5 ms·
When you scan for uncorrupt institutions, how the hell do you end up on "governments the world over"?
by BurningFrog 8y ago
When you scan for uncorrupt institutions, how the hell do you end up on "governments the world over"?
- lukeify 8y agoBecause some of us don't believe governments are inherently evil?
- WillPostForFood 8y agoAlmost no one believes governments are inherently evil, but that doesn’t mean many, or most, aren’t corrupt. How many anarchists are there in your neighborhood?
- minikites 8y agoI've never understood why governments (or labor unions) default to "corrupt" and private firms default to "virtuous".
- cortesoft 8y agoI mean, lots of people think both are corrupt.
- prewett 8y agoIt seems to be that if you lean Republican, governments are corrupt and private firms virtuous because freedom and the magic of the Invisible Hand of free markets make private firms virtuous (individual choice) and governments corrupt (coercive force). If you lean Democrat, then governments are virtuous and private firms corrupt because the free market doesn't solve all the problems, and for those you need regulation (government: coercive force). In fact, the regulated free market leads huge wealth disparities, which leads to social problems, and since private firms that are seeking to maximize their wealth disparity, obviously they must be corrupt. Naturally, neither of these pictures is right, or rather, they are both partly right.
- Retric 8y agoI don’t think that’s accurate. Companies and individuals benefit from outsourcing government work, that creates a huge incentive to paint government as incompetent. The US military which hands crazy money to private firms is viewed very highly by the Republican’s and less so by Democrats.
- rectang 8y agoPower corrupts when governments extend excessive control over markets. Power corrupts when private firms extend excessive influence over government. The most consistent principle is to oppose concentration of power in all its forms.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Pristina 8y agobecause private firms make money by making things people want and every consumer is by choice. government makes money by threatening you with violence (pay tax or go to jail) and its subjects are so rarely by choice, and if by choice, it's between one government and another.
- Tepix 8y agoThe goal of the government is not to make money. That's why people suggest to let the government run the nuclear power plants. Unlike a for-profit corporation, governmental organizations have little incentive to save money for maintenance by cutting corners.
- beaconstudios 8y agoit's more like both are made up of individuals with high self-interest. The difference is you can choose not to interact with a private firm.
- minikites 8y agoI thought about this in the wake of the BP Deepwater oil spill. How exactly can I choose to avoid interacting with any company that produces a fungible commodity (e.g BP, Archer Daniels Midland, Monsanto)? I can stop visiting BP branded gas stations but that has nothing to do with where the oil/gasoline actually comes from.
- beaconstudios 8y agoI agree, that's an issue. Or if you wanted to stop funding exploitative mining but still wanted to own electronics, you might have a hard time. But I prefer the "you can often avoid interacting with them" option of private companies, to the "you cannot avoid them and are entirely at the mercy of their whims" option of government. Not to say government isn't necessary - it is. But I don't understand why people treat it as virtuous, especially when those same people will express distrust in politicians. I suppose it's because government is the only way to legitimately force one's will on others.
- isostatic 8y agoI prefer the ability to get rid of a government by voting elsewhere.
- randiantech 8y agoMainly because most governments around the globe have the monopoly of public force, creating the perfect ground for arbitrary decisions. Its not black and white, by those defaults seems accurate.
- minikites 8y agoAre there private firms that don't make arbitrary decisions?
- moduspol 8y agoPrivate firms aren't inherently "virtuous," but their motivations are at least clear. A business seeking to maximize financial returns for its owners isn't "corrupt," it's "working as expected." The corruption of governments and labor unions often results in unexpected financial and non-financial returns for various people in ways that are more difficult to detect and measure.
- darpa_escapee 8y agoWith the government, you get a vote. With other institutions, you have to hope their stakeholders' interests align with yours.
- randiantech 8y agoI can have a vote, but government will still force me to pay tributes at gunpoint. On the other hand, im not forced to buy most of private goods. At the end, the evil organizations are those that became monopolies, no matter if it is public or private.
- isostatic 8y agoSure, I'm not forced to buy food, or medicine, or heat, or for somewhere to live, I could just decide to starve, or freeze, or die of plague.
- darpa_escapee 8y ago> I can have a vote, but government will still force me to pay tributes at gunpoint No, at most you'll get a letter in a mail and a lien if you aren't actively trying to evade taxes. No reason to engage in hyperbole.
- armenarmen 8y agoAnd then if you don’t leave your house you get put in the last socially acceptable debtors prison. And if you try leave that they will kill you. Ultimately the threat of murder and kidnapping are there
- anoncake 8y agoOr you could just be a decent person and pay your taxes.
- BurningFrog 8y agoWe're talking about "governments the world over", and they are typically not fairly run democracies.
- Pristina 8y agomost people are in the world are brainwashed by government propaganda to believe that the solution to any problem is more government power and control
- Tepix 8y agoSource? Also what's the proof that private organizations are a better solution to the problem? Just look at the US prison system.
- randiantech 8y agoNot to undermine your point, but you have used the worst possible example. In the top 1000 of worst prisons around the world, most if not all of them are not private. Just take a look a Brazil prison system as en example.
- amdavidson 8y agoDoes Brazil have private prisons that are much better than their public ones? If not, I don't think you have contradicted his point at all. There are not too many places that we can look at public vs private institutions for direct comparisons (in the contexts that they operate). Prisons are one, I can think of FedEx/UPS/DHL vs the Post Office as another, and it's difficult for me to come up with much after that.
- Tepix 8y agoOne glaring problem with private prisons is that it creates an incentive to put more people in jail and keep them there longer.