4 ms·
Really? Do you not think such a culture is actively detrimental? How can you ask anyone to give 110% if they might be getting sacked next year? If you have a
by benj111 8y ago
Really?
Do you not think such a culture is actively detrimental? How can you ask anyone to give 110% if they might be getting sacked next year?
If you have a tremendous number of low achievers, maybe its because the only people you can retain are people who can't find jobs elsewhere fast enough. I know I wouldn't be waiting around for my turn.
- czbond 8y agoI disagree with this. Every organization, and every department has a bell curve of talent. Average and low-average people hire sub-par and poor talent because everyone thinks they're rockstars, but statistically that cannot be true.
- benj111 8y ago"everyone thinks they're rockstar" Exactly, but knowing that, even if you think you're safe, you might not be, so what do you do? Plus you're saying below average people hire below poor talent. This just means that really the good manager is sacking good people, whereas the poor manager is sacking just 1 of his limitless supply of poor hires. So as an average employee what do you want, good manager and be bottom of the bell curve, or poor manager and be top of the bell curve?
- ex_amazon_sde 8y agoHuge oversimplification. Some companies can hire very good engineers most of the time. Most companies cannot.
- Twirrim 8y ago> Do you not think such a culture is actively detrimental? How can you ask anyone to give 110% if they might be getting sacked next year? As much as I dislike the forced attrition mechanism, people putting in 110% are not going to be forced out. It's the people putting in 30% that are going to be the attrition targets.
- benj111 8y agoNo it probably won't be the people giving 110%. But you want those people invested it what they're doing, or they won't be giving 110%. To put it another way. You should be focussed on maintaining and motivating the top 10%, not on getting rid if your bottom 10%.
- busterarm 8y ago110% and 30% by what metrics though? My 30% could be somebody else's 110%, though that's not the likely scenario we're talking about. What if instead, some people put in 110% by putting in 14 hour days and others are judged more harshly who have family or other obligations. This is how we get an industry of 20-somethings with no lives other than work. In a forced attrition scenario, if I were on a team with people significantly younger than myself, I would be shitting bricks.
- Twirrim 8y ago> if I were on a team with people significantly younger than myself, I would be shitting bricks. I was noticeably older than most of the people in my team in Amazon, and I was never shitting bricks[1]. The ones not reaching performance targets were always crystal clear to _everyone_. If you can't spot the underachievers, maybe that's the time to worry. Despite how detailed the Amazon interview process is, people slip through the gaps and you end up with someone who somehow can barely write functional code, let alone maintainable code. Or you find the person is capable of writing code, just maybe not today, or tomorrow. Is the day after good with you? There are much more interesting things to be doing on-line instead of writing code. [1] I was reminiscing with a co-worker in the kitchen one lunchtime about the respective things we'd had to do to deal with the Y2K bug at the places we'd been working at. Another talented and very capable developer co-worker overheard us and commented "I'd never even touched a computer before, back then."
- megaman8 8y agoIf a company is hiring people who can't write code then their hiring process has huge problems. In my 15 years of developer experience at 5+ companies, I've never once met a developer who couldn't code. I don't know where companies are finding all these developers who supposedly can't code.