3 ms·
You're implying (perhaps unintentionally) that selling an organ is equivalent to selling information on what websites you visit. There's a reason selling organs
by Wowfunhappy 8y ago
You're implying (perhaps unintentionally) that selling an organ is equivalent to selling information on what websites you visit. There's a reason selling organs is illegal, at least in the US.
I don't think personal information is so valuable that we need to outlaw its sale.
- barrkel 8y agoOrgan selling isn't illegal because organs are valuable.
- grp000 8y agoImpingement on quality of life by the seller of an organ can be, and is translated to a value statement. However, the paradoxical nature of human beings which relies largely on emotional responses dictates that while we can have people starving in the streets, because it would make society squeamish, they can't be allowed to sell their organs, for the sake of their own human dignity and quality of life, never mind that society stripped them of both anyway.
- Normal_gaussian 8y agoThis isn't paradoxical at all, when both options are horrific there is little benefit to cover up one with the other and claim a solution. Furthermore a short term windfall from selling organs will not provide the skills or assets required to prevent long term starvation and homelessness; so now the horror has been compounded: homeless, starving, and prone to debilitating illness.
- grp000 8y agoThe paradoxical nature is that being homeless and starving is horrifying but something humans have become accustomed to, and yet the idea of selling organs is embedded culturally as being shocking, even if the end result of being starving and homeless is relatively equivalent to being desperate enough to sell organs, so it's not allowed. Also, how you mention as fact that money from selling organs won't prevent long term starvation and homelessness is surprising; you don't know that's the case one way or another but you're trying to pass off an opinion as fact. I can't argue either that it would help with a clear and definite metric, but the correlation of living conditions and money is clear. How real-life application of such legalization or organ selling, with quality of surgery and post-surgery care, legal predatory practices, and other factors are dealt with are potential problems, but those are issues that exist in all commercial domains. I also never argued organ selling as a solution to a problem; as others mentioned, it is a potential band-aid to a problem that lies in wealth inequalities, but which I find interesting as a societal flashpoint that show how knee-jerk emotional responses can cause logical paradoxes.
- barrkel 8y agoImpingement on quality of life by the seller of an organ can be, and is translated to a value statement. How much is a Jew's life worth vs a Christian's life vs a Muslim's life? Or would it make you squeamish to try and adjudicate that? Or are some things not worth putting a price on because of principles, because breaking those principles would have worse second and third order effects?
- grp000 8y agoWell, the market as an aggregate dictates that. It's entirely reasonable to assume that from market to market, buyers have different value assessments for people of different religions, and place different values on each. On a personal level, I would pass judgment by objective quality of organ, but that's beside the point. The idea of employment already places value statements on people and mainstream moral perceptions mark discrete points that shift from moral to immoral, when in fact its all on a continuous scale and the point at which it shifts is arbitrary.
- peteradio 8y agoNoone said they were equal, just that informed consent is important.
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y agoI’m led to believe a whole bunch of intellectual heavy weights agree that privacy is so important it needs to be heavily regulated fairly immediately. I tend to agree with them. Come to think of it, is there anyone making a strong case for weaker privacy protection? I’m prepared to put aside my existing assumptions long enough to read an article or two.
- pluma 8y ago> I don't think personal information is so valuable that we need to outlaw its sale. Europeans seem to disagree. Maybe your "reason" is just cultural bias?
- dx034 8y agoGDPR doen't outlaw the sale of personal data. It just prohibits selling personal data without user consent. Under GDPR, it should be perfectly legal to compensate a user for agreeing to share personal data with marketing companies.
- pluma 8y agoNo, the point is that under GDPR you can't sell personal data because it remains the property of the person it was shared by. You can sell access to that data, but the purchaser inherits the terms under which that data was shared and can't use it for any purposes the owner did not already agree to -- plus that transfer itself has to be consensual. Also under GDPR the consent can be revoked at any point and the data has to be deleted. Plus the owner has to be given exhaustive information about what data was gathered, what basis it was gathered on and who it was passed on to (recursively).
- jolmg 8y ago> equivalent to selling information on what websites you visit. You make it sound like they're just obtaining a list of URLs, but that's not it. For $20, they get to impersonate you while you're in the VPN and after you leave (they have all your passwords and session cookies). They can also impersonate anyone you deal with. They have all decrypted information going between you and the rest of the internet. Not even your ISP gets that amount. Even further problematic is the scale at which they can do this. This isn't just a concern we should see as individuals but also as a group. They can control a grand portion of information flow and authentication in the whole web.