4 ms·
Analogs to the real world are compelling, but this line of reasoning is nonsensical when applied to the digital realm. The magnitude differences of "constant fa
by mindslight 8y ago
Analogs to the real world are compelling, but this line of reasoning is nonsensical when applied to the digital realm. The magnitude differences of "constant factors" make the Internet paradigm/philosophy wildly different.
It's quite hard to accidentally put a potato in an exhaust pipe. One cannot write a script that mechanically puts a potato up every car in the world's tailpipe, in 5 minutes nonetheless!
An appropriate real world analogy would be something like a maker of explosion-proof equipment forgoes designing any actual protection against those harsh environments, and then blames the ensuing explosion on all that dust in the air.
The Internet was successful precisely due to scaling from the End to End principle. The Internet is hostile noise - as soon as something speaks IP, it must be capable of standing up for its own security rather than relying on some imagined benevolence or accountability. If a manufacturer is not up to this task, then there are plenty of non-globally-routing protocols (eg USB, bluetooth) that printers can use to communicate with a competent Internet node.
(Furthermore ignoring the digital spookiness, the actual damage doesn't even add up to much. If we assume they hacked 30k printers, that's only 60 reams of paper - on the scale of petty larceny. And given that we allow junk mail and other advertising companies to do far more damage as their above-board business, it's questionable whether that integral even applies!)