3 ms·
Chili sounds spicy. I’m not pro jus soli but to characterize birth tourism as a big problem is crazy. A conservative think tank estimated it at 40,000 births p
by arcticbull 8y ago
Chili sounds spicy.
I’m not pro jus soli but to characterize birth tourism as a big problem is crazy. A conservative think tank estimated it at 40,000 births per year out of 4.3 million (0.9%) — the average delivery costs $32,000 for an economic benefit of $1.28B per year. Then those poor kids are going to have to pay US income taxes for the rest of their natural lives no matter where they live. We can expect the first 18 years to be abroad since their parents don’t get citizenship and the US has effectively zero social safety net anyways. What’s the big deal?
- mc32 8y agoIt’s not a problem in and of itself but it’s illustrative of our lax policy.
- arcticbull 8y agoHow does that make the policy lax? Compared to what, zero admissions?
- mc32 8y agoWe allow millions in legally every year. Birth tourism often involves immigration fraud. It’s seldom prosecuted = lax enforcement. So, no, we still would allow millions of legal immigrants in. We’d just crack down on unregulated immigrants.
- arcticbull 8y ago1 million per year, not millions, in a country of 325 million (0.3%), for comparison Canada lets in 0.33 million per year in a country of 36 million (almost 1%).
- jessaustin 8y agoNo matter how much some people might dislike the 14th Amendment, it ain't going anywhere.