4 ms·
I'm not sure this anonymous anecdote advances the debate about airport security in any meaningful way.
by eli 16y ago
I'm not sure this anonymous anecdote advances the debate about airport security in any meaningful way.
- protomyth 16y agoAnonymous anecdotes and writings have a long history of relevance in US. http://www.foundingfathers.info/federalistpapers/ http://www.foundingfathers.info/federalistpapers/
- natrius 16y agoThe Federalist Papers were not anecdotes. They were philosophy. Anecdotes must be true to be of any consequence, so the identity of the author helps to verify the anecdote. Philosophy just has to be correct, which makes the identity of the writer unimportant.
- protomyth 16y agoJournalism has a long history of using anonymous sources so knowing the source is not a necessary item. In a lot of ways, I don't see as much distinction as you do between anecdotes and philosophy particularly with the writings of people who were talking about governing people.
- ezy 16y agoI think in aggregate, it helps. And it's hard to not be anonymous when you can be put on a black list. It's not like you're converting anecdotes to data in the typical sense. It's more that it illustrates the kind of abuse that can happen, and why people are so concerned. In some ways, it beats harping on ideals of privacy when you're dealing with organizations who are concerned with nothing but pure pragmatism. You can draw connections from these incidents to the ideals to show that these aren't isolated incidents, but a pattern that emerges when we ignore some ideals to pursue others. It's similar to the "bad apples" excuse applied to other disciplines -- yeah, you can say that a majority of police officers or investment bankers aren't total douchebags, but enough are that you have to look into why and what you should do about the problem. And the only way that happens is by pointing out particular incidents as they happen, over and over and over again.
- bhiggins 16y agoI agree, we should just not talk about it and let the government do whatever they see fit. Brilliant.