4 ms·
Not only that, but we really don't need journalists in the traditional sense as much as we used to. It wasn't even that long ago that newspapers and TV were pe
by ravenstine 8y ago
Not only that, but we really don't need journalists in the traditional sense as much as we used to. It wasn't even that long ago that newspapers and TV were people's eyes and ears. Now anyone with a phone can record video of events as they happen, and anyone with a YouTube channel can report on the news and make political commentary for a mere fraction of the overhead that media firms operate on.
This isn't to say that there isn't value in traditional journalism, and I think the viability of member-supported radio is a testament to that. But the old guard of for-profit journalism is obsolete, and it's quickening its own death by going hog-wild with unverified sources, hit pieces, and lack of fact checking.
- ameister14 8y agoI actually think we need curation a great deal nowadays - there is definitely a market for it, if nothing else. The massive amount of chaff 'content' is hard to wade through. Your second paragraph is dead on, though.
- reaperducer 8y agowe really don't need journalists in the traditional sense as much as we used to Are you under the impression that government corruption and injustice are things of the past? Now anyone with a phone can record video of events as they happen, and anyone with a YouTube channel can report on the news and make political commentary for a mere fraction of the overhead that media firms operate on. Except that we live in a world of deepfakes, astroturfing, and a dozen other reasons not to trust what is posted on the internet by any random person. And building on my comment above, Random Joe isn't going to spend tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars investigating illegal arms sales, contract fraud, or hundreds of other things that big journalism companies do routinely. member-supported radio is a testament to that Member-supported radio doesn't cover 1/1000th of what local newspapers do. I think you may not understand the value of professional journalism, past and present, perhaps because you haven't been exposed to it, or its consequences.
- ravenstine 8y ago> Are you under the impression that government corruption and injustice are things of the past? Oh, come now. > Except that we live in a world of deepfakes, astroturfing, and a dozen other reasons not to trust what is posted on the internet by any random person. And professional journalists are going to be immune to these things? A lot of the time, journalists actually repost what they see on Twitter and YouTube. I suppose that in an ideal world journalists would wise up in the face of deep fakes and trust their various sources a lot less, but caution != profit. > And building on my comment above, Random Joe isn't going to spend tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars investigating illegal arms sales, contract fraud, or hundreds of other things that big journalism companies do routinely. I don't agree that you need Big Journalism for that job to be done. Individuals in the press who are outside Big Journalism, as you put it, can do the same job independently and for a fraction of the cost. > Member-supported radio doesn't cover 1/1000th of what local newspapers do. Sure, local newspapers have an edge over public radio, but you can also use that same argument against Big Journalism, which despite its resources can't do the same job that local newspapers do. > I think you may not understand the value of professional journalism, past and present, perhaps because you haven't been exposed to it, or its consequences. That's not a fair assessment at all.
- droopyEyelids 8y agoTo me, this reads like someone saying "You don't need graphs if you have the raw data" Journalists, in their true form, turn data into information. That is more important than ever in our context free world of video snippets and misleading quotes.
- ravenstine 8y agoI do agree that we need raw data. Sadly, we're not getting enough of it, and part of the cause is the speed of the news cycle; it's far more expedient for someone to write prose than spend the time gathering raw data, making sense of it, and distilling that data into graphs.
- jvagner 8y agomy latest theory is that people like participating in the news cycle more than they are inclined to consume it. click-bait and fake news lets people instantly rage / share, where as good journalism would be valuable to people who want to pause, comprehend and have an outlet that isn't just sharing, raging, etc. which is probably why even big brand journalism hasn't really changed. the list of outlets that i block on twitter and apple news (the latest of which is forbes, for yet another installment in their "latest iPhone update has a NASTY SURPRISE" articles) grows weekly, but i can't get out of the clickbait content tsunami.
- ravenstine 8y ago> my latest theory is that people like participating in the news cycle more than they are inclined to consume it. That's an interesting observation. It seems like how most people who watch sports have little to no interest in playing themselves, even recreationally, but they "join" a team because of the sense of participation they get. Not sure if that's the best analogy, but it's reminiscent for me.
- thrusong 8y agoIn a world where everyone has a video camera in their pocket and AI can generate deep fakes, maybe we'll come full circle to where traditional gatekeepers are needed once again to verify the accuracy of the information out there.