and violence isn't. But if I can play devil's advocate, isn't it possible that if sex was more commonplace and less censored it would be less arousing? Sure there's a biological aspect, but I think a lot of sex is psychological. And if our threshold for what was considered "exciting" was brought down by a complete normalization of nudity and erotic content, wouldn't it not be that uncomfortable at all? Similarly, if we completely censored violence, wouldn't you be incredibly uncomfortable if violence showed up in a google search while you're presenting to peers at work? Personally, I'm inclined to think that the answer is yes. I think it's all relative. And I think our censorship is directly linked to the fact that it's uncomfortable.
- 50656E6973 8y ago>isn't it possible that if sex was more commonplace and less censored it would be less arousing? Evidence of this is the female nipple.
- nine_k 8y agoIf visuals of sex became more commonplace and less arousing, won't it make real sex less enjoyable? This is a testable hypothesis. We have a wide variety of cultures on Earth, from highly wrapped-up to those where almost complete nudity is seen as a norm. We could research and compare. It doesn't even take traveling away from the Western civilization; just compare the US and, say, Germany, with their vastly different sensitivity to depicted or real-life nudity.
- LeanderK 8y agoI don't agree. Europe had a culture where the current handling of sexuality in the internet would be considered prude. There were people running around naked in the cities parks, munich was sort of famous for a these naked people in their park in the middle of the city center (englischer Garten). It's the biggest, most central park and munich and people go there with their work-colleagues for a beer after a long day. There was a strong nudity culture in germany/europe and nudity wasn't something that was entirely sexual. But now it seems to be entirely sexual, at least on the internet. > When I Google something in a meeting or in front of my mother, I do not want sexual results to appear because some term has an alternate meaning I don't agee. Not every mention of sexuality is arousing and when something sexual appears and is embarassing for you, that's a cultural thing. I don't see sexual things appearing when you google stuff front of your mother as embarassing in by human nature, I think it's entirely cultural. I honestly don't know whether I would care? My mother is an adult human being after all and smart enought to know that there's an alternate meaning and I didn't want to google sexual stuff with her! I really don't think this would be a problem at all? > but we certainly don't want to watch a steamy sex scene together This was weird when I was a teenager, where steamy sex scenes can overwhelme you very quick. But sex scenes are an important part of many movies, it's part of human nature after all. For example, I like art and my father likes art. When I am in my parents city and we go into a museum together, there are many artworks displaying nudity and some are explicitly concerened with the various forms of sexuality. There's no akwardness there, because we're both adults. > So having major internet services like Google and Facebook default to being non-sexual seems like a pretty smart move to me. It may be a smart move from a corporate point of view, but I really think it shapes our culture and defines what is a taboo and what not, they are just too powerfull. I don't think it's good that you can't post pictures of nudity on facebook. Nudity doesn't have to sexual. And if you argue that you shouldn't do that because some eployer could google you and sees you half naked, then that's also cultural, I think. Also, there's a privacy setting in facebook.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> When I Google something in a meeting or in front of my mother, I do not want sexual results to appear because some term has an alternate meaning. The solution for this is to have a cookie to show NSFW content or not, and if you have it set then the content is still there but you get a box in front of it saying "you have chosen not to see this", so that you actually know there is something relevant there that you're not seeing. > And then there are still countless sites on the internet devoted entirely to sex. Keeping them largely separated seems smart. The problem with kicking people off the platform or otherwise purposely preventing discovery is that the lines aren't nearly clear enough as would be so convenient. For example, sometimes sex workers need to get together with civil liberties organizations, or media organizations, or the general public. If you silo the sex workers off into their own universe, how does that happen? They can't come to the big sites because they're immediately banned, because attempting to communicate about their lived experience gets them flagged by an algorithm that isn't smart enough to understand context. But the others can't come to them because their sites are exclusively NSFW, which means companies ban the sites or employees fear being punished for visiting them on company time. Then we get more garbage like SESTA, which the people it was supposed to "protect" hate because it makes their lives less safe, but they have no voice in the matter because companies decided the public isn't supposed to hear from them. > And while what happened to Tumblr was very sad, I'm sure other sites will replace it... it's the internet after all. Sure, after years to rebuild another community. But then what happens when that site gets popular enough for a major company to buy it and decide they want to do the same thing? Having your community destroyed every time it becomes sufficiently popular is a real problem.
- crazygringo 8y ago1) Google already has that cookie, it defaults to SafeSearch but you can turn it off. 2) Sex workers don't need to display sexualized nudity to organize. I'm talking about not wanting to see explicit hardcore stills from pornos in my search results by default. I would never argue against anyone's right to organize and be heard, and I don't think many other people are arguing for that either. 3) There's no evidence that what happened to Tumblr is a systemic problem of the internet as a whole. Digg and Reader also shot themselves in the foot -- sometimes companies make dumb mistakes, that's all.
- house_atr 8y agoSeriously I don't get how promiscuous people complain shit censorship and shame when we are increasingly living in a society where people will cry bloody murder if they can't push their degeneracy on the rest of us and we just have to obey. Watch, someone will have a problem with my word selection of degeneracy. I should have used sex positive or some other nonsense like that.