5 ms·
> Such notebook is suitable for posting photos on Instagram, but not for work. There's something about that statement that put me off the entire article. Maybe
by criddell 8y ago
> Such notebook is suitable for posting photos on Instagram, but not for work.
There's something about that statement that put me off the entire article. Maybe the author truly is 3l337, but it just comes off as condescending. Plus, who uses a notebook for Instagram? The author managed to be simultaneously derisive and clueless.
- carlospwk 8y agoDitto. I instantly thought of a less successful and intelligent version of Gilfoyle from Silicon Valley.
- dagw 8y agowho uses a notebook for Instagram? I think he's doing the tech equivalent of pretending not have heard of a popular band or not knowing what the Super Bowl is to try to make yourself look extra cool.
- tom_ 8y agoWell, the sysadmin type of role does attract a specific type of dork! - but I think you rather unfairly stopped quoting just before the key point.
- supermooka 8y ago> All of them imitate the MacBook Air: thin, shiny, glamorous, and they all critically lack ports. This is the sentence before. IMO you’re being way too harsh. He is clearly trying to emphasize that the average consumers has lost their need for ports, thus, most lightweight computers aren’t sufficient for the author’s line of work. But OMG the author doesn’t know the proper context of Instagram! This whole article loses credibility! Listen to yourself.
- tedunangst 8y agoWhy do people who don't need multiple serial ports stop being real users?
- bubblethink 8y agoWhat does it matter who real users are and aren't ? The author has requirements which are not met. Judging by the fact that it's a popular post, several others have similar requirements too. That someone may not have such requirements is quite obvious. Hence the current state of affairs and the post in the first place. The author's jokes may be a bit off, but this sub thread in this discussion that has devolved into whether or not instagram users are real users or if you need a laptop to use instagram is utterly useless. Like what does it add ?
- tedunangst 8y agoI'm just kidding, man. Why can't anybody take a joke? Why be so uptight all the time?
- hibbelig 8y agoBack in university, having a Centronics port made you more attractive to the girls, I heard.
- rconti 8y agoYes. As a sysadmin myself, my immediate reaction was slow jerk and "I've worked with this guy before". But, everyone's welcome to their own opinions and hobbies. My best sysadmin laptop was probably my 13" macbook pro before they took away the ports. Built in ethernet and real USB for the KVM crash cart, which is the only dongle you'll typically need (other than, say, a usb-serial adapter, but even if you had a native serial port you're carrying a handful of console cables and adapters anyway, so the usb-serial part is hardly an additional hassle).
- panzagl 8y agoI haven't had a work provided laptop with with a decent screen in at least 10 years- 4:3 1600x1200 became 16:9, matte became glossy, and of course real keyboard keys became buttons.. so I get where this guy is coming from. Laptops now are great for streaming movies.
- munificent 8y agoI also like how he referred to me as not a "real user" because I don't need a pile of antiquated ports to do my job: > I thought about how a notebook would turn out if it were developed not with design, but the needs of real users in mind.
- ilkkal 8y agoAlso the idea that design is something that's just "out there" totally apart from how things are used is just precious.
- PascLeRasc 8y agoThe designer made Tab the smallest key on the keyboard, but left two Windows keys, Caps Lock instead of control/super, a full Fn row instead of an numrow layer, Page Up/Down right next to the arrow keys, and designed the color-coding for someone who looks at the keyboard for each keypress instead of touch-typing. I'm not sure what they consider Real Work to be, but it's not text editing or writing. I'd recommend that the author look at small mechanical keyboard layouts, like the HHKB [1]. [1] https://cdn2.bigcommerce.com/server1800/3cc7b/products/549/images/1475/HHKBBT3__00308.1499497323.1280.1280.jpg?c=2 https://cdn2.bigcommerce.com/server1800/3cc7b/products/549/i...
- diaz 8y agoAlso I'd suggest you may be interested in reading the article properly because he clearly explains and has a reason for the color-coding and for it to be visual.
- duxup 8y agoYeah a bit too much stuff that just seemed like arbitrary gate keeping. I have a low tolerance for "this is exactly how you do this job" when jobs like sysadmin and coding can involved a great deal of variation and variety. I have no idea who these folks are who can't see all that variety. I do know they're horrible to work with.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoTo each their own, but personally I reacted positively to that sentence and immediately knew I want to read the whole article - because I knew the author feels the same way as I do: that computers are increasingly built for casual consumption, and are optimized to be toys, not tools.
- pell 8y agoI've used a 2012 MacBook Air 11,6" till 2018 for 3D development among other tasks. It's not a toy only usable for consumption. It's simply a good compromise when you care about mobility.
- lostmyoldone 8y agoThe author is probably working quite a bit in cramped network closets with unmanaged, or only partially managed networking gear. While these environments might be becoming less common, they will still exist for many years to come. To work in these environments efficiently, an air is far from ideal. It's a good machine, but the amount of dongles you'd need to carry on a typical day would be rather intimidating, hooking it up and managing the rats nest of adapter cables would be tedious. From this perspective, it's not unreasonable to call them toys. Simple things like having prominent rubber feet helps a lot with not having to worry the machine will slip and fall if the surface isn't perfectly flat and level. With that said, I believe introducing an idea through calling other things toys without explaining why they are akin to toys in your line of work, is absolutely not the best way to present an idea. Anyway, some features, like having the laptop be able to work as screen and keyboard for a headless machine would really be amazing in this line of work!
- redsparrow 8y agoThe next sentence is: "At least not for mine."
- bigbugbag 8y agoMaybe it's my hate of the macbook air for lacking ports combined with my hate of people used by instagram on top of my hate of everything faceboook, but I had no problem with this particular sentence about the trend hardware has been following for a few years. I actually agree with it, the macbook air is not for work, at least not technical. it's akin to a toy for rich kids that like to brag and live pretend lifes on instagram.