6 ms·
There's a lot of woo in that article. Yes, Parmesan is made to strict rules; no, i probably couldn't tell it from Grana Padano if i was blindfolded. And there'
by twic 8y ago
There's a lot of woo in that article. Yes, Parmesan is made to strict rules; no, i probably couldn't tell it from Grana Padano if i was blindfolded.
And there's an effort from Wisconsin that is apparently very good:
https://www.thekitchn.com/a-morethanworthy-replacement-f-132465 https://www.thekitchn.com/a-morethanworthy-replacement-f-132...
- pacbard 8y agoAs someone who grew up in the Parmigiano Reggiano production zone and whose family is member of a Parmigiano co-op, I can tell you that it is possible to taste the difference between Parmigiano, grana padano, and the parmesan clones. It boils down to what you use the cheese for. If you just want to grate it on some pasta, you can use whatever. If you are making tortellini, you better use the 36-month cheese from your casaro (cheese maker). Edit: Compare the picture of the cheese you link to this one: http://www.caseificioboiardo.it/en/eshop/parmigiano-reggiano-12-months/ http://www.caseificioboiardo.it/en/eshop/parmigiano-reggiano... You can notice right away that the cheese has a different consistency. The American clone is smoother (it looks almost like plastic). The 12-month Parmigiano Reggiano (the youngest "age" that the cheese can be sold as PR) is textured. That signals that the amount of moisture in the American clone is off and that will effect the aging of the cheese and ultimately its taste.
- m000 8y agoSince you seem to have a first-hand perspective on the production of Parmigiano Reggiano, would you care to comment on the claims of CIWF [1,2] about animal welfare in the region? The situation they describe is quite the opposite of the idyllic pictures in the BBC article. Is the kind of abuse described by CIWF on the rise? Is it specific farms that engage in it? Does the co-op take any measures against them? Can they lose their PDO seal for such abuses? [1] https://www.ciwf.org.uk/news/2017/11/the-cruel-truth-behind-parmesan-that-is-hard-to-stomach https://www.ciwf.org.uk/news/2017/11/the-cruel-truth-behind-... [2] https://www.ciwf.org.uk/philip-lymbery/blog/2017/11/hard-cheese-hard-life https://www.ciwf.org.uk/philip-lymbery/blog/2017/11/hard-che...
- pacbard 8y agoIn my experience, I have never seen or heard of anyone grazing their milk cows. I also haven't seen cows being abused or underweight (I don't think that an underweight milk cow would produce much milk, so that wouldn't make sense). Generally, cows are kept in barns and are usually tied to a rail. This is what I have in mind: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YZij6ZpBwSo&t=3m12s http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YZij6ZpBwSo&t=3m12s or this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ili9d4OmURk&t=1m3s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ili9d4OmURk&t=1m3s As far as I know, cows have been traditionally kept like that, as old barns have a similar set up. It looks like ciwf is advocating for milk cows to be grazing. I don't think that it is feasible given the current economic and geographical limitations of the Parmiginao Reggiano production zone. Economically, making cheese is barely profitable, with most farmers just making it. Most of the cheese is sold in bulk to wholesalers in the form of "futures". They buy the whole production for a year (for example) before the cheese is ready. That allows the cheese maker to pay the farmers in advance but that also makes it so they can't demand much for the cheese. The other option is to wait and try to sell it directly but they run the risk of not selling the whole stock (also, consider that the cheese as a very short shelf life, as once a cheese form is open it needs to be sold). Geographically, there isn't really much space for grazing cows. The pianura padana is probably one of the most densely populated areas in Italy. Plus, it is also where most Italian industry is located. I don't think it would be possible to find enough space for all the cows even if it were economically viable.
- emptyfile 8y ago>no, i probably couldn't tell it from Grana Padano if i was blindfolded. Maybe you lack a sense of smell? Seriously you don't even have to put it in your mouth it already smells quite different... I buy the cheapest imported stuff here in eastern europe and the difference is...well they're two different types of cheese. They just taste different.
- wenc 8y agoI don't eat cheese regularly and I can taste the difference between Parmigianno Reggiano and Grana Padano when I eat them as-is (not when shaved in a pasta though -- it's harder when it's in a pasta, which is why GP is often used as a cheaper substitute for PR). Otherwise PR tastes much "nuttier" owing to glumates, which is also one of its standout characteristics. There's another cheese, Pecorino Romano, that's distinctly salty and really good on Carbonara.
- kevingrahl 8y agoPecorino Romano is my favorite cheese! It’s flavor is more subtle than that of Parmaggiano Reggiano and it lacks some of the bitter notes which makes it excellent for Carbonara as you said. But I think it’s perfect for tomato based pasta sauces as well as most tomato’s are quite high in acidity save a few lesser known varieties like San Marzano for example. PR definitely has its place but I tend to only use it for foods that aren’t acidic themself. Broccoli or brussel sprouts and PR are a great combo for instance!
- klmr 8y ago> no, i probably couldn't tell it from Grana Padano if i was blindfolded. I can — they are quite different cheeses. Apart from the different taste and texture (Grana Padano has reliably less taste, and is dryer and more crumbly), I am extremely allergic to Grana Padano: after eating even a tiny piece my throat will swell up and slowly constrict (not life threatening, I think, but definitely uncomfortable). Parmigiano Reggiano doesn’t elicit the same reaction. It’s a very reliable, albeit unpractical, way of telling the two apart. Either way, this indicates that they are distinct on a fundamental level. (Just to clarify: this allergy obviously isn’t specific to Grana Padano, it affects plenty of other dairy products. And, as far as I can tell, seems to be against some by-product of the fermentation that is only present in some dairy products and not others.)
- basch 8y agoThis cheese they make is one I like http://www.sartoricheese.com/our-cheese/reserve-cheese/montamore.html http://www.sartoricheese.com/our-cheese/reserve-cheese/monta... "Is it Cheddar that tastes like Parmesan or Parmesan that tastes like Cheddar? Even though it's indescribable, we know you'll fall in love with this creamy, white wonder."