3 ms·

I was actually able to disable this in my GMC, but now I find myself double and triple checking to make sure it locked.

by devrod 8y ago

standardUser 8y ago
It's not clear to me why the clicker can't beep to confirm instead of the car itself! I guess it's just for finding your car in big parking lots? Seems like a different button could be dedicated for that far less common use case.
- shawnz 8y ago
  AFAIK the fob is normally just a transmitter, so this would require it to also have a receiver in addition to a buzzer and other circuitry. I imagine that could significantly reduce the battery life.
- VMG 8y ago
  I think the clicker can only send, not receive
- irq 8y ago
  The solution you propose requires 2-way communication with the car. Virtually no cars do this (in their OEM configuration anyway.) Without 2-way communication, the remote has no way of knowing if the vehicle acted on the signal.
- Deimorz 8y ago
  That requires the car to communicate back to the clicker, which is more difficult/expensive, and can fail even if the car did successfully lock. It's certainly possible though, these are usually called "2 way remotes": https://www.compustar.com/what-is-2-way/ https://www.compustar.com/what-is-2-way/
- Yetanfou 8y ago
  That's simply because these remote controls are transmit-only, fire-and-forget devices which spew out a pseudo-random code to the receiver without being able to listen to any response. This is also why you should not click the button on the remote too often (as in 'more than 255 times') when not in range of the car as that gets the transmitter (key) and receiver (car) pseudo-random generators out of sync - the receiver accepts a sliding window of 256 random codes as valid. There might be different implementations of this feature using key fobs but this describes the majority of them.
- markdown 8y ago
  In my car, the headlights and park lights flash once on every lock. No beep needed.
hinkley 8y ago
Same on my VW, but the preferences are per key fob. Surprised me the first few times when I used the spare.

I was actually able to disable this in my GMC, but now I find myself double and triple checking to make sure it locked.

by devrod 8y ago

I was actually able to disable this in my GMC, but now I find myself double and triple checking to make sure it locked.

It's not clear to me why the clicker can't beep to confirm instead of the car itself! I guess it's just for finding your car in big parking lots? Seems like a different button could be dedicated for that far less common use case.

shawnz 8y ago
AFAIK the fob is normally just a transmitter, so this would require it to also have a receiver in addition to a buzzer and other circuitry. I imagine that could significantly reduce the battery life.
VMG 8y ago
I think the clicker can only send, not receive
irq 8y ago
The solution you propose requires 2-way communication with the car. Virtually no cars do this (in their OEM configuration anyway.) Without 2-way communication, the remote has no way of knowing if the vehicle acted on the signal.
Deimorz 8y ago
That requires the car to communicate back to the clicker, which is more difficult/expensive, and can fail even if the car did successfully lock. It's certainly possible though, these are usually called "2 way remotes": https://www.compustar.com/what-is-2-way/ https://www.compustar.com/what-is-2-way/
Yetanfou 8y ago
That's simply because these remote controls are transmit-only, fire-and-forget devices which spew out a pseudo-random code to the receiver without being able to listen to any response. This is also why you should not click the button on the remote too often (as in 'more than 255 times') when not in range of the car as that gets the transmitter (key) and receiver (car) pseudo-random generators out of sync - the receiver accepts a sliding window of 256 random codes as valid. There might be different implementations of this feature using key fobs but this describes the majority of them.
markdown 8y ago
In my car, the headlights and park lights flash once on every lock. No beep needed.

hinkley 8y ago

Same on my VW, but the preferences are per key fob. Surprised me the first few times when I used the spare.