3 ms·
"...it's a rather limited view of the problem not really taking into account the various feedback loops each option has when it feeds back into the economy and
by bilbo0s 16y ago
"...it's a rather limited view of the problem not really taking into account the various feedback loops each option has when it feeds back into the economy and thus back into taxes collected..."
This would be a difficult thing to do. What would be an acceptable model for these feedback loops? Given that, at the end of the day, the budget MUST balance.
Let's say we all agreed that cutting taxes X%, would have a Y% chance of increasing tax revenue Z% over W number of years. How do we know that? Or, more precisely, what is the probability ratio that we assign that node in the decision tree? Y, right. Now if Y is not 1, then we do not KNOW that the budget will be balanced at date W. My point is, when modeling economic feedback loops 'Y' is rarely 1.
So I think what they are saying is, given the serious nature of the current economic shortfalls, they will confine the discussion to only those cuts whose savings can be assigned a probability ratio of 1 in the decision tree. I think they would readily concede that this leads to 'non-creative' solutions. But the output of that decision tree is also guaranteed to work if implemented.
- lukeschlather 16y agoNothing on that list has an obvious probability ratio of 1. This is world politics, not a computer simulation. Most government services provide a safety net for minimal-income workers. You take that away, the lower class could quickly become insolvent, threatening our entire social structure. Obviously I'm specifically hitting entitlement, but all government services have people who rely on them, and in most cases the government does them more efficiently than private business can. Military spending secures the US role as world superpower. You take that away and businesses working abroad have a much harder time creating factories with exploitative labor pricing. Prices rise. There is a possible good outcome where factories are forced back into the states, but it's a gamble. Take that stuff away, there's barely 100 billion worth of cuts with a probability ratio with anything approaching 1.
- eru 16y ago> Military spending secures the US role as world superpower. You take that away and businesses working abroad have a much harder time creating factories with exploitative labor pricing. Prices rise. Sounds very outlandish to me. But then, by that understanding, say, Germany is probably just freeriding on American oppression.
- lukeschlather 16y agoYes, but nobody can agree on which cuts have a reasonably small chance of an economic backlash that wipes out the hypothetical cost saving. So it sounds outlandish to you, but there's a large group to which our military budget is a thing of vital importance to the stability of our nation that we cannot cut. Me I'd like to see it drastically reduced, but I'm not going to pretend it's clear the results will be economically positive.
- regularfry 16y agoThe sort of feedback loops you're talking about aren't really that difficult to analyse. They're just complicated. The difficulty is that, as you refer to, the political climate makes it difficult. The specific difficulty I see is that it's politically impossible to try a policy out and then tweak it quickly if it turns out to be necessary to do so. Accurate and timely data collection to be able to do so is also a big issue, and it's one I'd rather see more budget allocated to.