9 ms·
Which 8 banks?
by Fnoord 8y ago
Which 8 banks?
- dessant 8y ago> A European Commission statement Thursday didn’t identify the institutions being investigated for "a collusive scheme that aimed at distorting competition" in trading sovereign bonds issued by euro-region governments from 2007 to 2012. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-02-01/tech-s-european-nemesis-vestager-targets-banks-in-latest-probe https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-02-01/tech-s-eu...
- mtgx 8y agoThere's no good reason why those names should be hidden from the EU population. None. It's a disgrace that governments continue to cater to large corporations and allow them to get away with small fines and "admitting no wrong" (despite receiving the fines for the crime done).
- matt4077 8y agoHere’s one, possible, good reason: the EU has a sort of “whistleblower” defense, where the first company to cooperate in a cartel investigation gets off free. Assuming that bad PR is a significant part of punishment in these cases, it would make sense to delay announcing the culprits here to give one of them time to escape being named.
- kwhitefoot 8y agoThey still get named in the end but they avoid some of the fine.
- nicktelford 8y agoA plausible reason is that it would likely impact their market value as shareholder confidence in those banks is affected by the potential for large fines in the near-future. Since the banks haven't actually been found guilty of anything (yet), they're simply being investigated, it would be damaging to release their names.
- mtgx 8y agoThe "economy will be hurt" if bankers go to jail is getting a little old, isn't it? It's also sounds like exactly the kind of thing bankers would like the public to believe and would try to influence media narrative to repeat it.
- nicktelford 8y agoMy point is simply that they haven't been found guilty of anything yet, just charged. If they're subsequently cleared of any wrongdoing, but their market value is tanked by the accusation, they're effectively being punished for nothing. Innocent until proven guilty and all that.
- sgift 8y agoAs long as they are not found guilty naming them would equal to putting up the pillory. Always a bad idea.
- short_sells_poo 8y agoI work in finance (although on the buy side), my gut feeling is that it's the usual suspects: big investment banks. The people manning the prop desks in these institutions get to know each other eventually as the landscape is fairly small and they all work for/with each other eventually. This means that cliques along the lines of "I'll scratch your back if you'll scratch mine" form naturally. It's almost impossible to prevent as a lot of the trading happens directly between traders and never crosses exchange boundaries and even then, it's often tricky to prove collusion purely based on the trades. Official trading communication channels are monitored, but this is irrelevant if the deal can be pre-arranged privately off channel. There are too many conflicts of interest in the entire industry really. It's not in the best interest of the banks to monitor their internals too closely. Sure, there are plenty of theatrics and checkbox-ticking exercises, but really, as long as it is cheaper to pay the eventual fines than to employ armies of auditors and actually give them the motivation and power to enforce the rules, it's not happening. The internal controls themselves can be fairly annoying too. I remember a 6 month effort to get our legal department to clear a US fund launch because their incentive was to just reject every proposal. They don't directly get to see the benefits of a successful product, but would certainly feel the pain of one that gets into trouble for whatever reason.
- heyjudy 8y agoCheckbox-ticking folks will be glad to sell you a quasi-legal tax avoidance scheme: powered by PwC, EY, D(&T), KPMG. Recommended by MBB.
- short_sells_poo 8y agoAbsolutely. The bank - advisor (PwC, EY, etc...) relationship is just as riddled with conflicts of interest. It is in the interest of the advisory firm to find a "creative" solution for their clients (the banks). Otherwise the bank would go to a slightly less scrupulous institution. The theatrics apply again, the bank gets to claim to have been audited by a prestigious consultancy, the consultancy gets paid, the authorities get to shovel the problem under the carpet and the specific individuals in the authorities get a cushy consultancy job after their public service. It is not in the interest of any of these players to change anything, so it is not going to change.
- whatok 8y agoBloomberg mentioned Deutsche Bank, Credit Suisse, and Credit Agricole were mentioned in a separate bond trading "cartel". Would not be surprised if they were part of the eight. http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_IP-18-6895_en.htm http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_IP-18-6895_en.htm