17 ms·
Google’s also peddling a data collector through Apple’s back door
- minimaxir 8y agoGoogle's approach appears to be less sinister than Facebook's approach (it doesn't obfuscate what the research is really for), but I suspect Apple's decision today to revoke FB's Enterprise cert will force them to also take action on Google's Enterprise cert. Well played, TechCrunch.
- firloop 8y agoIt’s also still a violation of Apple’s terms. Enterprise certs aren’t meant for consumer software distribution. Full stop.
- gojomo 8y agoCan you quote the relevant terms? Depending on exact definitions, the people in an outside compensated "research panel" could be seen as "employed by" the company doing the research. There's consideration being exchanged for services rendered.
- wsy 8y agoYou pay employees with gift cards?
- tzs 8y agoI've actually suggested, not fully seriously, that my employer give us the option of taking part of our pay in Costco gift cards. A Costco member can buy and load gift cards, and then give them to a non-member, and that card will admit the non-member to Costco stores and allow them to buy things there on the card. Some of us wouldn't use Costco enough to justify buying a membership, but would like to use them occasionally, and this gift card hack would allow that.
- ceejayoz 8y agoWouldn't that be a loophole big enough to drive a few million trucks through?
- garyb2 8y agoSure would. If that would pass, I would simply create a club, let everyone join up and call them members of my organization and ship apps through it, bypassing Apple, the 30% and App Store review all in one shot. Considering how I've been treated at the hands of the iTunes support team, I'd do it in a heartbeat.
- gojomo 8y agoPerhaps, which is why the exact terms, as they are now written or might be amended, would be interesting to know.
- pcwalton 8y agoI don't think lawyering over the terms is what's important here. Instead what matters is whether Apple thinks it is better for its business to pull Google's enterprise cert. Apple holds all the cards here. If it wants to punish Google over this, it will, and Google won't be able to do a thing about it, terms or no terms.
- gojomo 8y agoApple has immense discretion here, of course. But a punitive enforcement action with potentially large spillover effects, in impairing other apps, is being discussed. Whether that's considered justified, and even whether such an action might create a legal/antitrust liability for Apple, could depend on the actual terms/definitions Apple provided. In the long run, Apple can adjust their terms subject only to a few legal and market checks. But in the short term, Apple should respect the terms they've offered, contractually, to other entities.
- pcwalton 8y agoI don't think antitrust is relevant in this case, because Apple doesn't have a monopoly in smartphones. In fact, if anyone does, it's Google, since Android accounts for 75% of mobile phones worldwide [1]. [1]: http://gs.statcounter.com/os-market-share/mobile/worldwide http://gs.statcounter.com/os-market-share/mobile/worldwide
- gojomo 8y agoAntitrust enforcement doesn't require an absolute monopoly, just abuse of market power in anti-competitive ways. Further, Apple has a 100% monopoly control of the iOS App Store.
- briandear 8y agoTrue, kind of — it depends on the definition of “market power.” There is a dominant market share test used by the courts, generally a market share over 50% is required while some courts require a much higher percentage. Here is the better explanation from the FTC: https://www.ftc.gov/tips-advice/competition-guidance/guide-antitrust-laws/single-firm-conduct/monopolization-defined https://www.ftc.gov/tips-advice/competition-guidance/guide-a... > Further, Apple has a 100% monopoly control of the iOS App Store. That irrelevant. Best Buy also has a 100% monopoly control of Best Buy stores. That doesn’t mean that Best Buy has a monopoly on consumer electronics stores, nor does Apple have a monopoly for computer app stores. True, Apple does have a monopoly when it comes to the iOS App Store.. but no more of a monopoly than Baskin Robbins has for ice cream sold by Baskin Robbins. That doesn’t mean you can’t by non-Baskin Robbins ice cream somewhere else, nor does it require Baskin Robbins to sell Hagen-Daz. If you want to be a sell your stuff at a store, you have to follow the rules of that store and pay the commission. Just like there are other places to buy computer software for a mobile device, there are other places to buy ice cream.
- gojomo 8y agoKind of disappointing that so many people just want to downvote this thought, but no one can quote (or even seems to care about) the actual terms that Google (and Facebook) are alleged to have violated. All hail arbitrary Apple, unbound by contract or law! Save us from ourselves, Tim Cook!
- cmsj 8y agoThis is a fairly pointless comment, but since you asked, it's Section 2.1 of https://download.developer.apple.com/Documentation/License_Agreements__Apple_Developer_Enterprise_Program/Apple_Developer_Enterprise_Program_License_Agreement_20181019.pdf https://download.developer.apple.com/Documentation/License_A... which you may need to be a registered Apple Developer to view. So, a relevant quote: "Apple grants you...license to.... (f) Allow Your Customers to use Your Internal Use Applications on Deployment Devices, but only (i) on Your physical premises and/or on Your Permitted Entity’s physical premises, or (ii) in other locations, provided all such use is under the direct supervision and physical control of Your Employees or Permitted Users (e.g., a sales presentation to a Customer);"
- gojomo 8y agoThanks! But, depending on the definitions of 'Employees' and 'Permitted Users' (and perhaps 'Permitted Entity'), that section's wording doesn't necessarily make the Facebook/Google use prohibited. FWIW, I am a paid-up, registered member of the Apple Developer program, but still can't access that page, as it is apparently limited only to enterprise developers. So I can't check the definitions/details myself. That limitation also helps me understand why so few, here or in the journalistic coverage I've seen, seem willing to quote the exact section violated. Those curious and willing to answer perhaps cannot access the formal wording, whereas those with the rights to access the terms may fear they'd be violating some obscure provision of their Apple agreements by merely quoting it.
- seanalltogether 8y agoWhat enterprise certs are meant for and what they are used for in practice are very different things. Apple themselves bought out the Testflight service and integrated it into their toolchain and it was built on using enterprise certs to distribute to external users. It has always been used as a release valve for the standard restrictions of the app store process.
- JimDabell 8y ago> Apple themselves bought out the Testflight service and integrated it into their toolchain and it was built on using enterprise certs to distribute to external users. This isn't true; when you logged in with TestFlight, they pushed a configuration profile to you that would collect your UDID. The developer would then register those UDIDs with Apple and sign the app with an ad hoc provisioning profile / normal developer certificate, as Apple intends. You could also distribute enterprise apps through TestFlight, but they did nothing specifically to help you do that, they were just a hosting service in that respect. They certainly didn't abuse enterprise certificates themselves, although somebody using their service could, just as they could use any hosting service to distribute the apps OTA.
- faizmokhtar 8y agoDoes the external testers in TestFlight work the same way as the one you mentioned too?
- JimDabell 8y agoWe're talking about the old TestFlight service from before Apple acquired them. It's the new TestFlight service that distinguishes between internal and external testers. There's very little similarity between the old and the new TestFlight beyond their general mission statements. They don't work in the same way at all and the new TestFlight was built from the ground up.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- a-wu 8y agoI might be naive in this but I hope Apple does revoke the certs, not because of the privacy implications (which I still do have concerns about), but because I would like to see the rules applied evenly. We’ve seen Apple apply the rules differently to big vs small developers but this time it’s Google and FB and by revoking FB certs for being in violation of terms, they must unquestionably revoke Google’s certs lest they bring on another bias debate.
- skh 8y agoThe rules should not be applied the same to everyone. Apple needs to look out for its long term interests and it can deal with small companies in ways that it can not deal with Google or Facebook without harming said interests. It's sort of like the quip, "Owe the bank $10,000 and they control you. Owe the bank $1,000,000,000 and you control them." In the world of business there are unequal relationships.
- Varcht 8y agoYou are chastising Techcrunch for reporting the truth? There are some things we just don't need to worry our little heads about?
- pixxel 8y agoApple just took Google’s money to be the default integrated browser/Siri search engine in iOS. Apple’s morality on privacy has a price. The public outrage will need to be huge. Heh.
- eridius 8y agoI remember a while back them talking about how they use Bing with Siri and about how Apple anonymizes the queries so Bing doesn't know who's actually doing them. I would imagine they'd apply the same anonymization to other search providers too.
- simple_phrases 8y agoReminds me of the anonymized AOL search dump from back in the day[1]. Needless to say, the dump was a trove of personally identifiable information despite being "anonymized". [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/AOL_search_data_leak https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/AOL_search_data_leak
- eridius 8y agoMy vague recollection is Apple would actually take the Siri request and route it to Bing for you, so Bing doesn't know your IP, and they would attach a unique identifier that they'd rotate every 15-or-so minutes, so that way Bing can correlate multiple requests done back-to-back but loses any correlation with requests outside that 15-minute window.
- pixxel 8y agoSo Google pays a reported 9-12 billion a year for data it can’t tie to user profiles. The skeptical fuck in me finds that hard to believe. That means Google pays that money simply to ward off Bing/Yahoo. Maybe. I’m interested to know more.
- eridius 8y agoFor actually serving Siri search results directly, I'm not sure what benefit the search provider gets. My guess is they're really after the "Search Web" fallback if you're not satisfied by Siri's initial synopsis, which will take you to the search page (and therefore the search provider will now know who you are).
- nerdjon 8y agoIs Amazon next? Microsoft? Who else would benefit from something like this, and have the ability to pull it off? I am hoping this gains more traction and Google and Facebook get very publicly shammed. However, I am curious if there is anything Apple can do to stop this without actually breaking the functionality of enterprise deployment certificates.
- Illniyar 8y agoLet's not forget that the appstore is an anti-competitive lawsuit waiting to happen. If apple is going to antagonize some of the biggest lobbying tech firms there's no telling what the windfall would be.
- renholder 8y ago>If apple is going to antagonize some of the biggest lobbying tech firms... Google and Facebook would be the antagonists with the Enterprise Certificates and Apple would be protoganist, in these scenarios, yeah? In other words, it's not as if Apple is telling these companies to use their Enterprise Certificates to skirt Apple's review process and then pulling their certificates when they're discovered to be doing so. Calling Apple the antagonist, at least in these scenarios, seems a bit disingenuous to what's actually playing-out.
- mmmmmmmmm 8y agoNobody called Apple the antagonist. Learn to read.
- _bxg1 8y agoGoogle in recent years has felt like the Lyft to Facebook's Uber. It does a lot of the same evil things, but uses just enough restraint and decorum to let Facebook remain the one in the hot-seat. It avoids scrutiny by simply being less icky.
- sramsay 8y ago"Be Less Evil" didn't have quite the same ring. Also: yes.
- gdulli 8y agoAlso, a company that offers a wide variety of services and collects your personal data to distribute internally among those services seems to get a pass. Compared to companies that are more vertical and benefit by selling your data rather than using it themselves. Even though you've lost your privacy either way.
- mattkevan 8y ago“Mister Pichai, we can NOT allow a creepiness gap!”
- ganeshkrishnan 8y agoGoogle started being shady way before Pichai joined. I doubt he has much power to change the board decisions.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ardy42 8y ago> Google in recent years has felt like the Lyft to Facebook's Uber. It does a lot of the same evil things, but uses just enough restraint and decorum to let Facebook remain the one in the hot-seat. It avoids scrutiny by simply being less icky. Many of Google's services have a great deal more basic utility than anything Facebook provides. I think that also provides additional cover for them. When Facebook pushes for more data collection, it almost always looks way more self-serving than when Google does.
- sidewaysloading 8y agoThis is Google not only intercepting people's smartphone traffic, but a lot more: - Google will send you a router to intercept your entire household's internet traffic on all devices with a browser (https://support.google.com/audiencemeasurement/answer/7574391?hl=en&ref_topic=7573819 https://support.google.com/audiencemeasurement/answer/757439...) - Google will send you a device that listens 24/7 to audio in the room to figure out what you are watching on TV and listening to (https://support.google.com/audiencemeasurement/answer/7574764?hl=en&ref_topic=7562482 https://support.google.com/audiencemeasurement/answer/757476...) - Google's project includes tracking of desktop and laptop internet activity via a browser extension that can basically read literally anything you do online (https://support.google.com/audiencemeasurement/answer/7574481?hl=en&ref_topic=7573811 https://support.google.com/audiencemeasurement/answer/757448...) This isn't just trying to figure out what new up-and-coming apps are going to be the next big thing, this is Google building out very far-reaching profiles of your entire household, in return for some gift cards. This is signing away your family's entire digital life (and a significant part of anyone they interact with in a browser).
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mont 8y ago> Google's project includes tracking of desktop and laptop internet activity via a browser extension that can basically read literally anything you do online What browser extension is this?
- ppeetteerr 8y agoI "love" how the reward are gift cards, not actual money. How much more insulting can they be: your privacy is not even worth liquid currency. Some people probably need the gift cards, but it's as upsetting as people selling blood for gift cards.
- ppeetteerr 8y agoI suspect Apple's policy is "we're going to turn a blind eye on this until it becomes public". If it leaks, we'll act.
- chooseaname 8y agoDon't they have to? They don't know what every company is actually doing with the Enterprise certs.
- garyb2 8y agoThey know how many installations are active and how many people work for the org. When wildly out of line they could send a lawyer-gram and then shut it down if they don't get a response that accounts for the difference. Enterprise apps still phone home to the mother ship (Apple) and will refuse to run if, for example, the device doesn't have an internet connection for some number of days. (90 if memory serves.)
- chooseaname 8y agoOk, but this is now Apple having to police thousands of organizations. That's just not practical. I think they should handle it on a case by case basis.
- saagarjha 8y ago> Enterprise apps still phone home to the mother ship (Apple) and will refuse to run if, for example, the device doesn't have an internet connection for some number of days. (90 if memory serves.) I would not be surprised if the list of apps that a user has is not disclosed to Apple, and the only thing that is exchanged is Apple's "blacklist" of revoked certificates.
- ppeetteerr 8y agoThis illegal use of enterprise certificates must have leaked. How big is Facebook, after all.
- fixermark 8y ago"Putting the not-insignificant issues of privacy aside — in short, many people lured by financial rewards may not fully take in what it means to have a company fully monitoring all your screen-based activity..." Not putting those issues aside, it's oddly paternalistic of us to assume people selling their data aren't making a rational trade. Uninformed data collection is one thing, but when we start looking down our noses at folks who are willing to get compensated for letting a big company spy on them consensually? That starts to look a bit "We know what's best for you, and it's not to let megacorporations have your data" elitist. What if people look at the sum total of what companies have done with big data and like what they see?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- greglindahl 8y ago"may not fully take in" is pretty clearly NOT making that assumption, so you're doing a lot of name-calling over something that doesn't appear to have been said.
- LarvaFX 8y agoYeah, we see what they did with Trump, yo...https://www.opendemocracy.net/brexitinc/paul-hilder/they-were-planning-on-stealing-election-explosive-new-tapes-reveal-cambridg https://www.opendemocracy.net/brexitinc/paul-hilder/they-wer...
- m0zg 8y agoYeah, this seems _way_ less nefarious than what's going on behind the scenes to everybody else without their consent. At least they get people to consent and compensate them in this case, whereas nobody asks you whether you'd like to be tracked on the internet, and there's no way to turn it all off. If I were to guess, this stuff isn't just "here's a router and we'll send you a check". There should also be a huge and very detailed survey the user needs to fill out so that Google could then correlated that data with similar demographics based on co-visitation. This is also not new. Many years ago at Google I sat directly across the hall from the team that did demographic inference based on (IIRC) Nielsen panel data. I think it's safe to say that _every_ advertising company does this one way or another. Basically at a high level they'd look at where Nielsen-paid tracked folks (about whom they knew everything) went on the web, and then looked at you, and their algorithm would guess your gender, age, income level, education level, etc etc.
- rawrmaan 8y agoWow, this is making me realize how much power Apple holds as the arbiter of enterprise certs. They hold more power to quickly punish other corporations than even the government does, in a certain respect. I hope they continue to leverage that power for good--iOS has tremendous market share and Apple can entirely force other companies to play by their rules.
- ydnaclementine 8y agoFool me once, shame on you; fool me twice, shame on me
- glitchc 8y agoNo no, it's "Fool me twice... you can't get fooled again."
- skybrian 8y ago"in short, many people lured by financial rewards may not fully take in what it means to have a company fully monitoring all your screen-based activity" I would like to see this spelled out. What are the risks? Why is this any worse than being a Nielsen family back in the day? It seems like the most likely thing to happen to the people who signed up for this is: nothing. They helped a tech company with their research and got paid. That's it.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoNielsen captures drastically less, and less-specific information than any of these modern Internet-based ad networks.
- HillaryBriss 8y agoi don't believe the Nielsen boxes had microphones that monitored the conversation in the room.
- skybrian 8y agoBut they could have! See what I did there? It seems like confusing what a company could have done with what they did is a common rhetorical move these days.
- lotu 8y agoIt has been pointed out else where in the thread that they do have mics in them. It is possible that Nielsen is only looking for audio from TVs and Phones, but Google also wants general audio for speech recognition. But I'm not sure.
- HillaryBriss 8y agoi stand corrected. thank you.
- nerdjon 8y agoNielson data is a very small very targeted piece of data. Nielson may be able to somewhat tell something about your family (so critically it is about a group of people instead of an individual person, which is a major difference). Considering how most people use their phones, this basically gives Google all of your information. There is little to nothing they would not know about you. Worse is them being able to get information about other people (thanks to them messaging you, while you have this tracker running) without their consent.
- srkmno 8y agoI don't understand what's so objectionable here? there is ample disclosure, it's for adults, and those who opt in receive rewards, is this really about everyone being concerned for apple's terms or is it just that it's "hip" to portray tech companies in the worst possible light?
- saagarjha 8y agoDistributing apps signed with an enterprise certificate to users is against the rules.
- srkmno 8y agoYeah what's the exact text that says that? Besides this isn't portrayed as an apple terms mismatch story it clearly reads as another pearl clutching privacy panic clickbait.
- saagarjha 8y ago> Join the Apple Developer Enterprise Program for 299 USD per year and get everything you need to start distributing proprietary in-house apps to your employees. From the page describing the program: https://developer.apple.com/programs/enterprise/ https://developer.apple.com/programs/enterprise/
- pertymcpert 8y agoYou really want a source? That's a completely obvious violation. Otherwise you'd see lots of apps by 3rd parties being used without going through App Store approval. Come on.
- cmsj 8y agoThis kind of program doesn't just suck up the data of the people who opted in with (theoretically) clear knowledge of what it means, it also likely pulls in data about the other people they communicate with using their phone, and none of those people consented to anything. Even if we were to pretend that isn't the case, why is it so necessary for companies to be able to suck up so much data about people? Why shouldn't we insist that companies respect our privacy in the same way we respect each others' privacy (I'm assuming that you don't go and peek into your neighbours' windows to figure out what they've been buying recently).
- gesman 8y agoGoogle and FB should partner with Huawei to complete the picture.
- spdustin 8y agoI assume the gift card sponsors are companies that are given access to this data in some form?
- clarketus 8y agoFrom what I've read, the Facebook research app installed a new root certificate on the device which allowed man-in-the-middle interception of all encrypted internet traffic. Which is obviously a huge issue. From what I've read, the Google app does not appear to be doing this. I am assuming the main reason that Apple revoked the enterprise distribution certificate for Facebook is due to this man-in-the-middle attack on encrypted traffic. The fact that they are solely circumventing the Appstore using an enterprise distribution certificate is a different issue. Is my understanding of all this true? It would seem to me that Google isn't really doing anything that bad and Facebook has had its enterprise distribution certificate revoked for good reason.
- brown9-2 8y agoNo, Apple’s statement makes it clear that the use of the enterprise distribution certificate signing method for this use case is an issue. https://www.recode.net/2019/1/30/18203231/apple-banning-facebook-research-app https://www.recode.net/2019/1/30/18203231/apple-banning-face... “We designed our Enterprise Developer Program solely for the internal distribution of apps within an organization. Facebook has been using their membership to distribute a data-collecting app to consumers, which is a clear breach of their agreement with Apple. Any developer using their enterprise certificates to distribute apps to consumers will have their certificates revoked, which is what we did in this case to protect our users and their data. “
- userbinator 8y agoI wonder if Facebook may argue on what constitutes an "organization" or "consumer", because the sum of all Facebook users is clearly a something... and as much as those users consume, they are also the ones ultimately contributing to Facebook's profits... it's not so black and white after all.
- sydd 8y agoIt doesn't really matter what Facebook says, Apples TOS is basically "we can ban you without consequences whenever we want"
- jechamt 8y agoI don't yet see any discussion here on the effective difference between the assumed conclusion of this news, so I'll add this: How do you expect the difference between Google and Facebook's internal ecosystems, and even their competitive stance (or lack thereof) with Apple, would affect the decision to revoke the enterprise certs? Hypothetically, if Apple proceeded to revoke Google's enterprise certs on the same basis, wouldn't it have significantly less effect on Google's day-to-day operations? Certainly there large teams of iOS developers working on iOS apps, but I would expect (with no basis but idle speculation) that most other Google employees outside those teams are on Android and it would simply cause issues with Google's ability to develop apps on a competing platform. If this is correct, then couldn't this act be interpreted as more of an anti-competitive move? I'm curious others' thoughts on this aspect of the recent sequence of news.
- calewis 8y agoThe editor who wrote that headline had to be British.
- saagarjha 8y agoWhy, is their word choice indicative of a British writer?
- Groxx 8y ago>"The Screenwise Meter iOS app should not have operated under Apple’s developer enterprise program — this was a mistake, and we apologize. ..." This isn't something you can do accidentally. What's the actual explanation, beyond "oops, we got caught"?
- cmsj 8y ago"Oops, we got caught" is exactly the explanation. Everything about this app, from how it was coded, how it was signed, how it was distributed and how it was documented on google.com was done with full knowledge of what was going on - it had to be. You can't build, release, or document an app like this without knowing that you're outside the normal App Store process.
- Svoka 8y agoI have an issue with calling enterprise certificate distribution a "back door". It is a good thing for specific uses. Facebook & Google misused it for something inappropriate, explicitly against rules Apple set for it. It is hard to enforce this kinds of distributions, but it is very useful for lots of people and companies, which are not into data collection business.
- imhelpingu 8y agoPeople need to start seriously considering doing everything they possibly can to get tech monopolies completely out of their lives.
- _bxg1 8y agoThere was an update to the article: Google totally discontinued and disabled the app, apparently in under three hours. It'll be interesting to see how Apple responds given that this was a "first offense" and didn't appear to be actively trying for deception, but it was also still an abuse of the enterprise certificate, which the first version of Facebook's app wasn't.
- cmsj 8y agoI'd put an asterisk on "totally", considering the app is still available for Android[0]. They acted quickly when their hand was caught in the cookie jar, they didn't suddenly grow a conscience. [0] - https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.google.android.apps.userpanel&hl=en_US https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.google.and...
- _bxg1 8y agoOh of course. Even the original iteration of Facebook's is still on the Play store. I was more commenting on how scared Apple had about sharing Facebook's fate.
- shanehoban 8y agoI can see Facebook OS coming down the lines. Doesn't seem like they will stop until they have nobody to answer to. Google are pretty set as it stands.
- edoloughlin 8y agoSigh, another Techcrunch article. Another "Before you continue... TechCrunch is now part of the Oath family" interstitial page and no way to actually turn off tracking, just links to numerous privacy policies. No thanks. I haven't read a Techcrunch article in months.
- Gustomaximus 8y agoDisclosure: Did the acquisition marketing for this product across a few countries. I think it's unfair comparing the 2. The Google product isn't grabbing the same about of personal data. It was focused on device usage, apps, media consumptions etc. Personally I was surprised Google were respectful enough to not be grabbing this data passively in the first place. This app was an add-on that was upfront about what it was doing and paid people for providing this access to their behaviour. And this desire to understand how people use products seems a reasonable thing for a company to want to know about improving and creating products. Do people saying this is bad feel its wrong to get people in a research group for an unboxing to see how people unfamiliar with a product do things. As long as its opt-in and clear about what its doing this seems reasonable and feels people are making a storm in a teacup... but maybe I'm missing something?