3 ms·
This is a bit of a silly statement, as it's grossly misleading. Firstly, in the very strictest sense it isn't true, given that defects in operating systems and
by InclinedPlane 16y ago
This is a bit of a silly statement, as it's grossly misleading. Firstly, in the very strictest sense it isn't true, given that defects in operating systems and processors and single event upsets due to cosmic rays can introduce some degree of randomness into computer processing. Secondly though, even ignoring all of that, it's not helpful. It's a bit like telling a chemist "remember, the chemicals will always do exactly what you tell them to." Well, sure, that's true in the abstract, but the full complexity of the entire process is greater than any human mind can cope with, so it's necessary to use models and techniques that bring that complexity down to human scale. The same goes for the full breadth of the complexity of programming significant pieces of software today.
The computer will do exactly what you tell it to, but your brain is not capable of determining exactly what the computer will do (it'll process billions of instructions a second, if you tried to fully map out the operations of a computer in complete detail you wouldn't get even a fraction of a second done in your lifetime). Which is why we have to use abstractions, models, and various techniques to render that complexity manageable by human minds.
- olalonde 16y agoDown voted for lacking a sense of humour. Seriously, why did you feel the need to explain at large that computers are deterministic when OP was clearly making a joke. (I know I'm probably going to get down voted myself but I had to vent off)
- petercooper 16y agoHaving read the post you voted down, I don't think he/she was actually responding to my joke but to the concept I was quoting. He/she seems to be arguing against computers being entirely deterministic at all. I wish there were a better/more formal way to quote things on HN as it can lead to confusion with attribution. Purely italic text doesn't quite cut it, but nor does the "source code" quoting feature.