6 ms·
It's probably unthinkable for a lot of people these days, but the US once had an income tax for those in the highest tax bracket of over 90%.
by pmoriarty 8y ago
It's probably unthinkable for a lot of people these days, but the US once had an income tax for those in the highest tax bracket of over 90%.
- Kaveren 8y agoThis gets parroted out frequently by people who think it's a cute quip. This article, however, explains why the situation was much more complicated than can be explained in a one-liner.
- SeanBoocock 8y agoIn what way was it more complicated? The top marginal tax rate was ~90% and high earners used a number of means to structure their income to avoid paying that, just as they do today with a far lower rate. I don't think anyone who makes this observation thinks that people were less motivated to lower their tax burden when it was substantially larger.
- WalterBright 8y agoWhat the article meant was that the 90% tax rate was on paper, but people didn't pay it because they structured their income into tax shelters to avoid paying it. Those tax shelters were removed by Reagan in 1986 as part of the deal to lower the marginal rates. Another tax shelter not mentioned in the article was the "3 martini lunch" where people charged their lunches off to the business, so it was taxed at the lower business rate. This tax shelter was removed as part of that deal. In England, with their high tax rates, it was common to have the businesses provide cars for the employees for the same reason - tax avoidance. Tax avoidance is also why in America today people prefer to pay for their health insurance as a business expense rather than a personal one.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> What the article meant was that the 90% tax rate was on paper, but people didn't pay it because they structured their income into tax shelters to avoid paying it. This is also true with a 39.6% top marginal rate. The specific structuring methods have changed with tax policy (which has not all been closing loopholes; new favorable tax options available primarily to the rich have been opened up, as well), but “people, especially rich people, structure income for tax avoidance” didn't go away as maximum marginal rates dropped.
- WalterBright 8y agoIt was greatly reduced. Higher rates mean it becomes profitable to invest in crummier shelters. Lower rates means the shelters have to be much better. It goes back to do you want wealthier people to invest in improving the economy, or shuffling money around in marginal investments? I.e. do you want them investing in SpaceX, or some offshore shell game? Besides, something like half of the government tax money comes from very wealthy people.
- XMPPwocky 8y agoBut tax shelters aren't just manna sent down from Heaven to small island nations. They're products of the tax code- what we tax and how much. If "tax shelters" are nonproductive, that doesn't say much of anything about the tax rate directly- it's an orthogonal issue. If we're taxing things that we want more than things we don't want, that's the problem! The tax rate sets, among other things, how strong of an incentive folks have to do things that are taxed less. Right now, some unproductive and sometimes downright absurd things are taxed less. Playing with the tax rate just sets how big of a problem that is- to eliminate it, you need to do meaningful incentive engineering.
- WalterBright 8y agoMaximizing the tax rate on the most productive investments isn't good incentive engineering. But that's exactly what those high marginal tax rates are aimed at. Another way to look at it is look at the extremes. Nobody is going to spend much effort avoiding a 1% tax. They'll expend a heluva lot of effort avoiding a 99% tax.
- dahfizz 8y agoWhile I think it is absurd for the government to take a marginal 90+% from anyone's paycheck, regardless of whether they could "afford" it, it's worth noting that that tax bracket started at aprox $2 mil in today's dollar
- dragonwriter 8y ago> While I think it is absurd for the government to take a marginal 90+% from anyone's paycheck, regardless of whether they could "afford" it, it's worth noting that that tax bracket started at aprox $2 mil in today's dollar i.e., a vastly lower level than where the proposed 70% top rate would kick in.
- maceurt 8y agoStill not fair. Furthermore, taxation should be created out of neccesity, and should not just be thrown around for anything. If we really need the extra tax dollars figure out a way to allocate some money from other parts of the budget instead of increasing the tax willy nilly. Also, it is absurd that anybody would have to give away more of their legally earned income than they get to keep.
- jimcsharp 8y agoBy our collective grace are people permitted to be so successful. Not one of our most successful billionaires would be where they are today without the people around them. The fairness/absurd thing doesn't really fly with me because of this.
- dahfizz 8y agoThis strikes me as incredibly entitled. Do you think you deserve part of Jeff bezos's money because you voluntarily bought something from Amazon? >"By our collective grace are people permitted to be so successful" While I fundamentally disagree with you, if this applies to rich people, why doesn't it apply to everyone? Why shouldn't the government take 90% of your income? The logical conclusion to your position is communism. Nobody may have more than another because we all helped equally to build Amazon (no we didn't). The reason I disagree with your statement is that nobody participated in another's success unwillingly. It is not by "grace", it is by mutually beneficial transactions. Yeah you can make the argument that Amazon relies on the entire society around them to run: people to build and maintian roads, people who build and maintain and drive trucks, people who make cardboard and tape, people who buy from Amazon, etc etc etc. But here is the thing: all those people have been paid in the process. A fundamental principle of capitalism is that two rational actors only ever make a transaction if both people find it to be beneficial. Again, this is why I find it so entitled to claim some stake in Amazon's success when, by definition, you've already been compensated for your participation.
- agent008t 8y agoGiven that we are on HN, it is probably safe to assume most people here work in tech, earning 2x-3x the median salary or more. Would you actually want to be taxed at 90%?
- lotsofpulp 8y agoIf that would help result in a society where people are more educated, relaxed, healthier, and feel like they are part of a community, then yes. Technology and the efficiencies of scale are allowing fewer people to do more and whether they deserve it or not is not the question. The question is what kind of society do we want to live in.
- SolaceQuantum 8y agoFull honestly, I don't even make a braggable amount in the greater HN group (if I posted my TC on Blind I'd probably be laughed out of the room) and I wouldn't mind my paycheck to be taxed 90% above a treshold in which I live comfortably, especially if through government programs I can live comfortably on less with minimal guilt that other people are living uncomfortably(or even being essentially worked to death) while working harder than me.
- AlexTWithBeard 8y agoI don't mind paying 90% on a top portion of my income. But before we start collecting more money, I'd like to see existing money used wisely. New York City spends about 30k per homeless. And it's still not possible to walk a couple of blocks in Midtown without stumbling upon a homeless person sleeping rough. New York subway has a budget of 8+ billion. London tube is about 2 billion. I can keep going, but from the above I'm sure if we tax everyone at 101% the government will still manage to run a deficit...
- agent008t 8y agoGiven that not a single person here has protested against the idea of a 90% marginal tax rate, but some have expressed concerns about the funds being spent inefficiently, why not impose a voluntary tax on ourselves and agree to donate to charity 90% of earnings over a certain amount? Surely there are some very good charities that do work in the area you are most interested in - e.g. homelessness, educational scholarships, poverty in general? The added bonus is that a society where people voluntarily donate 90% to charity is a much better society than the one where people get taxed. It means a lot more when something is done voluntarily, and it changes the perceptions on the side of the people receiving the help.
- tjbiddle 8y agoDid you even read the article? The entire writing addresses this point.
- graeme 8y agoYes, that's what the article talks about, and how the rich avoided it legally.