3 ms·
I used visual programming many years ago, in the form of LabVIEW, and encountered the following issues: 1. The sheer physical labor involved in creating and ma
by analog31 8y ago
I used visual programming many years ago, in the form of LabVIEW, and encountered the following issues:
1. The sheer physical labor involved in creating and maintaining programs. I was going home each evening with severe eyestrain and wrist fatigue, due to the fine mouse work and clicking through menus.
2. Programs are more readable until they get bigger than one screen, then all hell breaks loose. You can arrange things in sub-programs, and use the equivalent of subroutines / classes. These are good techniques in any language, but it compounds the physical trauma problem exponentially.
On a separate note, I wonder if text based languages persist because it's just easier to create them. As a result, people are more likely to experiment with new languages, libraries, and so forth, if the format of a program, and its inputs and outputs, are text. If you want to invent a new graphical language, you have to create a full blown graphical manipulation package, and make it work on multiple platforms, just to get started. That's a huge amount of work, and it doesn't necessarily attract the same people who are interested in language development. The result is a more vibrant pace of development in languages if you're willing to give up graphical representation.
- Scarblac 8y agoI also spent four years long ago with LabVIEW. Also 3, you really miss source control tools that are smart enough to merge changes by different people in different branches. And useable diffs.
- slacka 8y agoI also worked on LabVIEW for a couple of years for our assembly line QA testing. In our case, all of our programs fit on a screen with only a few needing SubVIs. As long as the programs are relatively simple or are amenable to subroutines, it is one of the easiest languages to learn, teach, and make simple changes. My only complaint for our use case was lack of good source control.
- no_identd 8y ago#1 sounds like an issue with bad support for keyboard navigation, not an issue with visual programming. #2 sounds like you might want to take a look at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DRAKON https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DRAKON. Albeit Petri nets, as described in the OP article, also address many of these grievances.