3 ms·
There are a number of strategies, each of which has pros and cons. 1. Hard switch away from fossil fuels for base energy generation. The only option for this i
by vkou 8y ago
There are a number of strategies, each of which has pros and cons.
1. Hard switch away from fossil fuels for base energy generation. The only option for this is nuclear. Pros: This could reduce our emissions by ~60%. Cons: Everyone hates nuclear.
2. Transition to a steady state economy. Drastically reduce our net consumption of energy and raw resources, by taxing energy, resource extraction, or waste, while keeping the same mix of energy generation. Pros: You can reduce emissions by... As much as you want, with this. Cons: Everyone is banking on unlimited exponential growth, and this would cause an economic collapse/depression.
3. Invest hundreds of millions of people, and trillions of dollars into carbon sequestration. Pros: If we do enough of this, we can drive emissions negative. Cons: You can't do this cheaply. So, you get all the cons of #2. Also, you have to stop using fossil fuels, because there's no point to digging up and burning coal, at the same time that you're growing, and burying trees.
4. Do next to nothing, and let our children deal with the fallout. Pros: It's easy, and we're already doing it. Cons: Your grandchildren will inherit an ecological disaster.
There's no winning move.
- Iwan-Zotow 8y ago> There's no winning move. sure there is - #1 is clearly a winner. "Everyone hates nuclear" is zero cost change
- vkou 8y agoSure, you just have to get in bed with both the fossil fuel lobby, environmentalists, and the cost-sensitive lower-classes. All at once. Convince the three groups that their business is done, that they should do a 180 on the last four decades of their identity, and that they should pay twice as much for electricity, and you'll get them on board.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoOnly one of the three groups you mentioned needs to do an ideological 180. The masses don't care and the energy companies don't care so long as they stand to make money. Only (some) environmentalists activity dislike nuclear.
- tick_tock_tick 8y agoFor number 3 we already have very cheap solutions to carbon sequestration by artificially triggering algae blooms. The real questions is what kind of unintended consequences will come after.
- pfisch 8y agoI mean I think at this point it isn't unreasonable to say it's over for the ocean. Either we start sequestering on a massive scale or the ocean is going to turn into a pool of acid anyway. I wouldn't be surprised if it was already too late right now and all life in the ocean is just currently in a slow death spiral because of what we have already done.