5 ms·
I think that the best thing is that it shows it is possible! More interestingly, it does not even seem to require all out austerity measures. For example, if
by nkurz 16y ago
I think that the best thing is that it shows it is possible! More interestingly, it does not even seem to require all out austerity measures. For example, if you choose "Cap Medicare growth" and "Reduce the number of troops in Iraq and Afghanistan to 30,000 by 2013" you are halfway there for 2030 with only those two choices.
Go on to choose "Eliminate Loopholes but keep taxes slightly higher", "Reduce Tax Break on Employer-provided Health Insurance", "Payroll tax: Subject some incomes above $106,000 to tax" and the 3 largest cut-military-spending options and you are done. Sure, these things aren't as side-effect-free as they sound, but it almost sounds feasible and does not require flour sacks and cat food.
- tomjen3 16y agoYou don't even have to raise the taxes - all you have to do is more eligibility for social security to 70 and that alone will get you half way there, combined with ending the waste in Iraq/Afghanistan and that is all that is required.
- eru 16y agoAnd ending farm subsidies is a good thing, in any case. Even if that would not save any single dollar. (Just getting rid of the market distortion would be good enough.)
- raquo 16y agoMarket distortions are unilateral evil only under a ton of economic assumptions. I don't know enough about the US agriculture foods market (let alone how exactly is it subsidized) but I would imagine it to be reasonable to provide your farmers with some kind of protectionism against foreign suppliers because the latter definitely have lower costs, with cheap labor, less legalities, whatever. You really don't want to depend on some China for your food supply.
- marvin 16y ago...and also you want to make sure that you have a fair bit of domestic food production in case war or some other geopolitical event causes imports to become expensive or unavailable. It's potentially a life-and-death question. You Americans don't have a lot of history with this, but Europeans have.
- CapitalistCartr 16y agoThe USA is a major producer and exporter of food, most of which doesn't get subsidies. Reducing or eliminating the subsidies on corn, sugar, peanuts, and milk wouldn't make that change. We are the most successful agricultural producer on Earth.
- vilhelm_s 16y agoConversely, you may _want_ interdependence for exactly this reason. If two countries are dependent on each other for basic needs, they will not be able to go to war. This kind of reasoning was the seed for the European Union: by joining the coal and steel industries of France and Germany into a single entity, the European Coal and Steel Community was thought to make further wars in West Europe practically impossible.
- quanticle 16y agoThe US is the worlds largest exporter of grain. I think we'll have enough even without subsidies that strangle African farmers.
- tomjen3 16y agoIts one thing to do protectionism (if you want to ensure a base level on quality, codify that in law and put harsh enough penalties on it that people follow them), but the way the US does it is that they subsidize corn production, but put protection in against foreign sugar which means sugar is very expensive, but corn is cheap and so is used as a substitute.
- tesseract 16y ago
- kingkawn 16y agoYou could save even more money by eliminating social security altogether, yet it is a useful service that shouldn't be dismantled for the sake of budgets alone. When cutting its important to take into consideration why something was started.
- eru 16y agoOr even better: Why something is useful right now. But there's enough waste you can cut, without impacting on the worse off too hard.
- nodata 16y agoI think that increasing eligibility for social security to 70 is dumb. It should be linked to something, like life expectancy. Without a formula we have to face the same upheaval every time people live longer.
- anthonyb 16y agoI think that's the other side of the coin - which the puzzle sort of glosses over. Costs are going to go up wildly, mainly due to increased health care costs and an ageing population. Without either capping medicare or increasing the retirement age, you have to slash a whole bunch of stuff to make up an equivalent amount.
- cletus 16y agoI have some questions for you: 1. What state decided the 2000 election? 2. What state has a huge retiree population? 3. What state, which was once a safe Republican state, was a swing state in 2004 and 2008 and will likely be a swing state in 2012? Hint: the answer to all three is "Florida".
- m_myers 16y agoRaising the minimum age wouldn't hurt people who are already retired. But that wouldn't stop the AARP from mobilizing its entire membership against it, of course.
- jbooth 16y agoAll you have to do is cap medicare growth? Wow, that's easy. How's that work? How do you "cap" it? Obamacare was a huge process just to limit future growth, and it involved talk about "death panels" in order to make incremental reform happen. What's a straight "cap" look like?
- quanticle 16y agoWell the specific proposal the New York Times cites would essentially put Medicare funding on autopilot. Instead of letting Medicare funding be dependent on the whims of the current Congress it would allocate 1% of GDP to Medicare every year. It would be up to the Medicare administrators to determine how to spend that 1%. I think its a good idea, but its so politically infeasible, it may as well not be considered. I mean, anyone who tries to defend a hard limit like that is going to get totally mauled by the other party, who will demagogue it as, "You're going to kill seniors by taking away their health care."
- jeffreymcmanus 16y agoThere's a hard limit on it today, this would just make the hard limit consistent.