3 ms·
The correlation between energy use and ability to pay large tax bills is at best, loose. Alaskans on average consume >5x the amount of energy New Yorkers, whic
by notahacker 16y ago
The correlation between energy use and ability to pay large tax bills is at best, loose. Alaskans on average consume >5x the amount of energy New Yorkers, which certainly doesn't reflect their respective per capita incomes
http://www.census.gov/statab/ranks/rank30.html http://www.census.gov/statab/ranks/rank30.html
On average the rich use energy more than average people, but the proportional difference isn't huge, and it's pretty safe to assume the top 1% of earners aren't consuming anywhere close to 20-30% of household energy.
Replacing income tax with a levy on energy would be regressive beyond belief, to the point where I don't think it would be possible to match the returns generated by the current system and maintain a minimum tax-free level of fuel consumption that would allow the average person in some states to stay warm and be able to travel to work on a daily basis.
And this is coming from someone who gets by comfortably paying approx 4x the fuel tax Americans do...
- jackfoxy 16y agoEvery qualifying person (citizen, legal resident, TBD) would have a baseline exemption. As you point out energy requirement varies by geography, and the exemption would also have to be geographic sensitive. More importantly, such an energy based tax system would result in the vast majority of tax being remitted by business and institutions, not individuals. Businesses would not be able to avoid taxation through accounting tricks, but at the same time the cost to business of paying tax would be eliminated because it requires no bookkeeping. Like all taxes on business, this reflects in cost of products and services. Less energy intensive products and services become more competitive on cost.