4 ms·
This really isn't that surprising is it? The human body relies on so many microbes that do not share what we consider to be "our" genes to function, wouldn't it
by AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y ago
This really isn't that surprising is it? The human body relies on so many microbes that do not share what we consider to be "our" genes to function, wouldn't it be odd if those microbes didn't have a communication channel with the brain? I guess people are still subconsciously uncomfortable with the idea that what they consider to be their self is a communal organism?
- neuronic 8y agoI studied bioengineering and bioinformatics and have often brought up this idea in conversations. Honestly, I think it's more that people simply don't realize / have ever thought of it because most are quite receptive to it. But sure, I have also gotten quite the negative reactions but it tends to be the same monkeys who dismiss anthropogenic climate change in the face of decades of evidence.
- reitanqild 8y ago> But sure, I have also gotten quite the negative reactions but it tends to be the same monkeys who dismiss anthropogenic climate change in the face of decades of evidence. Not denying anthropogenic climate change but until recently fat was dangerous and sugar was less dangerous. This goes back to the thirties, so definitely decades. Worse, when some of the loudest voices in the climate camp not only fly across the globe to climate conferences but in private jets, then you can understand why people are sceptical. (1400 private jets this year?) Same with the EAT campaign: travelling around the world in luxury, telling other people they can basically forget their current lifestyle. I'm not saying it isn't right. Personally I travel with public transit (bus, train, bus or walk) for a good hour to work and the same back home. I try to do reuse, repair and recycle in my household. We coordinate with 4-5 other families to get kids to soccer / other activities 3 times a week with as few cars as possible. It actually makes a lot of sense too. But it is not like we get any support from the thought leaders who fly around in a luxury we have a hard time imagining even. I can very well understand why people don't believe. So can we stop calling other people monkeys? If your are going to make a change you have to learn to make those people care. And you don't do that by calling them names.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- fxfan 8y agoAlso, further on the "just because you don't see or know doesn't mean absence" front- a lot of health issues don't manifest in weeks or months. Sometimes things accumulate over years. Something that FDA (or really the pharma companies) don't want you to think about.
- DrAwdeOccarim 8y agoI don't think it's that the FDA or pharma companies don't want you to think about, I think it's just very difficult to properly study the effect of things that take a lifetime to manifest.
- hnnh44 8y agoI'm inclined to believe this as well. It's so hard to get a statistically significant effect and approval for drugs that are worth billions of dollars, that there's simply little incentive to study and promote "natural" alternatives. Maybe moving to a city with better drinking water is the best move for a small subset of the population. There's no sinister cabal trying to hide this, there's just no incentive for anyone figure this out for you in an individual basis. I could see pharma working the other way though. If you could identify a location with a population who exhibit a deficiency and your drug is more effective there, there's an incentive to better promote it there. I don't think the industry is sophisticated enough at this point to accurately track this though, as individual patient response is difficult to measure and report on. Source: dated someone that did marketing for one if the top 5 pharmas.
- mmjaa 8y agoI think its more likely that the resistance to this idea is based on peoples addiction to quick fixes from well-marketed pharmaceutical products than anything else. Having been totally convinced by ones local authority that ones mental health issues are all a result of a lack of proper chemical balances in ones brains, being told that its really all about what you eat is .. unsavoury .. to those with a consumer-oriented mindset, who mostly just want to take a pill to solve problems while also being granted immunity from responsibility for ones dietary choices ...