5 ms·
No loss for Facebook. I've had vigorous discussions about Snopes with friends. I'm mostly conservative, I feel Snopes has a liberal bias. My liberal friends
by RickJWagner 8y ago
No loss for Facebook.
I've had vigorous discussions about Snopes with friends. I'm mostly conservative, I feel Snopes has a liberal bias. My liberal friends feel otherwise.
After much back-and-forth, what we found is this:
- Snopes seems to be careful about printing only true things
- But Snopes controls the narrative and decides which issues to fact-check. They seem to publish a lot more material that validates left-leaning opinions than right-leaning ones
At the time of last checking, Snopes had a single political fact-checker, she was a staunch Democrat.
- chrisseaton 8y agoIt’s like the BBC in the UK - half the population think it’s left biased and the other half think it’s right biased.
- MeltySmelty 8y agoI don't think anyone views Snopes as right leaning. If they do, they might want to look around the site.
- RickJWagner 8y agoI do admit I see the BBC as left-leaning. I just finished reading a BBC article on Jussie Smollett, the actor in the news this week. The BBC article gave no hint the issue under discussion is anything less than accepted fact as Smollett presents it. A review of police findings (especially video reviews) suggests there is much to be investigated. I can't see how the BBC justifies this.
- sn41 8y agoI'm Indian, I think the BBC has an anti-India bias, and is heavily politically conservative, but socially liberal. The one thing I do give the BBC credit for, is that they did not resort to overt mud-slinging against Jeremy Corbyn, as opposed to the Guardian.
- MeltySmelty 8y agoExactly, it's a garbage website anyway.
- jewelthief91 8y agoSpot on. You don't need to lie when you control which truths are allowed to be told.
- pfisch 8y agoI think what you said about choosing what to fact check is true, however, it is also true that spreading propaganda/intentional false information is a massive problem on the right, and a much smaller problem on the left. It exists and is an issue, but there is a massive industry on the right that willfully spreads false information and it encompasses almost every conservative media outlet. All of the big political commentators on the right do it constantly all the way up to the president who tells nonstop lies.
- matis140 8y agothe left is just better at producing propaganda. do not forget most of our universities have become extreme left and the papers they write reflect this. It is not an accident the way money has corrupted research.
- Sohcahtoa82 8y ago> do not forget most of our universities have become extreme left I'd posit that people on the left typically value education more than people on the right and are therefore more likely to attend universities. > and the papers they write reflect this. It is not an accident the way money has corrupted research. I read this as "research is coming up with conclusions that don't fit my world view/opinions/beliefs and I don't like it."
- leesalminen 8y agoThe HN equivalent of the deplorables comment.
- Sohcahtoa82 8y agoMeaning it was rude and unprofessional, yet undeniably true?
- mulmen 8y agoIf I crank the steering wheel of my car hard right the center line of the freeway doesn't actually move. It might appear that way from my little bubble but reality stays the same. From the perspective of a typical Fox News viewer education has a strong left bias because they're effectively driving on the shoulder.
- eridius 8y agoIf Snopes is doing more conservative fact-checks than liberal fact-checks, it's probably because the modern Republican party seems to have made "lying" into one of its core principles (this is most certainly true for the President, and is at the very least a common pastime for other Republican bigwigs). > At the time of last checking, Snopes had a single political fact-checker, she was a staunch Democrat. What's your source on this? Snopes's own documentation for their team doesn't indicate that any particular person is "the single political fact-checker", and Snopes itself is run by 2 passionately apolitical people. I just did a random sampling of several of the "latest fact checks" that appear to relate to politics (e.g. about Nancy Pelosi, Kamala Harris, or Trump) and in the first 5 facts I checked, I found 4 different writers. So as far as I can tell, it's not remotely true that they have "a single political fact-checker".
- sremani 8y agoThe OP was describing Snopes Pre-Trump era and much of the 2016 election cycle, I think he was ball park right.
- RickJWagner 8y agoHave a look at this article from Forbes. The assertions (if true) are pretty harsh against Snopes. Please give it a fair read, offer your perspective. https://www.forbes.com/sites/kalevleetaru/2016/12/22/the-daily-mail-snopes-story-and-fact-checking-the-fact-checkers/#16860012227f https://www.forbes.com/sites/kalevleetaru/2016/12/22/the-dai...
- cauthon 8y agoThat's not an article from Forbes. It's a blog post hosted on the Forbes website. Any Forbes.com/sites/{something} page isn't Forbes content, it's independent content unaffiliated with the Forbes editorial team
- RickJWagner 8y agoFair enough, thanks for the correction. Still, if the assertions are true, it raises concerns.
- gscott 8y agoWithout the fake news of 2016 Facebook has become very boring. Facebook was much more exciting when people were promoting crazy almost Onion like stories and you couldn't tell if the person sharing it believed it or not... or they believed it I could feel high and mighty that they couldn't tell the difference of it being fake. Now my news feed today shows a video of a woman wrapping her dog in Christmas paper and another video of what life is with a cat vs not having a cat. Ok so I watched half of those two videos but Facebook is back to being a boring vehicle of an occasional post by a family member and random cat/dog/cooking/making something videos.
- IAmEveryone 8y agoYeah, sure. Let’s bring back the racist bullshit undermining democracy for your entertainment.
- gscott 8y agoYes because on the same platform where I consume cat videos I get all of my news where I'm going to choose on how to vote? It's an argument that can go on forever but if people are changing their votes based upon what they see on social media they should be more informed.
- Sohcahtoa82 8y ago> But Snopes controls the narrative and decides which issues to fact-check. There's definitely truth to that and worth some concern. > They seem to publish a lot more material that validates left-leaning opinions than right-leaning ones Probably because while media on both sides has their bias and will twist the facts a bit to fit their narrative, right-wing media just invents complete lies and falsehoods. Nobody on the left has even come close to something as dumb as Pizzagate.
- eclipxe 8y agoReality has a liberal bias.
- wolco 8y agoUntil you are 35
- kstrauser 8y agoI'm not sold on Snopes, either. I don't know whether they have a bias, but I'm not convinced they're terribly accurate. For instance, they have a debunking of the myth that Marilyn Monroe use to have six toes. Part of their evidence was that if she did, and it were removed, then it would affect her balance and she would have to re-learn to walk normally, let alone gracefully. My wife is a podiatrist. A significant part of her job is lopping off toes. I asked her if that was true, and she said that it absolutely was not. Her post-amputation patients are routinely perfectly fine and have no trouble walking. Even losing your big toe isn't a huge deal. Try it yourself: point it upward so that it doesn't touch the ground and walk around some. It's not hard at all. I wrote them to share the information. I agreed that the myth was false, but that the bit about her being unable to walk afterward wasn't good supporting evidence. They replied with a snide comment basically accusing me of believing that Marilyn had six toes (which I absolutely don't believe, or more precisely, I could not care less about). Since then I've read a lot of their debunking skeptically. I mean, I think they mean well and I'm sure they're mostly accurate. However, I have first hand experience with them being unwilling to vet their own evidence. If they can play fast and loose with a goofy story about an extra toe, are they being rigorous elsewhere? I don't know.
- tzs 8y ago> They seem to publish a lot more material that validates left-leaning opinions than right-leaning ones Do you still see an imbalance if you take out one or both of the following: 1. Fact checking of President Trump, and 2. Fact checking of politicians' claims on matters of science? President Trump makes a lot more statements than any other politician, especially on Twitter, making a lot of very specific and objectively reviewable claims that often have no support even from conservative sources. He is the President, and so a fact checking site can't really ignore him. He's basically a huge outlier, and this alone is probably going to push any fair and balanced fact checking site into appearing left leaning. For example, he Tweeted "We are not even into February and the cost of illegal immigration so far this year is $18,959,495,168. Cost Friday was $603,331,392. There are at least 25,772,342 illegal aliens, not the 11,000,000 that have been reported for years, in our Country. So ridiculous! DHS". Nobody can figure out where he got those numbers, his staff says they don't know, and they are about twice as high as even conservative anti-immigrant groups claim. And he does this kind of Tweet a lot. As far as science goes, both liberal and conservative politicians do have problems with putting ideology ahead of facts, but not with the same sciences. For example, I think liberals are more likely than conservatives to think there is a connection between autism and vaccines, and so take a political position on vaccination that is at odds with science. Conservatives are more likely to think climate change is not happening, or if it is that human activity does not affect it, and so take a political position on that at odds with science. But vaccination is simply not something that comes up as often as climate in the news, meaning that there is simply less opportunity for politicians to says something stupid about vaccines than there is for them to say something stupid about climate. Vaccination rates are usually only going to become prominent enough to prompt politicians to make stupid statements when we have something like a measles outbreak which is still fairly rare. With climate, all it takes is some cold weather to get a few politicians to stupidly say that this proves that the climate is not warming, and this happens several times a year. (Also, the vaccination situation is muddled by the people who are against vaccination requirements for religion reasons or personal liberty reasons rather than misunderstanding autism, and these people tend to be more on the right than the left).