2 ms·

I've yet to see it used effective to give us desktop-like GUI's. My experience is SVG lacks common GUI widgets, and text positioning is still inconsistent acros

by tabtab 8y ago

I've yet to see it used effective to give us desktop-like GUI's. My experience is SVG lacks common GUI widgets, and text positioning is still inconsistent across browser brand/versions/OS-settings. Downloading tons of JavaScript to emulate typical GUI's gets right back to fat-client problems created by current browser "standards". Maybe someday these weak points will be solved, but so far it doesn't seem ready. SVG is meant to draw pictures, not manage GUI's.

goto11 8y ago
It is rather unclear what you want. First you state you want the client to be a dumb plotter and fully generate the layout on the server. Now you want everything we already have, and in addition a set of common GUI widgets in SVG. These seem to be opposite ideas?
tabtab 8y ago
(There is no "reply" under your comments, so I had to put the reply on the prior level.) Goto11, you are correct that I was ambiguous. I was mostly talking about positioning and sizing itself when I said, "browser should be a dumb x,y,z coordinate polygon plotter." I should have said, "browser should use absolute x,y,z coordinates for sizing and positioning objects....". By "dumb" I meant the layout & sizing engine is "dumb", not every UI object. No more client-side auto-flow nor auto-size. Good catch. I'll hire you to debug the wording of my Next Great Write-up :-)