7 ms·
Man, how is it defensible that they delete forum posts talking about the issue? Same with denying keyboardgate, this firmly puts their products in my do-not-buy
by netsharc 8y ago
Man, how is it defensible that they delete forum posts talking about the issue? Same with denying keyboardgate, this firmly puts their products in my do-not-buy list, because they'll even deny being terrible product engineers when their products break and turn your money to paperweight.
- threeseed 8y agoApple never denied the keyboard issues. They offered an extended warranty and fixed the core issue in a subsequent design.
- whitepoplar 8y agoI have the most recent 2018 MacBook Pro and I still get stuck keys.
- threeseed 8y agoStuck keys are an issue on every laptop if you get something under the mechanism. The problem in the 2016/2017 models was that you couldn't fix the issue because the dust etc was firmly embedded. The 2018 model has a membrane underneath so you should be able to fix the keys with compressed air.
- kalleboo 8y agoThe membrane still has holes in it, letting dust get trapped inside the delicate parts. It just reduces the risk of dust getting inside in the first place
- chatterbeak 8y agoI don't remember every having a stuck key on my Lenovo or my Surface.
- darkpuma 8y agoIf I ate a sandwich over my old thinkpad and crumbs got under the keys, I'd just push the keys harder to crush the crumbs into dust. Total non-issue for the better part of a decade. It's only when keyboards become thin and delicate that durability becomes a problem.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- whitepoplar 8y agoI've tried with compressed air and it's only a temporary fix. Same issue w/ 2016-7 MacBook Pros.
- highace 8y agoI'm convinced the problem with these keyboards isn't always debris under the keys. I've noticed it's often E and R, the keys right above the heatpipe system, which suggests that heat could be warping or damaging the contacts. This is even worse.
- samatman 8y agoI have owned five Apple laptops and six Apple keyboards in total. Two of those I used hard enough that keys fell off. This latest is the only one which has had issues with the keys not working. Even the ones missing keys, there was a small nub left that still worked. The main key failure has been the left Command key, which is an utter disaster. I’m furious about it. Not quite furious enough to give up 15 years of the Mac. But close.
- whitepoplar 8y agoSame issue with the Command key on mine!
- Jare 8y agoOver the past 20 years I have owned various laptops from HP, MSi, Acer, Apple, and also (for my desktops) external keyboards from a number of additional vendors. The only keyboard that ever had any trouble was after I gave it to my 4yo and over time he got all sorts of food inside it. My work 2018 mpb showed a stuck key after 2 weeks (no food near it), and it obviously is not bad luck on my part.
- setquk 8y agoI returned a 2018 MacBook Air with the membrane because it failed with the same failure mode. Then I got duplicate key presses. I now use a thinkpad.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoYes, if you used to get a bit of toast stuck under the keys of an old Thinkpad you just bash the key a couple of times and the crumb breaks up a little. Problem solved. Clear out any crumbs, dust and accumulated pet hair every now and then for neatness. Only '16 and on model Macbooks seem to require a cleanroom for the keyboard.
- pier25 8y agoMaybe, but I've never experienced that problem on any laptop I've owned. I've been buying laptops for almost 20 years.
- Someone1234 8y agoApple only offered the extended warranty and fix after they were sued multiple times including class suits. It took them almost two years after the first faulty laptop shipped for those steps to be taken. Let's not re-write history here.
- mehrdada 8y ago"Never" is the wrong word here. They offer "quality program" long after the issue was discovered like: - MacBook Air 2008 broken hinge issues - image retention issues with Retina 2012 model - GPU issues with NVIDIA GPU in Retina 2012 model only to name a few that I personally faced that they later admitted to only after you likely fixed it out of pocket yourself (or sold the device) and with threats of lawsuit.
- hopler 8y agoI'll refer back to this post next time someone repeats the canard the apple hardware was perfect until Jobs died. Also the 2008 era white plastic MacBooks whose shells cracked and flaked off into sharp edges.
- krackers 8y ago>2012 model Don't forget the infamous 2011 model! And it's less publicized but a similar GPU issue affected the 2010 models as well.
- mehrdada 8y agoI was personally affected by all those three I had listed, among other things. To add, I also personally faced: - The 2016-2017 keyboard issue on all MacBooks of that generation I had (5-6 devices). - The MacBook Air 2008 "core shutdown" issue that the machine thermally throttled itself to a grind and shut down all but a single core. - Most recently, I faced a water damage issue with iPhone XS Max (the device is advertised as water resistant). Class action lawsuit, anyone? My face gets grim when I have to admit that I am still a customer, even an advocate, because all the competitors produce mostly crap, insecure, poorly-made and/or invade your privacy. I have, however, started to break the ecosystem chain. There's been obviously plenty more. Especially on the GPU side it was super annoying. Most of these things will break even after they "fix" it under their quality programs.
- willtim 8y ago> I am still a customer, even an advocate, because all the competitors produce mostly crap, insecure, poorly-made and/or invade your privacy Not true. There is hardware that is better made and more reliable than Apple (e.g. ThinkPad) and operating systems that are far more secure (e.g. Qubes).
- saagarjha 8y agoAs much as people love to exaggerate issues with Apple's products, Apple itself isn't particularly great when it comes to acknowledging hardware issues.
- cm2187 8y agoNeither is Microsoft, I owned a Surface pro and it was barely usable. Lots of people having the same experience, Paul Thurott being vocal about it. Microsoft remaining in denial. Not sure if the denial had any effect on people purchase decisions but I would never buy another Microsoft computer again.
- tapland 8y agoI had an insane amount of network issues with my Surface Pro 3, and it received 35+ software updates regarding the marvel adapter over years before it started being reliable.
- 43920 8y agoNo, they didn't. First, they pretended the issue didn't exist, while charging people hundreds of dollars for new keyboards. Then, they announced a "quality program", where they'll replace your broken keyboard with another, equally defective one for 4 years. So after the 4 years is up, your keyboard is going to break again, and you'll have to pay again or get a new laptop. While they did change the keyboard design in 2018, there are still reports that the "improved" keyboard is failing as well: https://www.reddit.com/r/applehelp/comments/9w6vk3/macbook_pro_2018_keyboard_failed_spacebar_often/ https://www.reddit.com/r/applehelp/comments/9w6vk3/macbook_p... https://www.reddit.com/r/applehelp/comments/9w6vk3/macbook_pro_2018_keyboard_failed_spacebar_often/ https://www.reddit.com/r/applehelp/comments/9w6vk3/macbook_p... https://twitter.com/kapeli/status/1090640259921166336 https://twitter.com/kapeli/status/1090640259921166336
- xnyan 8y ago"improved" was a non-sealing dust jacket and even then apple was too chicken-shit coward to say it was an attempt to keep foreign particles entering the hinge. Apple called the addition a noise masking element, in my opinion an attempt to avoid giving evidence for any litigation against them that may come up. Maybe this is all great business sense, but it really makes me consider if buying another apple laptop is a good idea.
- dethac 8y agoIt is great business sense. It keeps from giving the opposition ammunition in their lawsuit... It's just a shame that good business sense isn't exactly good for the user.
- BOOSTERHIDROGEN 8y agoMagic keyboard also suffer from this design
- arvinsim 8y agoReally? I thought that they were using the same design from the original Magic Keyboard :(
- colemickens 8y agoProbably close to a year ago, someone posted a cynical fictional example timeline of discovery of MBP problems, (deleted) threads in Apple's forum, Apples' (lack of and) eventual response and the fans' denials and acceptance throughout. It highlighted the stages of denial, censorship, acceptance, revision, etc. It was pretty snarky but would up being pretty on the nose given what happened in the subsequent months as it was more discussed, officially acknowledged and then somewhat addressed in a hardware revision. I think about that comment every month or so when another MBP article pops up here. I'd be grateful for a link if anyone knows the HN comment I'm thinking of.
- sneak 8y agoIt’s defensible because people who have had a first gen of every new r/MBP for the last five years who experience no problems whatsoever (such as myself) do not take to the Apple support forums to post their counter anecdata, and Apple is a hardware vendor, and it would be terrible for people prior to sale to visit the Apple website (ie the support forums) and get a wildly inaccurate picture of hardware reliability from only seeing posts from a small fraction of people having problems. It's (self) selection set bias. As a shareholder, I entirely support exercising this type of control of the message (on their own website). It is the right thing to do. Nobody has any right to have their words hosted on apple.com except Apple, and I would prefer that anyone with a sample size of less than ten not post negative things about their products on a site potential customers visit. You may not agree with it, but this is a legitimate defense of what they are doing.
- appleflaxen 8y agopeople understand that forums are there to get support, and that five-year owners with no issues don't post. but taking down posts that expose a design flaw is terrible customer service, and borderline unethical.
- sneak 8y agoThe determination of whether or not it's a design flaw is subjective. It could be a manufacturing flaw; millions of touchbar retina MBPs have been sold, and it seems that the issues are affecting hundreds or perhaps single digit thousands. A design flaw would manifest in a much larger percentage of machines, would it not?
- pier25 8y agoSame thing happened during Radeongate, the GPU problem that affected thousands of 2011 MBP models. My top of the line MBP 2011 died in 2013, 2.5 years after buying it. At that point Apple denied any problems. Over a year later, with a couple of class action lawsuits on its back, Apple started a repair program. Of course I had already bought another machine to be able to work, so after repairing the 2011 I found myself with a very expensive MBP that was about 4 years old at this point. I didn't have a use for it and of course nobody wanted to buy it at a decent price because of its infamous problems. The expensive investment I made in 2011 went down the drain. The repair program was just a dick move to avoid legal problems. If Apple had wanted a fair compensation to their customers they would have taken those machines back and given 60% of the price paid in credit for buying Apple products, which is what a 3-4 year old Mac sells for. After that I lost all faith in Apple and am much more careful with what I buy from them.
- vbuwivbiu 8y agothere's always been something odd about Apple's forums. You'll see that almost any post detailing a problem is immediately replied to by apologists telling the OP that somehow _they_ are at fault.
- dethac 8y agoYou're looking at it wrong. It isn't a dent, it's an aesthetic mark to help differentiate your device and deter thieves. OMG you just don't get it do you? You must use a personal computer.