2 ms·
>The win would be a scientific publication that takes science seriously. I agree that there is a winning option for the editors (to do a good job), there just
by whatshisface 8y ago
>The win would be a scientific publication that takes science seriously.
I agree that there is a winning option for the editors (to do a good job), there just isn't one for Thiel after the editors have done a bad job.
I think Thiel purposely set out to fund a "maverick" journal that published things that other people weren't. If you're doing that you can't just pick whoever is the most successful today to edit it - so, you will probably have a few nutters in the system. The no-win situation arises once the nutters get together and make a bad decision. Do you let them make a bad decision, or break the veil of independence?
If the financial backers were allowed to decide what is serious science and what isn't, I'm willing to bet that their version of "tobacco cures heart disease" will be the serious science while "leaded gasoline is a public health crisis" will be pushed aside.
- staticautomatic 8y agoEnforcing standards of scientific integrity is not censorship insofar as the rejection of a submission is based upon its failure to meet those standards and not because it contains an unpalatable but well-founded assertion. Accordingly, it's not a "lose" for anyone involved in the publication, including Thiel, to support the rejection of junk or pseudo science. When you say "once the nutters get together and make a bad decision," you're treating it as if it was a single thing or collection of things that happened at a single point in time, but that's not the case here. It's an ongoing thing, which naturally raises the prospect of a pattern. Taken together with what appears to be solicitation of submissions from people known to traffic in junk and pseudo science, I think it would be naive to not suspect an agenda on someone's part.
- whatshisface 8y agoWhat I'm trying to emphasize here is that sure, it can be fixed, but Thiel can't be the one to fix it. Any funding source is going to look bad if they start messing with editorial authority. It's not the funding source that is supposed to be maintaining that.
- staticautomatic 8y agoPerhaps he should stop funding it then.