3 ms·
Yes, they were risky, but the risks were understood (and the technical people certainly were not giving any inaccurate information to managers about them). Not
by pdonis 8y ago
Yes, they were risky, but the risks were understood (and the technical people certainly were not giving any inaccurate information to managers about them). Not the same situation as the shuttle SRB O-rings, where at the time of the Challenger launch nobody understood exactly what was causing the failures; the engineers had suspicions but no definite knowledge (and their efforts to get NASA and their managers to give them more data to help them better understand the failures had been mostly unsuccessful).
- WalterBright 8y ago> nobody understood exactly what was causing the failures Nobody understood exactly at the time what was causing the F1 engine instability. They were reduced to trying random things and hoping it worked. The mathematical models to figure it out were not developed until years later. The schedule was rushed out of fear the Soviets would beat them. Don't mistake the success of the gamble as the same as the risk was low and understood. NASA gambled big time, and they were very lucky. I'm not saying they were wrong to take the gamble, either. But they knew the engines might blow up and launched anyway.
- pdonis 8y ago> Nobody understood exactly at the time what was causing the F1 engine instability. Hm, interesting, I didn't realize the state of knowledge was that limited at the time. > Don't mistake the success of the gamble as the same as the risk was low and understood. I didn't mean to imply that the risk was low. You're right that it wasn't (and you've clarified that it wasn't well understood either). It still seems like a different decision process from the one that led to the Challenger explosion, though. In the Saturn V case, it seems like NASA made an open-eyed decision to gamble with everyone involved being aware of the risk and on board with it. In the Challenger case, NASA basically refused to properly evaluate the risk in the first place.