5 ms·
Looks like this controversy was about a condescending poen written by a white woman about native girls, that specifically referenced the tribal group of the wom
by pessimizer 8y ago
Looks like this controversy was about a condescending poen written by a white woman about native girls, that specifically referenced the tribal group of the woman who led the protest (that the author learned of from the protester), and implied some sort of generalized drunken molestation and abuse of native women by the men of that group.
I still don't think that the university should have censored the poem, but
1) a protest isn't just for the university; maybe the author would see the point and withdraw the poem, or maybe people who heard of the controversy would be influenced to think in a different way by hearing the details and the protesters reaction to them, and
2) I'm pretty sure the reaction would have been different if the native woman had written a poem called "Stupid White Whore In My Class" and mentioned the other woman's hometown and family name, and how her uncle probably molested her. The free speech advocates that get super-mad about 10 people picketing in the courtyard of an Alaskan university for 3 days 20 years ago would instead be super-mad about "how you can say anything about white people and get away with it."
It shouldn't be the job of universities to censor speech, though. But protesting speech is also speech.
- gpm 8y agoI think you're misreading this letter if you're reading it as objecting to the protesting. I think it is objecting to vague threats made by university employees towards the author along the lines of "The University supports the right of free speech, but we intend to check into this matter", or "The University supports the right of free speech, but I have asked Dean X or Provost Y to investigate the circumstances".