4 ms·
To play devils advocate. Around that time you had periods where banks didn't know if their competitors were going to be around next month, there were also perio
by benj111 8y ago
To play devils advocate.
Around that time you had periods where banks didn't know if their competitors were going to be around next month, there were also periods where they didn't know if several major European nations were going to be defaulting on their debts.
In that kind of situation do the normal rules apply? I don't doubt during the banking crisis several 'dodgy' deals were done between the central banks, politicians, and banks. And if it stopped the entire global economy going tits up, I'm ok with that.
Now the devil is in the details obviously, this could just be a case of personal enrichment.
- M2Ys4U 8y ago>In that kind of situation do the normal rules apply? Yes.
- tumetab1 8y agoWell, the rules also stated that the ECB couldn't buy government bonds and now that's the norm. Central banks, and some banks, have a political side in it which deals badly with rules. And off course, banks and political institutions are always filled with corruption so just looking at rules text doesn't say much about what is really condemned or not.
- benj111 8y agoSo if at the worst extent of the financial crisis it was becoming clear a bank was going to collapse. If the central bank fast tracked through a deal to get that bank sold over a weekend, you would be against that?
- chmod775 8y agoI don't know how you could even get that idea. Upholding the law is significantly more important than saving some company, even if it's a large bank. If you're going to throw law and order out of the window over saving some shitty banks, then you already have a bigger problem than disagreeable numbers on balance sheets.
- benj111 8y agoIt isn't about saving the company, or its share holders. It's about saving all the savings of other depositors, about preventing a run on that, and other banks, about trying to maintain the banking system. Banking laws are meant to maintain stability. If they get in the way of that, they should at least be re examined.
- chmod775 8y ago"Re-examining" and changing laws is different from not punishing criminals and law-breaking corporations. You can change the law later as much as you like. The point is upholding it in the first place and not adding subjective measures like "but it's not a good law!" into the equation when you determine guilt and fines. Even if you immediately repeal or change the law, you still have to punish those that broke it.
- benj111 8y agoWere the last people to illegally practice homosexuality in your country punished? It is societies choice to decide whether to enforce a law. I meant 're-examine' very broadly. And the 2 examples I've given so far in this thread have both involved the authorities.
- cinquemb 8y ago>Banking laws are meant to maintain stability. If they get in the way of that, they should at least be re examined. I hope one thinks this can be done ad infinitum to maintain stability…
- tinktank 8y agoYes, normal rules -- i.e. the law -- still apply.
- projectramo 8y agoI think you have to complete the thought. What kind of scenario are you proposing. The accusation is that banks were manipulating an index to make their position more profitable at the expense of the client. I don't see how the potential collapse of some third party (a nation) changes this. Surely you're not saying, hey Bank A ripped of Customer C but that's only because we didn't know if Greece was going under. You seem to be suggesting that somehow a government might have let the bank do it to save themselves? I am not sure.
- benj111 8y agoThere isn't a lot of detail in the Reuters article. Your comment: "The accusation is that banks were manipulating an index to make their position more profitable at the expense of the client" Isn't mentioned in the article, do you have a better source? Given that lack of detail, there is potentially a reasonable explanation. I'm only suggesting this in extremis, your quote above wouldn't pass that test by a long way. 2008 might. Eg if regulators asked banks to hold off selling Greek bonds for 48hrs to avoid trashing the price, while they sorted out a rescue deal. Trying to avoid at the same time, a domino effect on Italy, Spain, Ireland and Portugal..... As I wrote in a different comment. The regulations are supposed to bring stability to the market. If the regulations stop doing that, they should be revisited.
- gammateam 8y agoThe global financial system is an ecosystem with very few silo-ed actors. These institutions have settled market rigging accusations in every market that any relevant government can weasel jurisdiction in. It is personal enrichment, it is common practice, it is a kickback to the government, the normal rules are never clarified fast enough to keep up with the new markets, the rules can be changed if the banks want, settling a decade later isn't a deterrent, imagine what they are doing in 2019 right now that we won't hear about until 2030. I'm agreeing with you.
- acct1771 8y ago> And if it stopped the entire global economy going tits up, I'm ok with that. Why? Genuinely - why is the corrupt financial system we've propped up worth saving?
- benj111 8y agoBecause we are inextricably wrapped up in the financial system? And getting rid of it would cause massive pain, real and metaphorical. What replacement financial system do you envisage? I cant think of a revolutionary financial system that I'm confident, could be better. And if its evolutionary, why would you chuck out what we've got?
- maze-le 8y ago>> And getting rid of it would cause massive pain, real and metaphorical. I don't doubt the premise, I doubt the scale of the result. >> I cant think of a revolutionary financial system that I'm confident This might be true, but it is in no way revolutionary. Defaulting is a very normal routine in every capitalist system. That's why there is always a 'risk' involved when considering investments. After a big default, there would still be the necessity to trade, exchange, and hedge the risks of deals like that. All of this would be valued, given a price- and a risk tag and so on [business as usual -- except the weeds have been rooted out]... What will be lost is "money" invested in "values" that werent values to begin with. >> And if its evolutionary, why would you chuck out what we've got? If it really is evolutionary, you should give evolution a chance and not intervene at the first sight of trouble. If a gambler has made a bet on the wrong horse, and keeps betting on the wrong horse, with money you provided, wouldn't you be concerned? Instead of funneling even more money to the gambler, you might be incentiviced to find other options.
- benj111 8y agoI was responding to the parents question "why is the corrupt financial system we've propped up worth saving? "