6 ms·
For me the next couple of years are going to make or break Tesla. You have pretty much every car manufacturer releasing flagship electric cars in 2019/2020. An
by threeseed 8y ago
For me the next couple of years are going to make or break Tesla.
You have pretty much every car manufacturer releasing flagship electric cars in 2019/2020. And most of them are either cheaper than Tesla or offer far more value i.e. premium branding and better interiors. And whilst they have their Supercharger network I suspect that pretty soon we will governments intervening to regulate standards and build out infrastructure.
So they better get ready quickly before the onslaught comes and like you said be profitable if margins drop.
- rconti 8y agoElectrify America has an order of magnitude more money to spend on charging than Tesla used to build their supercharger network. That said, they seem to be using it to buy charging networks but so far the experience isn't improving. Conventional EV roadtrip charging is years behind Tesla. I'm not sure "premium branding" for the competition matters vs Tesla, as I don't think the latter has a downmarket reputation. Interior/existing brand relationships I can see helping the conventional players. Range doesn't seem to be there even on the models supposedly coming out this year. It seems like we keep hearing the Tesla killer is coming Real Soon Like Now. Still, I ultimately agree they need to sustain through the onslaught, it just seems like it's taking longer than expected.
- RobLach 8y agoI have a feeling Tesla didn’t capitalize enough on their first mover advantage and now it’s going to be tough as proper competitors move into the market. Audi is matching the Model X with the E-Tron, but without Tesla build quality: https://www.audiusa.com/models/audi-e-tron https://www.audiusa.com/models/audi-e-tron Volvo Drive-E, Jaguar I-Pace, new Nissan Leaf; similar stories.
- btilly 8y agoAs I most recently pointed out in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18712442 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18712442, there is good reason to believe that all the other car manufacturers are going to learn the hard way that their interests do not align with their dealers. Which means that consumers will learn that they shouldn't go to existing car companies to buy electric cars. Which does not bode well for the future of existing car companies. (This is a prediction that I've been aware of for around 20 years now. And the form of the problem - that existing tech manufacturer's wind up hamstrung by their existing supply and sales networks, is a common one for companies that get destroyed by disruptive innovation.)
- reitzensteinm 8y agoThis is a bizarre argument to me, and I remember thinking that the last time you "pointed it out". You're essentially saying that tens of thousands of dealers and hundreds of billions of dollars worth of car companies are going to go out of business because they can't find a mutually beneficial incentive structure. It's not going to be all roses, but Tesla shunning dealers hasn't exactly been either, from a service quality and cost structure perspective. Porsche doesn't seem to have any trouble shifting Taycans, doubling their production from an initial 20k to 40k units a year (simultaneous to Tesla cutting their X/S production from 100k to maybe 80k). Here's my prediction: legacy auto manufacturers will continue to be years behind Tesla, but if and when the space matures that'll stop mattering. At that point, Tesla better stop acting like a startup and have their shit figured out, lest they become the Myspace of EVs.
- btilly 8y agoYou're essentially saying that tens of thousands of dealers and hundreds of billions of dollars worth of car companies are going to go out of business because they can't find a mutually beneficial incentive structure. It would be far from the first time. One of the biggest problems is for a company whose internal incentives and business model are based around one set of market assumptions to rethink it all and do something else instead. Both The Innovator's Dilemma and The Innovator's Solution touch on this. The latter one in particular walks through how internal structures and incentives have caused company after company to fail to figure out how to sell products that they know consumers are buying. The two most common problems being that it is very hard to cut your own margins to match a low margin competitor, and it is even harder to convince a third party sales distributor to cut their margins. Anyways this is something that I've been aware of for close to 20 years. In another 10 years you'll be able to decide whether I was wrong.
- reitzensteinm 8y agoYeah, I've read them too. But you're not saying that it's a challenge the industry will face, you're saying the death is a fait accompli, and the entire traditional auto industry is not real competition to Tesla (your words from your linked post). I don't need to wait ten years to decide that you're wrong; even if your prediction turns out to be correct (which it might), assigning a 100% probability to this outcome is absurd, and if you could reliably do this you'd be a trillionaire. Since we're reading the tea leaves via business school curriculum, what about a little Prisoner's Dilemma? Let's assume that consumer demand exists for EVs (which Tesla has basically created single handedly), and EVs aren't profitable when slotted in to the cost structure of a traditional dealership due to the lack of maintenance. Dealers try every trick in the book to steer customers away from EVs. Why wouldn't a percentage of dealerships defect, rebrand and focus exclusively on EVs? They'll enjoy abnormally high sales, and be profitable on the margins from new car sales alone. Dealerships that insist on only selling ICE vehicles will stick around for a while, but nobody will start one, and the number will be reduced by attrition. The total number of dealerships fall and the EV transition is completed over a few decades. So to be clear: you assign a zero percent probability to this happening?
- Reedx 8y ago> For me the next couple of years are going to make or break Tesla. Maybe, but haven't people been saying that about Tesla for 15 years now?
- taneq 8y agoThat's what happens when you aggressively scale a business. They could have throttled back and been a profitable niche manufacturer with the Roadster, and again (albeit a bigger niche) with the Model S, and again now with the Model 3. But that's not their goal, so they're continuing to expand as fast as possible, and that carries risks.
- threeseed 8y agoSure. But they never really had serious competition until now. Companies like Mercedes, Audi, Jaguar own the mainstream, premium car market and they've only just joined the game.
- tomp 8y ago> offer far more value i.e. premium branding and better interiors This can't happen soon enough. Ever since driving a Tesla, I'm completely disappointed by the interior/control panels of most (all?) other cars. Buttons, seriously? A 9-inch screen?!
- erobbins 8y agoSeriously? Tesla interiors have a high tech feel, but they are pretty spartan and lack luxury I expect in a $100k car. You can get into a 3 series BMW and it's got a higher quality interior than any Tesla.
- paganel 8y ago> Buttons, seriously? Buttons allow a driver to not take his/her eyes off the road while changing the radio station or adjusting the AC. Totally eliminating dashboard buttons is dumb, but fortunately some car-makers have started realizing this and have started to re-introduce some of those buttons.
- tomp 8y agoYeah, I'm not opposed to a few buttons - like +- temperature, all blinkers, etc. But in most cars, the number of buttons is just overwhelming, so you probably need to take your eyes off the road just to find the button you're looking for!
- Ntrails 8y agoI could type on my old Nokias etc without ever looking at the message. It was flawless. If one wanted to do it whilst driving (not that anyone ever would, of course) it could be done without ever looking away from the road. That's the power of actual physical feedback. I'm sure there's someone somewhere who can prove me wrong and touch-type flawlessly on their touch screen phone. But in most cases you're relying heavily on auto-correct to make a parseable sentence. Which means you'll need to look at the screen a lot. The radio/Cassette player in my car is all buttons. I can change stations, volume, switch to tape etc without looking much at all. Some buttons I might no remember their place - but here's the crucial thing. I don't have to keep looking until I make contact. I glance, see where the button is, and then feel for it. A touch screen simply doesn't give you that, you either need to see yourself making contact or wait for the software to do something you may (or may not) have wanted. If it's wrong, you're now trying to fix that and try again. I do not believe that touch screens reduce risk in interacting with car functionality, indeed I'm pretty sure they increase it.
- wpdev_63 8y agoThe tentative release for many of these new electric cars are in 2019/2010. There's probably going to be a good chance that they are delayed with the technical difficulty of manufacturing electric cars at scale. Also I wouldn't count out Tesla's major advantage in sourcing the best batteries at wholesale prices.