6 ms·
> meaning there's little to no interest buying books online meaning there is no competition and prices are artificially inflated for no particular reason excep
by ekianjo 8y ago
> meaning there's little to no interest buying books online
meaning there is no competition and prices are artificially inflated for no particular reason except some ideological one. I'm not sure it's a good case for regulating the price of books.
My observation: Japan has WAY more bookshops than France without any regulation of book prices. And they produce a LOT more books locally than France ever does.
- adamsea 8y ago> no particular reason except some ideological one ... You make ideology sound like a bad thing. Depends on the particular beliefs of the ideology, no? After all the “free market” (for lack of a better term) beliefs in your post are an ideology too ...
- namdnay 8y agoThat's a bit like arguing that atheism is a religious belief.
- stcredzero 8y agoI'm an atheist, but I've seen "atheists" intone their beliefs, even though there was no one around to convince, like it was a profession of dogma from a Mass. There are definitely some "atheists" around who approach it from more of a tribal affiliation perspective, not an intellectual one. Even the most intellectually sound movement can become toxic. https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/ZQG9cwKbct2LtmL3p/evaporative-cooling-of-group-beliefs https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/ZQG9cwKbct2LtmL3p/evaporativ...
- posterboy 8y agoAtheism is a believe, just not a religious believe. ... ... Whereas, Christianity doesn't hold a believe, just a religious believe.
- boudin 8y agoJapan has fixed book prices too: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fixed_book_price https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fixed_book_price
- scotty79 8y agoDoes culture need to be market driven?
- chrisseaton 8y agoIt seems like a good thing to let the market make books as cheap as possible so that more people can access them.
- C4stor 8y agoBut even with fixed prices, books _are_ cheap. Pocket editions here are the price of a cigarettes pack, something a lot of people even not rich afford once or more a week. I don't think affordability is a problem.
- samspot 8y agoI'm sure how it compares, but here it's $5 USD for a book you'll finish in 15-30 minutes. I find that to be _very_ expensive and I have a great job. So expensive that I've given up on buying and I always go to the library or use a subscription service.
- gmueckl 8y agoI think that a free market would actually lead to steeply rising prices. It's a seller's market, especially for the popular titles. Occasionally you might see some price wars from publishers pushing others out of the market, but between those, the average book price is not going to go down.
- stcredzero 8y agoHistorically, markets for media powered by mass media and technology tended to squash diversity from the Industrial Revolution up through the late 20th century. Now, networks and markets have produced a flowering of diversity, but often with lower profit potential, though individuals are often empowered to be in business for themselves, and a few still manage superstar status. Markets tend to do both harm and good to culture, much as trade, migration, and wars have done both harm and good. Culture will always be market driven. However, there is definitely a place for culture outside of ordinary commerce.
- C4stor 8y agoIs that really an observation ? I personnally observe than Japan in fact practices fixed book prices.
- ajnin 8y agoIn a society we have to consider a balance of various values, competition is a value, and having a rich ecosystem where small bookshops aren't completely obliterated by unequal competition on prices with big online stores is another one. For some reason we live in a world where increasingly the only value that has any worth is money, and any other value is belittled. And somehow, we're the ideologues.
- gmueckl 8y agoWell, I disagree: Germany has similarly fixed book prices (the publisher sers the final price). But prices for textbooks are generally much more reasonable there than in the US.