20 ms·
> but 15 is not 5. What is the relevant difference in this context?
by xg15 8y ago
> but 15 is not 5.
What is the relevant difference in this context?
- shittyadmin 8y agoA 15 year old could be working in many places - probably at least has a functional understanding of value for money based on past experiences, a 5 year old almost certainly doesn't.
- bg4 8y agoA child is a child.
- brianwawok 8y agoWhy do we try children as adults for certain crimes? It’s just a magic line. 17? No consequences. 18? Full adult.
- iamdave 8y agoBecause prosecutors sometimes care more about being seen as tough on crime and not compassionate towards young kids who do stupid things at an age where they're not blessed with an abundance of restraint and good decision making skills?
- rdiddly 8y agoBecause it's cheaper and more fair to set an arbitrary limit and apply it across the board than to try to evaluate each offender's maturity level individually.
- reaperducer 8y agoIt’s just a magic line. 17? No consequences. 18? Full adult. Complete fiction. Minors being tried as adults happens all the time. It all depends on how heinous the crime is.
- brianwawok 8y agoI was missing a ? Mark in there. Other two posters figured it out. Will edit for you.
- ycombobreaker 8y agoThere is still a huge difference between 5 and 15. I am not saying the 15yo "got what they deserved" by any means, I'm just saying that it doesn't help anyone to pretend that they are developmentally identical. Laws may be descrete but morality is surely continuous.
- TheRealPomax 8y agoWhich, unfortunately, doesn't mean anything. Someone can have a full time job at 15 on this planet, earn a living wage, have a bank account, and for all intents and purposes be financially independent. A five year old pretty universally cannot.
- shittyadmin 8y agoA 15 year old likely makes some of their own financial decisions, occasionally, or even often, buys their own food, entertainment, etc. 15 year olds buy game consoles, computers and games all the time.
- wuliwong 8y agoCould you expand on what you mean by "relevant difference?"
- dtech 8y agoAge matters > Alcohol brand starts marketing campaign targeting 18 year olds > Alcohol brand starts marketing campaign targeting 5 year olds
- eshyong 8y agoIt's important because the article headline is a bit clickbaity. It's true that Facebook called children "whales" but not "as young as 5", since the linked chat transcript in the article mentions a 15-year old child.
- ajcodez 8y agoWhen I was 15 I spent $3,500 on a video game console, controllers, Xbox live, halo, halo map packs, etc. When I was 5 I spent $1 on gum.
- ams6110 8y agoWas it your money? Was it really your decision as to whether you could spend it?
- ajcodez 8y agoYeah my money, my decision. I had around $6k of bar mitzvah money and savings from working as a teaching assistant and summer jobs. I spent just over half on video games during high school and related costs. I made it all back the summer after high school as a tech intern and then spent it all going out drinking first year in university.
- rdiddly 8y agoLegally there is none. Both are considered minors, not capable of giving informed consent for (in many US states) marriage, employment, military service, voting, driving, or opening a bank account independently. And it's not like Facebook deserves rebuke for exploiting 5-year-olds and a Nobel Prize for exploiting 15-year-olds. But it's also true that the content of the article doesn't support the headline. Edit: Even the math is wrong. If they're asserting that everyone's eligible to be called a "whale" who plays Angry Birds, and that the average age of an Angry Birds player is 5, then the minimum age ("as young as") of a whale isn't 5, it's less than 5.