19 ms·
>>Unless you know something the insurance seller does not that makes you more likely to be paid out than others, then it is a waste of money to buy insurance fo
by gambiting 8y ago
>>Unless you know something the insurance seller does not that makes you more likely to be paid out than others, then it is a waste of money to buy insurance for a loss that you can afford.
That's....insane. Fires happen. Theft happens. Thunderstorms happen. Kids breaking things happen. Yes I can "afford" to replace most things in my house - but why would I risk all of my savings if I can pay ~20 quid a month and not worry about it??
- sokoloff 8y agoI would change the qualifier to "comfortably afford" , but I do self-insure on most things. Take an extremely poor insurance bet as an example. The electronics store will offer you an extended warranty plan on your new TV. An LG 55" LED TV (UK6090PUA) is $400 right now at BestBuy. 2 years of "protection plan" on that TV is $50. Do you think that anywhere near 1 in 8 TVs need any kind of service in 2 years, let alone something that would require the replacement of the TV? Sure, there are people who pay $450 for their TV instead of $400 and come out ahead. The vast majority don't and most people can easily shoulder the burden of buying a new TV when their current one breaks. (By the way, that insurance policy allows the insurer, at their sole discretion, to pay you the market value of your TV rather than repair/replace it.) I self-insure against collision on our cars (meaning I dropped collision coverage). Collision insurance (covering repairing/replacing of our cars) was running around $1000 per year for 2 drivers and 3 cars. In 20 years, between insurance savings and investing the savings, I've banked about $40K by not carrying collision. Not only could I cover a collision now, I could buy 3 replacement cars outright and have money left over and don't have to deal with any insurance paperwork to do so... I do carry liability insurance (at high limits) for auto. I have our home insured. I have a high-deductible medical insurance plan. I'm not anti-insurance in general; I am anti-insurance for losses that can be easily weathered.
- Retric 8y agoI would drop that to trivially afford. Getting a new TV is the kind of thing most people on HN would barely think twice about. At which point the cost benifit simple. But, move up a few rungs to say a 5,000$ massage chair and you could replace it or do without but most people would feel it. Further, the policy is likely to be closer to 1/20th the price at something like 250$. It’s still a bad deal, but you can feel better about your overall purchase knowing it will last at least X years.
- ravar 8y agoWhy are you buying a 5000$ massage chair if you can't comfortably afford to replace it?
- gambiting 8y agoWhat a weird question. I sometimes feel like people on this website are super ultra rich. Like $100k+/year salaries rich. I feel like anything up to say $300-400 I can "comfortably" replace - but more than that and it's starting to eat into my savings, which obviously I don't want to do. Like, my $800 TV is not expensive by most peoples standards, yet if I had to replace it it would be two months of my savings. That's not trivial or comfortable in any way. Maybe I wouldn't buy a $5000 massage chair, but I own a ~$2000 solid oak table and chairs specifically because I want it to last few decades, it's a really solid table. But I couldn't "comfortably" afford to replace it. That's what insurance is for.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoYou also rarely need to replace TVs, massage chairs, and solid oak tables. The other aspect is the need to replace. You can live without a TV while you build up savings, you can live without a solid oak table, but you can't live without a vehicle to get to work, or a home to live in.
- ravar 8y agoThis is context you might find interesting, I make less than 40k a year. This is a choice that I have made, and I understand that it has implications for the lifestyle I can afford.
- Spooky23 8y agoThere’s a mix of overpaid software people and the weird tech libertarian-ish attitude towards many issues. Just roll with it.
- Retric 8y agoMostly I am just using it as an example of a durable good. Let’s say it’s going to last ~5 years on average then that’s a little under 20$ per week you can set aside for the next one. For something used regularly providing 20$ a week in value is a minimal hurdle, but that does not mean they can drop the full cost on a whim. Making the extended warranty a more understandable choice.
- notahacker 8y agoI've seen worse insurance bets than that: mobile phone companies offering insurance at fees and excess levels where you'd have to lose or break two phones a year for the insurance company to return more in claims than you pay in premiums!
- Nursie 8y agoThe TV insurance thing is effectively a scam. Your home insurance likely covers accidental damage, and your consumer rights cover any breakdown in that sort of time (depending on where you live).
- brewdad 8y agoI agree it's a scam but even if my HO insurance would coverage accidental damage, I'm not making that claim. I have to pay the first $500 no matter what, then my rates will go up. Worst case, my insurance company drops me and I have to scramble to find another company since lapses in coverage lead to all sorts of issues. Still, I'm not buying the store's insurance on a TV. I might buy it on my teenager's phone or laptop depending on price and coverage.
- sametmax 8y agoIt must not happen that often, otherwise insurances would not make much money. Those events likelyhood, the cost of them, and what the insurance will actually pay you back are probably way off what you think it is in your mind. Now I do think insurance is important for catastrophic events: low likelyhood, but incredible cost, because you can't take this chance at the scale of an entire society. But for theft or kids breaking things, I'm not so sure.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoThe insurance company is taking your money, and investing in an index fund, and returning it to you minus their payroll and profit margin. You can take the same money, and invest it in the index fund, and if and when you need it, sell your assets to pay for the loss. But you get to avoid paying the insurance company's employees. You wouldn't buy insurance for the bag of rice you buy at a grocery store in case you drop it outdoors, the bag splits open and the rice is ruined. Why? Because you can easily afford buying another bag of rice. The same reasoning applies to a car. If you have sufficient savings, you can buy yourself a new car if and when you need to. Until then, just invest the savings and reap the investment rewards, exactly like the insurance company will be doing. But suppose you can afford to buy a new car (like many higher income professionals in the US), but you can't afford to pay for someone else's $500k to $1M medical bills (like almost everyone). Then you would forego the collision insurance for the vehicle, but still purchase the bodily injury liability and personal injury protection insurance.
- roganartu 8y ago> You wouldn't buy insurance for the bag of rice you buy at a grocery store in case you drop it outdoors, the bag splits open and the rice is ruined. Why? Because you can easily afford buying another bag of rice. > The same reasoning applies to a car. If you have sufficient savings, you can buy yourself a new car if and when you need to. Until then, just invest the savings and reap the investment rewards, exactly like the insurance company will be doing. But it's not the same reasoning. I can afford to buy hundreds of bags of rice every month if I need to, without stretching my budget significantly. Rice for me is pocket change, so yes insurance would make no sense. For the vast majority of people, a car is not pocket change. Sure high income people might be able to buy another and not go bankrupt, but there's a big difference between being able to afford something, and considering the expense pocket change.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoThe reasoning is: If you can't afford to replace it, then you purchase insurance for it. Replace "it" with whatever you want. Just because a car is not pocket change, doesn't mean you can't afford to easily replace it. And maybe if you feel that it will cause you stress or stretch you thin, then it doesn't fit the definition of "afford to replace it". Auto insurance company has way more data than you do on how likely it is that they will need to replace your car, so they will charge you appropriately, plus their salaries. So if you have a sufficient emergency fund, then you don't need the insurance, just like you don't need it for the bag of rice.
- mcguire 8y agoIf you are risking all your savings, you can't afford to self insure.
- tehwebguy 8y agoSeriously. $1500 auto insurance / yr x 60 yrs of driving is less than the cost of a single catostrophic wreck, even if no one dies.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoYou can insure just the more expensive parts of a collision, such as liability for others' property and medical care.
- brewdad 8y agoYou seriously underestimate the cost of a significant wreck in the US. The medical bills alone could reach into the hundreds of thousands. The pain of paying $100/mo for insurance vs having to come up with $250,000 all at once makes insurance a no-brainer. My state used to allow drivers to self-insure (I think they removed the option for individuals recently). I was a really bad deal though, since you had to give the state a minimum $50,000 deposit interest free. It's cheaper to just pay for insurance and earn the returns on your cash.
- tehwebguy 8y agoYeah I think you misread it, I said that the cost of premiums over 60 years is much LESS than a single catastrophic wreck :)
- csomar 8y agoIf it happens once on a lifetime and you can afford it: You just calculate how much it'll cost in insurance policy vs invested in government bonds. The other point: I think most people here are concerned with the insurance paying up once the real deal happen. Most of the time the insurance will: 1. take a lengthy legal path to exhaust you 2. pull some article that you didn't notice from the contract to get away with it. So you are screwed twice. ouch. I'm not claiming insurances are a scam and you should avoid them. I'm using them. But I can understand why some people are frustrated.