4 ms·
For all the complaining, can you point to anyone, anywhere, who has been harmed by Google Analytics? There are real issues with privacy, but the scaremongering
by skybrian 8y ago
For all the complaining, can you point to anyone, anywhere, who has been harmed by Google Analytics?
There are real issues with privacy, but the scaremongering sometimes seems to be independent of any actual harm to users.
- wool_gather 8y agoWithout commenting on Google Analytics itself, why on earth would we wait until after something bad happens? If real risks can be identified, then one should think seriously about whether they outweigh the gains. If the gains are worth the risk, then that's fine, but there's nothing "scaremongering" about pointing out things that could go wrong. That's at least half of engineering as a discipline.
- skybrian 8y agoThat's a good point and I would like to read a good risk analysis. The problem is that when large companies are involved, you get very superficial risk analysis. Something analogous to: "The worst thing that could happen if I put my money in a bank is they take all my money. So, we shouldn't put money in banks." If you point out that this generally doesn't happen people will talk about what the company could do. How do we get beyond fully general arguments that you can never trust any company to do anything (or alternatively that theoretical risks don't matter)? I guess to really understand the risk you'd have to understand a company's internal controls, and those generally aren't public.
- unclebucknasty 8y agoMany define the harm as the loss of privacy itself. In the case of analytics, this would be particularly egregious: the user gives up privacy to a third party, generally without knowledge and with no direct benefit.
- skybrian 8y agoSee, this is treating "loss of privacy" as an abstraction meaning "any information somehow derived, no matter how indirectly, from my behavior." That's something I fundamentally disagree with. When people get upset about it then I have a hard time taking it seriously. If I log all the hits to my website and generate aggregate reports based on that, there's no personal information disclosed in the reports. Nobody is harmed and they have no case, as far as I'm concerned. It's the same if I'm outsourcing to Google.
- unclebucknasty 8y agoI've heard this argument and, sure, some people just don't care. Privacy. Shmivacy. But, the thing is the example you gave is just a matter of degree. I mean, if you sold the logs with PII, location info, etc, then that would be near the other end of the privacy continuum. And, since you explicitly provided an example that included aggregate vs personal info, then I assume even you would care about the latter. So, the question is, at what point along the continuum do you begin to care? Following that, surely you'd allow that others may choose a different point and that, given that it's their privacy, maybe their concerns shouldn't be summarily dismissed? But, beyond that, the example you gave is invalid. There is a qualitative difference between you logging information about visitors who have chosen to visit your site, versus participating in a scheme to provide that information to a third party who your visitor did not choose to visit. This is especially so when that third party is then able to compile a dossier on that visitor's broader behavior, based on other site-owners who participate. Add to this that Google is frequently able to personally identify that visitor via their Google login.
- skybrian 8y agoRather than turn this into a one-bit argument (people who either care or don't care about privacy), I would rather talk about privacy risks for vulnerable populations, like activists or people who have crazy exes. A privacy risk is when data could be disclosed to someone who could use it against you. I'm not sure any of them are threatened by Google Analytics? Google's terms of use prohibit uploading PII to Google Analytics, and it appears they upload data to a separate domain [1], so at least if you don't enable the DoubleClick cookie (which, if you're responsible you shouldn't do), they don't seem to have a way to correlate Google Analytics data with Google logins. But I only did a shallow investigation. show me the risk and threat model and I'll care. [1] https://developers.google.com/analytics/resources/concepts/gaConceptsTrackingOverview https://developers.google.com/analytics/resources/concepts/g...