59 ms·
Sometimes I wonder how (un-)realistic it is to fill a complain with the EU of google misusing it's quasi monopoly on search to actively discriminate against: -
by dathinab 8y ago
Sometimes I wonder how (un-)realistic it is to fill a complain with the EU of google misusing it's quasi monopoly on search to actively discriminate against:
- People with open opinions about sex (e.g. down ranking there blog posts etc.).
- People which had been victims of sexual violence (and similar) by making it harder for them to inform them self/get help.
- Sex workers.
- etc.
(note that this is a unordered list!)
Same goes for other platforms e.g. PayPal.
Sure there might be a difference if you use a platform to display pornographic content to people
without appropriate age checks. But non of this
applies for Google (search) or PayPal (payment).
Lastly people might argue that they are just following US law (e.g. for PayPal) but if they operate in the EU then they will have to follow EU law and discrimination against people for _any_ reason is illegal, this includes excluding a blog from search results because it openly speaks about
porn or people _legal_ earning money with videos of their naked body.
Well but then I'm not a lawyer and didn't really think this through either ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- thaumasiotes 8y ago> if they operate in the EU then they will have to follow EU law and discrimination against people for _any_ reason is illegal This is totally incoherent. Lack of discrimination is the problem that Google solves. Search results can't all be first; that would be the same thing as not having a search engine at all.
- LeanderK 8y agoi don't agree. Google ranks, but shouldn't be allowed to treat one group unfairly. For example, google shouldn't be allowed to downrank one ethnicity and prefer another. Similiar, google shouldn't be allowed to "forcefully" downrank one's blog, just because it doesn't like some thoughts about sexuality (I don't know if it does though). It's not that google has the total freedom to adjust the search-ranking like it sees fit. I don't know how the law is implemented, but I bet they have a good definition what illegal discrimination actually is. For example, I don't think google would be allowed to rank results (or, as you say it, discriminate) based on gender.
- thaumasiotes 8y agoThe comment I responded to explicitly states that "discrimination for _any_ reason is illegal". That doesn't work and can't work; it's not even meaningful. By that standard, the existence of Google is, in itself, criminal.
- LeanderK 8y agoah ok, then I've misunderstood your comment :)
- seba_dos1 8y agoNo, it isn't. You're just using the wrong meaning of an overloaded word. Definition of discrimination 1a : prejudiced or prejudicial outlook, action, or treatment racial discrimination b : the act, practice, or an instance of discriminating categorically rather than individually 2 : the quality or power of finely distinguishing the film viewed by those with discrimination 3a : the act of making or perceiving a difference : the act of discriminating a bloodhound's scent discrimination b psychology : the process by which two stimuli differing in some aspect are responded to differently (https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/discrimination https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/discrimination)
- sametmax 8y agoFor google it's not that bad. I have a niche french blog about Python and porn. Had it for years. Google still brought 10 millions views to us since it started. We are ranked pretty well in the french version of the search engine. Now It's true I have now way of knowing how well we would rank without the porn, but funnily, it's 10% of the content, but 60% of the traffic.
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y agoRegarding your first three points: open opinions about sex; victims of sexual assault; sex workers. Have you tested any of these on google.com recently? I have and I do regularly. There is definitely no shortage of results when looking for information / blogs about any of these three. I'm in Australia, but the results appear to cover the Anglosphere in general. The search term blogs about earning money with porn appears to be an industry in and of itself, and well represented on Google search results. So, in response to your initial question, I'm going to go with: exceedingly unrealistic.