5 ms·
I think the most unsettling thing about this is not the expunging of someone's past achievements as punishment for some terrible act, but the fact that the mere
by taneq 8y ago
I think the most unsettling thing about this is not the expunging of someone's past achievements as punishment for some terrible act, but the fact that the mere accusation of such can destroy someone.
The higher profile and more in the public eye you are, the higher the chance that someone will throw some mud at you (even anonymously, in some cases!) and that it'll stick, and there will be nothing you can do to repair the damage.
- watwut 8y agoWho was destroyed by mere accusation? Because really, these are people who were accused repeatedly again and again and their victims ended in oblivion while piling up.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- maceurt 8y agoWoody Allen, Aziz Ansari to an extent, Brett Kavanaugh, Dr. Luke. Derrick Rose lost over a million dollars in sponsorship dollars, Kobe Bryant lost over a million too. The list goes on and on. All those people lost a large amount of money, and reputation was seriously hurt by one accusation.
- cafard 8y agoWhat money did Brett Kavanaugh lose? For that matter, what did Woody Allen lose? He has still been making movies.
- slothtrop 8y agoNot since the Weinstein scandal, and actors who've recently worked with him had expressed publicly it was "a mistake". Mind you the man is nearly 100.
- throwawaymath 8y agoI don't know why this is relevant, but Woody Allen is turning 84 this December. He's not nearly 100, for what it's worth.
- slothtrop 8y agoThought he was older. What I meant by that is I didn't expect he'd be continuing on making more films, but you never know.
- loco5niner 8y agoI'm sure for him it was his reputation that was more important.
- 49531 8y agoI don't think Brett Kavanaugh is really suffering right now, or that he lost any money.
- AdmiralAsshat 8y ago> Brett Kavanaugh Oh no, the poor guy might now get the occasional dirty look from some people as he fills out his lifetime appointment to the highest and most powerful court in the nation. The agony!
- loco5niner 8y agoFor honorable people, a perceived stain against their honor is a big deal.
- maceurt 8y agoHe got publicly humiliated, and now must explain to his kids why when they google his name a bunch of videos and articles show up calling him a rapist and a piece of shit. Furthermore, no matter how much his wife trusts him, she will still have doubt if he really raped that woman, and he is going to have to live with his kids and wife for the rest of his life also. I would value my reputation, my legacy, the views of my kids and wife to be far more important than being supreme court justice.
- coldtea 8y ago>Because really, these are people who were accused repeatedly again and again So if an accusation is repeated "again and again" it's true?
- appleflaxen 8y agono, but when there is a set of accusations that all follow the same pattern, it is more likely to be true (albeit still circumstantial)
- IAmEveryone 8y agoAziz Ansari did get a lot of sympathy, suffered far less than many others, and had all reputable news publishers take a pass on the accusations that were floating around. For Weinstein, as the counterexample, it seems like the public accusation was necessary to get the regular wheels of justice to turn. And to add the argument that is almost as tired as yours: “Innocent until proven guilty” is for punishment by those with the monopoly on violence, i. e. the state/the courts. If I can not watch a comedian because I don’t find them funny (which is, unfortunately, not a crime), surely I can skip their HBO special because I believe their accusers?
- cpcallen 8y ago> If I can not watch a comedian because I don’t find them funny (which is, unfortunately, not a crime), surely I can skip their HBO special because I believe their accusers? Of course. But TFA asks: does it follow that everyone should be deprived the HBO special?
- SolaceQuantum 8y agoEveryone should be able to pool together resources to hire the person if there is enough demand for it. Another company could pick it up, maybe? Edit: to be clear (I’m concerned about being seen as 100% supporting any position) my position is that if there is enough demand, a presumed minority outcry can be ignored safely (Facebook).
- AlexTWithBeard 8y agoIt would be very difficult for another company to go against public opinion. You'll have to find not only another company but also another cable provider and, in the most extreme case, another guild of comedians in case if they decide to boycott your channel.
- SolaceQuantum 8y agoThen perhaps there aren't enough consumers to support the commodity in question, and this is just market forces at play?
- ucaetano 8y ago> I think the most unsettling thing about this is not the expunging of someone's past achievements as punishment for some terrible act, but the fact that the mere accusation of such can destroy someone. When you live by your public image, you die by your public image. Your rise likely happened in the same way as your downfall. You can't have your cake and eat it too, you can't reap the benefits of being a public figure but complain about the drawbacks. You're, after all, Caesar's wife.
- coldtea 8y ago>When you live by your public image, you die by your public image. Your rise likely happened in the same way as your downfall. Not really, the rise usually happens after years, or even decades, of paying dues and hard work. You don't build a career in anything, journalism, comedy, whatever, by just one gesture. At least most don't. >You can't have your cake and eat it too, you can't reap the benefits of being a public figure but complain about the drawbacks. First of all, this doesn't happen just to "public figures". A person can be fired from their non public job for saying something wrong on social media, without having ripped anything Second, this doesn't make much sense anyway. One should be able to "reap the benefits of being a public figure" while still complaining about the drawbacks if the drawbacks are detrimental to society and kill public dialogue A actor, for example, can be a public figure without giving license to be stalked. Public figure means their job is to make movies for public consumption, not that they have to suffer any BS paparazzi. There's no inherent tie between one and the other. The suggestion to also "bend over and take the drawbacks" would only make sense if the "benefits of being a public figure" were obtained in a way that called for those drawbacks (e.g. celebrities being famous because they purposefully stir trouble and put on shows for the media).
- ucaetano 8y ago> Not really, the rise usually happens after years, or even decades, of paying dues and hard work. Sure, but it happens because of your public image, always with a "big break" or a "breakthrough". > At least most don't. Actually, most do. There is almost always the one big break, where you are launched into the public's view. It is a step function. Pick a number of artists, and look up their career, for most of them you'll easily find their "big break". > A person can be fired from their non public job for saying something wrong on social media, without having ripped anything Sure, but that's a different topic. I'm focusing on the public-figure part of it. > Public figure means their job is to make movies for public consumption, not that they have to suffer any BS paparazzi. There's no inherent tie between one and the other. Oh, there is, and plenty of it, the relationship between the "fame industry" (magazines, publications, etc.) and the public figures is a symbiotic one. And the more you rely on the fame industry to fuel your growth, the more you're exposed to its risks. It is a deal with the devil. There are, however, public figures who simply avoid the fame industry. They are harder to find, and have a harder time succeeding, but they are there (Daniel Day-Lewis, for example).