3 ms·
You ignored the law of unintended consequences. If you cut defense spending you also shrink a massive section of the economy, this will have a large ripple eff
by ars 16y ago
You ignored the law of unintended consequences.
If you cut defense spending you also shrink a massive section of the economy, this will have a large ripple effect and you will end up with less tax receipts, and unemployment.
If you add a carbon tax you are taxing literally every single thing in the economy, this will reduce growth by exactly the amount of the tax, making the whole business a wash in terms of budget. (You'll convert some energy to other sources, but not much, if it was so easy we would do it already.)
Adding a sales tax would do about the same, and would also end up as a wash.
- philwelch 16y ago"If you cut defense spending you also shrink a massive section of the economy, this will have a large ripple effect and you will end up with less tax receipts, and unemployment." This doesn't even make sense. If defense spending pays my salary and my salary pays my taxes, my taxes can't be any higher than 100%, and if my taxes are 100% then me losing my job due to cuts in defense spending can't cost the government more in tax receipts than it's gaining back by paying my salary. "You'll convert some energy to other sources, but not much, if it was so easy we would do it already." Why? People respond to incentives. (First rule of economics.) Carbon tax is an incentive.
- lotharbot 16y ago> "cuts ... can't cost the government more in tax receipts than it's gaining back by [not] paying my salary" Not exactly true. Your salary doesn't disappear once it's been paid to you. You spend it, someone else gets it, they spend it, and so on. At each step, taxes get paid, which the government spends, following the same pattern. Over the course of the average year, each dollar changes hands some number of times between about 6 and 12 (google for "velocity of money" for more info.) As a result, the aggregate taxes on your salary and its "inheritors", as it works through the economy, can (in some circumstances) actually end up being more than your salary itself. Note this is not an argument either for or against any particular bit of government spending. I'm merely noting that both tax increases and spending cuts can have counter-intuitive effects, and that those effects need to be accounted for when trying to understand how a change in government policy will affect the economy.
- ars 16y agoThere already is an incentive: You have to pay for energy. Adding a carbon tax just means you have to pay a bit more. It's not possible to switch from hydrocarbon fuels to other types in any large amounts (every type we can do we already are). Say you want more windmills - sounds easy, make non-windmill energy more expensive (tax it). One problem, making windmills costs energy. But now energy is more expensive, so windmills are also more expensive. Since windmills are more expensive windmill energy is also more expensive, making the increase in non-windmill energy prices meaningless since windmill energy ends up being just as expensive. All you did was make ALL energy more expensive, but you did not switch people to other types. So now what will you do with all this extra carbon tax money? You'll either give it back to people as a rebate, or you'll reduce income taxes. End result? Nothing. It's a total wash.