3 ms·
A lot of the time it's hard to see any other "spirit" to those "loopholes". The "oil depletion allowance" in the article is described as "Meant to give incentiv
by lmm 8y ago
A lot of the time it's hard to see any other "spirit" to those "loopholes". The "oil depletion allowance" in the article is described as "Meant to give incentives to drill for oil" - isn't that exactly what it did? If I do the things that the government offers tax incentives for, so as to reduce my tax payments, isn't that exactly the point of those tax incentives?
I have a tax-advantaged pension, tax-advantaged life insurance, and commute on a tax-advantaged bicycle. I believe all those things are in the spirit of my country's tax law - isn't the whole purpose of tax breaks on pension contributions to encourage people like me to put more money into their pensions?
Similarly I have no idea what the spirit of a rule giving capital gains different tax treatment from regular income could be, if it isn't to encourage people to form companies and take dividend payments instead of getting paid normally. Why on earth that's something Congress would want to encourage, I can't imagine, but presumably they passed that law for a reason.
- jki275 8y agoTo answer your final question, I think that the intent is to stimulate long term investment (investments held over a year are taxed significantly lower than those held less than a year) -- this tends to boost the economy and grow businesses, which create more jobs etc. To the rest-- yes, that's how I see it as well.